Scalloped Hammerhead shark (Sphyrna lewini) The wide-set eyes give hammerheads long visual range, better than most sharks. Image CC-BY Kris-Mikael Krister
Nature can sometimes surprise us. Some things are obvious. Whales and dolphins hold their breath when they dive – as air-breathing mammals they would drown if they didn’t. Some things are unexpected. Grey seals breathe out before they dive, to avoid some of the trickier physiological issues they would otherwise face at depth. And some things provoke a straight ‘wait, what?!’ reaction, such as the shark that holds its breath when it dives. Why would a shark – a fish that breathes underwater – hold its breath? It turns out that oxygen is not the only resource that needs conserving when an animal dives deeper into the ocean: heat also matters.
The scalloped hammerhead shark (Sphyrna lewini) lives in tropical and warm temperate waters, the sort of waters where jumping in doesn’t immediately result in the rapid gasping breath of cold shock and a desire to climb back out again. This shark is an ectotherm, which means its main source of body heat comes from the environment. Some ectotherms, like the ocean sunfish, can divert blood flow to keep particular muscles and organs warm while leaving other areas to cool, similar to how our fingers might go cold when outside on a winter’s day. Others, like the leatherback turtle generate heat with their muscles, visiting colder areas outside the range of other turtles. But none of these tricks are available to our scalloped hammerhead, and the structure of the gills that make it so good for the exchange of oxygen and carbon dioxide – a large surface area, and seawater and bloodstream in close proximity – also make it exceptionally good for the transfer of heat from shark to water. The gills work like a radiator, potentially to the disadvantage of the shark because its prey lives far below it in much colder water. Researchers at the University of Hawai’i at Manoa tagged ten sharks and recorded 106 dives using a set of instruments to measure depth, water temperature, the activity and orientation of the shark, and its core muscle temperature. They were interested in seeing how the shark might deal with the thermal challenges of hunting in water of only five or six degrees centigrade.
So, let’s pick a shark and follow them on a typical dive to see what they do. Our shark starts near the surface. It’s night; the water temperature is 26oC. They start to swim down, a gentle descent at a shallow angle, like a submarine nudging down to a greater depth. When they reach a depth of perhaps 110 metres their orientation changes. They turn steeply downwards, hold their breath and descend. They swim faster and the temperature drops by as much as 20oC in five or six minutes until the shark, now at a depth of more than 600 metres, levels off and starts to hunt. The tracking data shows short sprints as the shark searches for squid in the darkness. Time is limited. Four minutes later, the shark turns sharply upwards, swimming strongly in a mirror of its descent path. At around a depth of 290 metres the shark slows and turns closer to the horizontal as it makes a steady approach towards the surface waters, recovering.
The researchers called this change in angle on the ascent the inflection point. It is here that a drop in muscle temperature was recorded: the shark, still in relatively cooler waters, has taken a breath, the need for oxygen outweighing the need to conserve heat. The dive has lasted almost an hour, and the shark has held its breath for 17 minutes of that time. So how does a shark do it? One way would be to divert blood away from the gills reducing oxygen intake as well as heat loss, but examination of dead sharks accidentally caught by fishermen didn’t show any evidence of that. A second way would be to close the gill slits to stop water flow over the gills. Scalloped hammerheads have been filmed swimming with their gill slits tightly closed at deeper depths than in this study, so it seems likely that this is the technique they use. So, a shark that holds its breath. Not what you may have been expecting. Let’s leave the last word to Mark Royer, the lead author on the paper: “This was a complete surprise! It is an extraordinary behaviour from an incredible animal.”
Antarctic Minke Whale. CC-BY Ari Friedlaender, Oregon State University
It’s a stunning sight: a humpback whale breaks through the ocean surface, mouth agape to engulf tonnes of water and the prey it contains. But why are whales the size that they are? How they feed seems to be the key.
Whales and dolphins are all cetaceans, and the cetaceans are divided into two groups. Unhelpfully, the two groups are not ‘whales’ and ‘dolphins’. For example, Killer Whales, more correctly called Orca, are actually large dolphins. The first group includes the rare and elusive beaked whales, the sperm whale, and all the dolphins and porpoises. This group is the odontoceti, the toothed whales. The second group are the baleen whales, sometimes called the ‘whalebone’ whales, named for the baleen plates in their mouths that are made of keratin, the same biological material that hair and fingernails contain. Scientists call this group the mysticeti.
There seems to be a critical size for whales that determines how they feed. Below a certain size they feed on individual prey items, like fish or squid, one at a time. Orca, the largest dolphin species, include seals in their diet. This feeding strategy is typical of the toothed whales, often using sound – biological sonar – to locate, track and then target their prey for capture.
Above this critical size baleen whales feed on shoals of smaller prey items, taking many at one time. Some baleen whales feed simply by opening their mouths and swimming forward through clouds of their prey, a method called ram-feeding. Bowhead whales, found only in Arctic and sub-Arctic waters, feed in this way. It’s a technique adopted by non-cetaceans, too. The two largest fish species in the world are both filter-feeding sharks: the basking shark and the whale shark.
The Rorquals are a sub-group within the baleen whales, and includes the humpback and the blue whale. They have what look like ‘lines’ running parallel to their lower jaw. Rorquals are the gulp- or lunge-feeders. They accelerate towards a shoal of prey and open their mouths. The ‘lines’ are actually folds of skin that allow the throat to expand to enclose a huge volume of water and the prey within it. It’s effective, but costs a lot of energy.
There is also a difference in size as well as feeding strategy between the two main groups. The baleen whales are big, the toothed whales generally much smaller, with one exception: the sperm whale. The sperm whale is a large toothed whale that dives to feed on single prey items, like giant squid, that live deep in the ocean. Why is it the exception? Scientists think that in this case, the large body size means that they have a more powerful biosonar to detect their prey in the darkness of the deep.
The blue whale, a Rorqual, is the largest animal to have ever lived, but what about a minimum size? Why are there no lunge-feeding whales the size of a common dolphin? Like a roller coaster, is there a biological equivalent of ‘you have to be this big to take this ride’? An international team of researchers from the USA and Australia think that the answer is yes, and that Minke whales are the smallest species that could feed in this way. “Minke whales are right at the threshold” says lead author David Cade “Anything smaller than a Minke could not achieve the foraging rates necessary to survive.”
All animals have an energy budget: to live, they have to take in more energy than they spend. How much energy a whale takes in depends on how often they feed when they dive, and how much prey they capture with each feeding attempt. Antarctic Minke whales feed on krill. The researchers tagged 23 Minke whales during 2018 and 2019, measuring how deep and how often they fed, and compared it to the feeding behaviour of blue and humpback whales, who also feed on krill. The bigger the whale the more water and krill it can engulf, not just in terms of the total volume, but also in relation to their body size. A blue whale can engulf water equivalent to around 135% of its body mass, while a Minke whale can only engulf water equivalent to 42% of its body mass. For Rorquals – these lunge-feeding whales – bigger is better it would seem.
Krill spend their days at depth to avoid predators and then migrate towards surface waters at night. A whale will need to dive deep to feed during the day, and while Minkes dive to the same depths as blues, their smaller size means that they feed less effectively. To compensate for this, their feeding rates are much higher, and they can lunge-feed sometimes as often as every fifteen seconds. All of the Rorquals are thought to have evolved from a Minke-sized common ancestor, and once lunge-feeding had developed as a feeding technique a larger size meant more efficient feeding. Evolution did the rest, resulting in the variety of larger whale species we see in our ocean today.
But there are limits to this evolutionary tendency of ‘big is better’. The larger an animal the more food it needs each day for its energy budget to remain in credit: large predators need lots of prey. But prey populations also need to be large enough so that they themselves can survive and reproduce, despite their losses to their leviathan predators. And these prey species also need to feed, which means that the populations of what they consume – their prey – would also need to be larger.
Energy is the currency that all living things depend on, and there are critical points at both ends of the size scale. For large whales, there comes a point at which becoming bigger is not an advantage, when more energy is expended for no increase in the amount of prey captured because there is only so much prey available. Any larger, and prey populations are too small for the whales to prosper. At the other end of the scale, the energy budget of the Minke whales is just above the break-even point, just in profit. Any smaller as an adult and it would not be able to lunge-feed often enough and catch enough prey to make up for the energy spent in feeding. It’s energy budget would be in debt, and running at a loss, and no animal can survive that for long.
A humpback whale breaks through the surface, mouth wide, the skin of its throat bulging, while a few lucky herring make the leap from mouth back to ocean. It is both spectacular and energetically costly. But there are reasons behind why these animals are this size, and why they behave and feed in the way that they do.
An image of Britain and Ireland taken by the Sentinel 3 satellite, part of the Copernicus programme. Contains modified Copernicus Sentinel data 2017, CC BY-SA 3.0 IGO via Wikimedia Commons
‘Wild isles’, presented by David Attenborough, is being broadcast on the BBC in March and April 2023. In contrast to his other work, this series turns away from the wider world to take a deeper look at the wildlife of Britain and Ireland. This blog, although with an emphasis more on what is in and beneath the waters around these wild isles, also has the same focus. So why do I concentrate on the local, when there is so much beauty, so much wonder elsewhere in nature? Let’s start with what the reason is not. It is not nationalism, with its unthinking pride in country and blindness to its flaws. Neither is it exceptionalism, the view that one’s own country is somehow better or more special than any other. The UK is exceptional, but not in a positive way for nature: it is one of the world’s most nature-depleted countries. It is also one of the least wooded countries in Europe, with just over 13% of woodland cover in the UK compared to over 40% for Europe as a whole. And the scale of sewage discharges into water courses simply beggars belief, with one blue flag beach in Devon (Blackpool sands) having sixty-three sewage spills totalling over more than one thousand hours in 2022.
So why the local focus? Put simply, it is my home. It is where I live. It is also what I have access to. With the exception of going to the EMSEA conference on Crete in 2015 I haven’t flown since 1988, when my last flights were as a young soldier on the plains of Germany practising loading and unloading drills from a Sea King helicopter, soaked by rain accelerated like bullets by the downdraft of the blades. I visited a dive show a few years ago, and was shocked by just how many companies were offering ‘liveaboard’ holidays in tropical locations: the Maldives, the Seychelles, Egypt, Mexico, the Galapagos islands. But how were they to get there? Ocean warming and ocean acidification are the two biggest threats to tropical reefs, and long haul flights are one of the most polluting ways to travel. Anyone taking these trips may as well have packed a hammer in their luggage to smash the reefs once they got there. I have never seen a coral reef in person, the experience kept at a distance and mediated through photographs and television. I may never see one, but by not flying, by bearing witness to the problems that the natural world – including us – face and how they may be solved, my grandson may yet have the opportunity to do so.
There are wonders in our waters, despite our nature-depleted status. We have basking shark, the second largest fish in the world. We have leatherback turtles as summer visitors, along with sunfish. We have grey seals, common around our coast with 95% of the European population and 40% of the world population residing in our waters. At smaller scales we have nudibranchs such as the violet sea slug, the orange-clubbed sea slug, and molluscs such as the blue-rayed limpet, hunkered down in their pits in the stalks of kelp. With all these jewels their small size allows them to be overlooked.
I have my own treasured moments immersed in nature in the UK; moments that hang in the memory like Christmas tree lights sparkling in the darkness of a winter night. Harlyn Beach in Cornwall, newly married and picnicking with my wife and young children on Wednesday 11th August 1999, the temperature falling and the sky darkening towards eclipse. Just after 11am, a fire juggler emerged to light what would have been the brief window of totality, had not the cloud cover conspired to hide the eclipsing sun. Diving the wreck of the James Eagan Layne, a World War two liberty ship and swimming along the bottom of what would have been the hold, the ribs curving up either side, stripped bare of hull plates long ago corroded to rust, the ribs enclosing me as if in a cathedral, with shoals of pollack and a solitary cuckoo wrasse as congregation. Or the squeal of discovery, wide-eyed with a broad grin and gesticulating towards the spot on finding a badger sett when walking with one of my daughters in the local woods; a response sometimes parodied back to me when she wants to show her excitement over something.
‘Wild isles’ has five episodes broadcast on TV, starting with the first ‘our precious isles’, followed by episodes on woodlands, grasslands, freshwater and ocean. There is, controversially, a sixth episode of ‘wild isles’ called ‘saving our wild isles’ released online through the BBC’s iPlayer service. The controversy arose because it was wrongly reported that this sixth episode had been pulled from broadcast and relegated to an online only presentation. The allegation was that the episode with its emphasis on the state of nature and the work needed to restore it was too political a message, provoking as it might the question ‘who’s fault is this?’. The BBC said that this was not the case and the episode had always been planned for an online-only delivery. This, I think, is a lost opportunity. I have written before about how important our relationship to nature is, both for ourselves, and for motivating action to protect it; we protect what we know and love, springing to its defence when it is threatened. A programme that shows both the threats and how to respond positively to them would be a powerful call to action.
Citizenship – the status of belonging to a country – goes beyond what is written on a birth certificate or passport. Surely being a good citizen involves more than blind acceptance of how things are now. It involves pointing out where the faults and failings lie; it is, in fact, a disservice to our home – country and planet – not to do so. For if we do not say ‘this is wrong: this should not stand’ are we not then complicit in the damage being done? And that brings us to the key question: do we want to be responsible for perpetuating the problem or responsible for solving it? We all make a choice. We all get to live with the consequences, good or bad, of that choice. So we must choose wisely.
If you’re not in the UK, then search for organisations in your area. What can you do to preserve the natural world local to you? Research for one or two actions you can take that will make a difference. Systemic change is needed (e.g. no new fossil fuel extraction), but individual actions are also important.
Experience it. Get outside and feel the rain on your face or the wind in your hair. Watch a bee harvesting pollen from a flower or a squirrel foraging in woodland. Listen to the birds or the whisper of surf across shingle. Breathe it in. Breathe.
We all leave footprints on our Earth through our choices and actions. The consequences of these depend on where and how heavily we tread, and this remains true for the many ways we have to prospect for and extract energy from the ocean. We have tidal lagoons to impound the tides, tapping their energy as the water is released back to the sea. We have tidal turbines to intercept the flow of water caused by the rising and falling of the tide. Some turbines sit on the seabed while others float tethered just below the surface. Wind blows across the water, two fluids in physics terms, and friction between the two rucks the water into waves. Towers hold rotors aloft to catch the wind, while wave energy converters bob and the waves pay a toll of energy as they pass. This mix of technologies has a variety of impacts on different parts of the natural world. The scientists working to tease out the details of this complexity will talk of stressors and receptors: the processes that cause the impacts, and the things that they impact upon.
The stressors include noise, collision, displacement, the risk of entanglement and the emission of electromagnetic fields from the cables as they carry the electricity ashore. The receptors, the things that these stressors impact upon, are both biological and inanimate. The biological receptors run through the whole size range, from the large, the marine mammals such as whales, dolphins and seals, though to more moderately-sized animals such as fishes and seabirds, and then to the small, the neglected, the overlooked: invertebrates such as limpets, mussels and anemones. The non-living but no less important receptors are the physical environment, and the oceanographic processes that shape it. Lastly, there is the human dimension to this. As these developments are built, as these stressors interact and work to re-model habitats and ecosystems, who will be the winners and losers? Which communities will prosper, and which be left behind, with only the old ones to speak of the glory days long past?
The ocean is not silent; it whispers with the splash of surf, speaks with the whistles of hunting porpoise, and sings a chorus of whale song. But within this concert of melodies there is disharmony: the tinnitus of shipping noise, the shrieks of sonar, and the percussive detonation of seismic surveys for oil and gas. Added to this are the notes of new instruments. Wind and tidal turbines turn fluid flow into the rotation of blades and generators, and the noise of these transmits to the water; noise that may then act to exclude and displace, especially for those that hunt with sound.
Tides flood and ebb; the currents slow, pause and then reverse their direction. As the current builds its momentum again life is drawn here. The motion of the water can concentrate plankton and the creatures that feed on it, and with those the creatures that feed on them. Place tidal turbines here and predators are not the only hazard to be navigated. Collision with the moving blades becomes a real possibility. Some seabirds are only attracted when the current reaches the ‘Goldilocks’ zone: not too slow, not too fast, when their prey is gathered but before the water is too turbulent for them to hunt. Some, like Razorbills, prefer shallower water near the surface, feeding mostly in the top ten metres. Others, like Black Guillemots, forage close to the seabed. Making the choice between surface- and seabed-mounted turbines and the current speed at which they start to generate can make a big difference to the risks for those they share the water with.
Moving water has kinetic energy; it carries this energy along with sediment, nutrients, plastic litter and pollution. For waves, it is different: the energy travels much faster than the water, which loops almost in place, taking tiny steps forward as the energy races ahead. Tidal turbines and wave energy converters extract a portion of this energy for our use, which leaves a tidal flow less capable of transporting its load, leaves a wave train weaker. Slow the flow of a tidal current and the heaviest particles can no longer be carried and will settle out. It’s not that simple though. The flow downstream of a seabed-mounted turbine can be tumbling and turbulent, a by-product of passing through the rotating blades; this water may actually pick up sediment from the seabed and transport it away from the site.
Perhaps an unexpected stressor, an unthought of impact, comes from the transmission of the electricity to shore, where it joins the national grid and is forwarded to where it is needed. Cables from individual turbines often connect umbilical-like to a central hub, from which the main cable runs to shore. The cable may be buried, or covered in rock ‘armour’, for good reason: without this, the nets of fishing boats could snag the cable, potentially lethal for the crew, and potentially an expensive disruption of supply for the generating company. But cables produce electro-magnetic fields (EMFs). Despite their burial, they can still interfere with the lives of the living things that stray within their range. There is something of the ‘chicken and egg’ with EMFs. Earlier developments assumed the effects to be negligible. Now, as we try to determine if that is true or if we should be concerned about EMFs, we find we have a scarcity of existing data on which to base our conclusions. As a result, these fields and their potential impacts are receiving renewed attention from the research community.
Both offshore wind and tidal stream developments provide new territory to colonize for those creatures unable to live on the prairies of soft sediment that surround them. As succession proceeds the first arrivals are joined by others; communities form, an interacting web of producers, predators and prey. Fish come together to use the space, the structures providing the opportunity of refuge unlike the open water that leaves no place to hide; refuge from predators both natural and human. As each nation strives to reach their net zero targets, ramping up their production of offshore energy, these islands of solidity become more abundant, allowing organisms to ‘island hop’ across habitats that would otherwise impede their spread. As climate change makes its impacts felt, this could allow non-native or invasive species to spread. It could also provide escape routes for some species to spread to cooler waters, nature’s own climate refugees. The CHASANS project is looking at the connectivity of habitats in the North Sea, trying to quantify the implications and consequences of adding these structures to the ocean.
We are all part of nature, not separate from it, but our perspective is, naturally, to consider the human dimensions. We are both stressor and receptor. Our actions cause impacts and changes in the ocean, and these affect us in return, although the groups that cause the stress and the groups that receive it are frequently not the same. Reconciling the interactions and intersections between the different groups is difficult. There are no easy choices or answers, no quick fixes, just the messy complications of sometimes flawed systems and people trying to reach a compromise. It is vitally important that any solution should be a just one – that any solution should not, as far as possible, unfairly disadvantage one group or sector of society.
An obvious assumption is that the areas set aside for energy developments are not available for other uses, but this may not necessarily be the case. It’s very likely that certain types of fishing would be excluded: few fishers would risk trawling these areas with the financial consequence of losing gear or liability for damage to the infrastructure of the site. But other types of fishing may be possible. Trials have already taken place at the Heywind site off the north east coast of Scotland, looking into the use of static gear such as pots and creels. Other activities in addition to some forms of fishing could also share the sites, a practice known as co-location. Shellfish aquaculture, or seaweed farming with its multitude of uses from pharmaceuticals to food and the potential for carbon sequestration, could share the space. It does depend, however, on the type of energy development, and what the co-located activity is. Some will be compatible, while others will conflict. Seaweed aquaculture, concentrated in the more brightly lit surface waters could work well with offshore wind, but less well with tidal stream or wave energy converters, where it might potentially dissipate the energy of the waves or tidal current. Co-location has great potential, but more research is needed to make it a reality.
Just because these areas might not be available for fishing doesn’t automatically mean that it’s all bad news for the fishers. Dr. Ruth Thurstan and her colleagues published research in 2010 that looked at the historical catch records for demersal (bottom-living) species in the North Sea dating back to 1889. They found that many fish stocks had fallen by more than 90% between then and the present day. This means a modern trawler, with its complement of diesel engine, electronic fish finders and powered winches, has to expend seventeen times more effort to catch the same amount of demersal fish as a sail-powered trawler in the 1880s. It is entirely possible to reduce the area available to fishing through designating areas for conservation and renewable energy, and yet have larger fish stocks available to catch. It does not have to be a zero sum game. These areas can act as refuges from fishing pressure allowing populations to increase, and fish from these areas to ‘spillover’ into areas where they may be fished; such spillover effects are well documented in other marine protected areas around the world. But there remains the critical issue of timing: how long between the loss of fishing area and the increase in stocks, and how can the fishing industry be supported in this transition?
Climate change adds another human dimension, one in which we are both stressor and receptor. It is through our gaseous emissions, our collective societal belching of carbon dioxide and methane, that stress the ocean through increasing heat and acidification. Rising sea-levels and an increasing frequency and ferocity of storms driven by a warmer ocean are the results of that stressor. Harvesting the different forms of marine renewable energy offers us a way to address climate change, reducing the causes and impacts together, but we must be mindful of the impacts of the harvesting itself. It is a balance, like all things in nature. It is a balance that we must get right.
This was my (unsuccessful) application for the Save Our Seas Foundation Ocean Storytelling Writing Grant, submitted at the end of November 2022. Congratulations to the three winners, and looking forward to reading their work.
Thirty metres underwater in the inner sound of the Pentland Firth a harbour seal searches for a meal of sandeels. Nearer the surface razorbills row themselves through the water looking for herring. An unimaginable mass of water squeezes between the Orkney islands and the north coast of Scotland, moving between the Atlantic and the North Sea and back again. Here, the speed and turbulence of the water attracts all partners in the dance between predator and prey, but they are not alone in their interest. Here, people and nature are brought together by the surges and eddies of tidal waters. For the animals, to feed themselves; for us, to feed our society’s hunger for energy.
The Pentland Firth sits at the very north-eastern tip of the mainland UK where two islands, Stroma and Swona, squat like stepping stones between the mainland and the Orkney islands. On the seabed about halfway from the mainland to Stroma lies phase I of the MeyGEN tidal energy project. Scotland has a rich potential for wave and tidal energy, the result of having around sixteen and a half thousand kilometres of coastline and many narrow channels to funnel the tide on its daily rise and ebb. That, and the powerful Atlantic swells that roll on to the west coast unhindered by any intervening land masses. The four turbines of phase one became operational in April 2018, with a capacity of six million watts (6 MW), enough to provide the electricity for 2,600 homes. Phase one is the demonstration phase. Phase two, already approved, is for an array of turbines providing 80 MW. A third phase would expand the array further to a capacity of almost 400 MW.
But everything has an impact: nothing is without environmental consequences, of which the risk of collision is one. The blades of the turbines in phase one are eighteen metres in diameter, the slowest of the two types turning eight times a minute at full power, giving the blade tip a speed of around seven and a half metres per second. The result of a spinning blade hitting a seal is not likely to end in the seal’s favour.
The ocean is far from quiet, and turbines add yet another instrument to the orchestra of man-made sounds. The turbines themselves emit noise from the movement of their components: gears, bearings and generators, but also from the tumbling chaos of the water as it leaves the spinning blades. Noise can exclude. Noise can displace. Those species that hunt or sense their surroundings through sound are particularly vulnerable. Dolphins, harbour porpoise and Orca have all been seen in the waters of the Pentland Firth.
A third, more unusual, potential impact could easily be overlooked. The turbines feed their power to a hub on the seabed, and from there a cable brings the power ashore. These cables generate electro-magnetic fields. Some animals, such as sharks, can detect the minute electric fields from their prey. Others, such as eels, sense magnetic fields to navigate. What effect would the cables have on these animals?
Doug Gillespie, Gordon Hastie and Joe Onouifrou, researchers from the Sea Mammal Research Unit at the University of St. Andrews, are working to assess some of these impacts. Harbour seals were tagged with GPS transmitters and their movements followed to answer two questions: did the seals change their behaviour when the turbines were installed, and do they behave differently when the turbines are turning? The tag data told the story. The presence of the turbines made no difference, no more than any other underwater obstacle. With the turbines turning the seals started to avoid the area, with a fall in numbers of almost thirty per cent within two kilometres of the turbines. The most likely cause, based on seal behaviour elsewhere in the world, is noise. That still leaves the majority of seals continuing to use the area, still risking a fatal interaction with the turbine blades. But how do the animals behave around the turbines? How do we ‘see’ their behaviour in murky, fast-flowing water thirty metres below the surface? The researchers have the answer: HiCUP, or High Current Underwater Platform. This package of scientific instruments has hydrophones to record the clicks and whistles of whales and dolphins, a technique called passive acoustic monitoring or PAM. But hydrophones only detect those species that make sounds, and many species do not, or at least too rarely to be useful for reliable detection; seals rarely vocalise. For these animals a different approach is needed: HiCUP has two multibeam sonars. One sonar alone will give you position on a horizontal plane. Add a second, its beam slightly offset vertically, and you gain some idea of the depth of the returning echo. HiCUP sends its data ashore but the quantities are huge, much too large for email or online storage, so the hard disks are sent back to the researchers by courier. And then, this mass of data needs to be analysed. Is this echo a seal or a shark? A cormorant or a razorbill? For now, deciphering these echoes still needs human expertise, but the researchers are developing software tools to automate this, much needed if we are to meaningfully process and analyse the data from multiple sites. And with better analysis of data we gain a better understanding of risk.
This is one tidal energy site. We will need many more, along with their above surface brethren of offshore wind if we are to reduce carbon dioxide emissions, reduce the exhaust of our addiction to fossil fuels. The exhaust that warms the atmosphere and then the ocean, raises sea levels and alters oceanic chemistry. We are inextricably linked to the ocean, and we can (and must) provide for our needs without degrading the ocean’s provision for its own. The story of the ocean is our story, its future ours.
The sand glistens. Footprints mar its surface, their ridges and troughs a photographic negative of the sole that made them. A wave arrives on the beach, hissing the last of its momentum to blur and level the footprints before falling back to be replaced by another. The tide rises and falls; the reliable ticking of a planetary clock. In one sense, the movement of the tides is an illusion. We see the solidity of the land and the fluidity of the water, and assume we know the nature of the movement between the two. But we would be wrong. A combination of gravitational attraction and planetary motion produces two bulges of water on opposite sides of the world, beneath which the land moves as the Earth rotates while the bulges slop and surge around it.
Everything has an impact. Everything we do leaves a mark. Step as lightly on the Earth as we can and still we leave footprints as an inevitable trace of our having passed that way. One of our deepest footprints is the carbon dioxide our civilisation exhales into the atmosphere. Massing like an invading army on the border, its capacity to damage and devastate is growing. The quantity rises and falls with the passing of the seasons, but the fall in winter never quite reaches the previous starting point and so the concentration sawtooths ever upwards.
Our society stands on a foundation of easily available energy. It fuels our transportation, enables our communications, powers our entertainments. With the possible exception of air travel, electricity could substitute for our other uses of energy, but its impact depends on the methods we use to generate it. This is where the ocean, with the rise and fall of the tide, offers us the chance to tread more gently on the Earth.
Energy from the tides has a long history. In Milford Haven the Carew Tidal Mill, built around 1801, trapped the tide to grind flour, but technology rarely remains static, evolving and morphing into something new. In Brittany, France the estuary of the river Rance is enclosed by a tidal barrage, generating electricity since it first went into operation in 1966. Strange then, that power from the tides should be such a novel idea in the UK, since the UK has the second highest tidal range in the world, second only to Canada.
But how to harness the power from these immense movements of water? Swansea Bay, South Wales, between where the river Tawe and the river Neath meet the waters of the Bristol Channel, is the site for a proposed tidal lagoon. The Blue Eden project, once built, will have a sea wall almost nine and a half kilometres long and enclose nearly twelve square kilometres of water at high tide. It will have the capacity to generate 320 million Watts of power (320 MW), enough to meet the energy demands of 155,000 homes. This project, costing £1.7 billion and funded entirely by the private sector, will be built in three phases over twelve years. As well as power from the tidal lagoon, there are plans for a floating solar array in the adjacent Queen’s dock, a data centre run solely on renewable energy, and a climate and oceanic research centre. There will be energy-efficient homes for 5,000 people using the waste heat from the data centre, and 150 floating homes.
Large projects are administratively complex, often needing multiple permissions and consents from multiple agencies. Wales has the added complication of being a devolved Government, with powers and responsibilities split between themselves and the central Government of the UK. Where there is administrative complexity there is always the possibility of delay, of an arduous journey to completion, or even cancellation as an earlier proposal for a tidal lagoon on the same site found.
The earlier project, Swansea Bay Tidal Lagoon, was originally given planning consent in 2015, but also needed a marine licence from Natural Resources Wales. This was initially refused on environmental grounds, with the impacts on fish populations thought too severe. The developers contested the refusal and the Hendry Review (commissioned by the UK Government) recommended the project should be built. The Welsh Government confirmed financial support for the project in early 2018 only for the UK central Government to then decide not to issue the project with a contract for difference (CfD) later that year. A contract for difference is one way of supporting the development of technologies that can’t yet compete directly on price. It pays the difference between what the market will pay for the electricity and the cost of generating it, subsidising the technology as it develops, as economies of scale are gained and costs fall until the subsidy is no longer needed. It is a model that worked well in the early days of onshore wind power, which is now amongst the cheapest forms of electricity available in the UK. A key legal permission, the development consent order, expired in 2020, ending the prospects for the project.
But all was not over. The proposal was revived as part of a wider project, Blue Eden, which proposed a more extensive redevelopment of Swansea waterfront. Construction is planned to begin in 2023, subject to planning consent which, as we have seen with the earlier proposal is not necessarily straight-forward.
One key advantage of tidal energy is that the tides are predictable, unlike some other forms of renewable energy. We know when a particular tide will be, months and years in advance. We know how high it should be, although wind direction and air pressure may alter the height of tide that we actually get. Contrast this predictability with wave energy where the wave height (and the power produced from it) depends on the strength and duration of the winds in the hours and days before. One reason we need tidal predictions is that the time of high tide changes from day to day, and varies from place to place. This variability is an inconvenience if you’re a fisherman, sailor, or freight ship captain, but very useful if you’re putting together an energy grid. Tides are always falling or rising somewhere; tidal streams flooding in one place, ebbing in another. There is a minimum amount of energy we need to generate called the baseload. Fall below this and our power grid may fail. Choose wisely in where we place our sites and we can use tidal energy to make a significant contribution to generating this baseload energy. Of course, how significant a contribution depends on the size of each site, how many we have, and where we put them around the coast.
Each of these lagoons will leave their mark on the Earth, as all of humanity’s works do, but what will that mark be? There are existing installations such as the tidal barrage in Brittany, France but tidal barrages and tidal lagoons are different. A tidal barrage encloses the mouth of an estuary with a relatively short sea wall, and rivers discharge freshwater into the area behind it, changing the characteristics of the estuary. A tidal lagoon is different; it uses a longer sea wall to enclose an area of water between two points on the coast. The two types are not the same. This means that experience with tidal barrages may not be the best teacher when learning how best to build and operate a tidal lagoon project. This is one of the reasons why the Swansea project is described as a ‘pathfinder’ project – an opportunity to learn, to troubleshoot, to advance the technology before the building of larger projects.
If we are to learn the most from the Swansea Bay project then surveying and monitoring are vital. We must know how things are before we can measure how they change. In the UK proposals for development are usually preceded by a phase I habitat survey, a standardised ecological assessment designed to identify what species and habitats are present, and whether any are protected, which would cause changes to the plans for the development. At Swansea the biological surveys for the previous project proposal were extensive. Fish, surveyed over a year to tease out the seasonal links between areas used for feeding, spawning or nurseries. Birds, surveyed to identify breeding and overwintering populations, as well as to document the local, more permanent, residents. But a tidal lagoon project needs onshore facilities as well, for example to connect to the electricity grid, and that means impacts on land as well as at sea. They may not be the most obvious candidates to be affected by a tidal energy development but bats and reptiles were also surveyed for.
Once the lagoon is built and generating electricity (assuming it is not delayed yet again), then the next phase of monitoring begins. In open water collision with tidal stream turbines is a risk for marine mammals such as harbour porpoises or grey seals. What risks here, where the flow of water around the turbines is constrained by the openings for them in the sea wall? Acoustic deterrents could be used to deter wildlife, but these have their own disadvantages to those that use sound to feed or navigate. The sea wall will cause the pattern and speed of currents to change, speeding up in one place, slowing in another. Moving water carries sediments. Where the water moves more quickly sediment is picked up and transported. The faster the water the bigger the sediment particles that can be carried; gravels instead of sand, sand instead of mud. Where the water slows, the sediment is dropped. The initial surveys looked at what types of sediment were present, and where they were found within the site. Together with measurements of wave heights, currents and turbidity these help develop an understanding of how silts or sands might be transported. Continued surveying and monitoring after construction turns a prediction of what might happen into a description of what did happen. Comparing the two adds another page to the book that shows us how to best build and use these technologies.
But our ambition should not be simply to document and reduce the impacts the lagoon may have. There is also the opportunity to enhance. The sea wall will become an artificial reef, and so what the sea wall is built from and how it is built matters. By varying the roughness of the surface, and using a mix of rock and crevice sizes, a much wider diversity of creatures can make it their home than would be able to on a plain concrete slab. Artificial rock pools can be added to the intertidal sections of the sea wall, increasing the complexity of the habitat further. Swansea Bay was once home to an oyster fishery, but pollution and overfishing reduced the population too much to support one now. Spatting ponds, where mature oysters can spawn, could be placed inside the lagoon, and used to re-stock the bay. Oysters, as well as providing food and employment through a fishery, also improve water quality through filtration, and store carbon. The lagoon would also be an ideal location for seagrass restoration, boosting biodiversity and again storing carbon.
Everything we do leaves an ecological footprint. Energy from the tides leaves a smaller impact in its extraction and use than oil and gas, but it is not without consequence. We have the tools and techniques with which to monitor and measure these impacts, and can learn from them as the technology progresses. We can place activities where they complement each other, like the co-location of the solar array and data centre of the Blue Eden project. Synergies build, moving closer to a more sustainable, more circular, economy. If we must leave a footprint then it is our responsibility to ourselves, our children, our planet and the wildlife we share it with, to make that footprint as light as we can.
Language matters. Language can explain or elaborate, confuse or camouflage. For example, what do we mean when we say we value something? Value is a word with multiple meanings, and multiple meanings can serve many masters.
But even plain words, words we think of as describing singular concepts, can be slippery. Suppose I show you a photograph of a dog. Just an ordinary dog, bright-eyed, expectantly looking at the camera as if waiting for a ball to be thrown. And then I point to this dog and ask you ‘what is a dog?’ You might look at me a little strangely, perhaps perplexed by the question. A dog is, after all, just a dog. But look at the photograph again. To Raymond, the pensioner who lives alone this is Reggie, his friend who lies alongside him as they sit on the sofa together and watch TV. To Sally, who volunteers with the mountain rescue team, Reggie is a respected four-legged colleague, without whom a number of people may not have gone home to their families last year. To Rachel, the geneticist, Reggie is a collaborator in her research, with Reggie’s DNA helping to unravel the story of when wolves were first domesticated, how and when the path from competitor to companion was first trod. To other scientists, Reggie may literally be an experimental animal on whom procedures are performed or drugs tested, although the tag on his pen will call him ‘D149’ rather than Reggie. In some areas of the world dogs are on the menu, afforded no more consideration than a chicken in a battery cage.
How this dog is perceived, how it is loved, respected or disrespected, used or abused, is not constant. In effect, the answer to the question ‘what is a dog?’ depends on who is doing the asking and who answers.
There’s a difference between the ‘value of’ something and the ‘value in’ something. ‘Value in’ describes the intrinsic worth, the value of something for its own sake. ‘Value of’ attempts to place a monetary value, to put a price on something. Which of these win in the conflict between them may depend on the circumstance. Someone who is unemployed and reduced to destitution may sell otherwise precious belongings so that their children do not go hungry. But some things are beyond price. The beauty of a sunset is an example typically used. But I think of an indentation of the river Camel estuary, enclosed by a horseshoe of rocks, and the early Autumn sun dropping lower in the sky. There is a shallow pool left stranded by the tide and the laughter of my toddler grandson as he splashes through the knee-deep water playfully chased by his grandfather, both chased by Bernie, the German Shepherd dog, who joins in the game when not distracted by thrown sticks. There is no ‘value of’ here, no price, only the glow of memory to be cherished as the child grows to adulthood.
Language is ambiguous. The same word can mean different things to different audiences. When a scientist talks of uncertainty and error in a measurement they’re talking of the preciseness and variability of the measure. It’s actually an expression of confidence in the correctness of the measurement. But to the general public, when a scientist says “uncertainty”, they hear “we don’t know”. When a scientist says “error” they hear “mistake”. I’ve discussed before that I dislike the term “ecosystem services”, partly because it suggests a hierarchy where those receiving the service are more important than that which provides it, but it’s also that the term, like value, can mean very different things. To the scientist the term describes something provided by the ecosystem, perhaps irreplaceably. To others, with interests beyond the ecological, the focus can be on the ‘value of’ rather than the ‘value in’. ‘Value of’ suggests a valuation, but place a price on something and the ‘value in’ becomes secondary. And that gets to the heart of a valuation. Money is a system of exchange: I give you these tokens, you give me my coffee, and you take those tokens to exchange for something that you want. If something is given a price, if it has a valuation, then that means that it is exchangeable. One of the dictionary definitions of value is this idea of exchange, and then the object with the valuation becomes just another token, no different from our usual coins, banknotes, or electronic funds. The object with the valuation, whether that’s Van Gogh’s sunflowers or endangered seahorses in a seagrass bed, has become fungible, transmutable into something different – the valuation. The object comes and goes, but the valuation remains. In this way, the ‘value in’ ceases to exist and only the ‘value of’ remains.
It’s a poverty of the human imagination that so many things are reduced to a ‘value of’, rather than being held in esteem for their intrinsic worth, but it’s also the result of human psychology and human choice. It’s the culture we are immersed in. Values don’t exist in isolation. They congregate with fellow travellers, and mass like armies against those least like them. They form consistent patterns across different cultures, suggesting that it is something fundamental within us as a species.
Shalom Schwarz developed the theory of basic human values, organising them into something he called a circumplex. He placed values according to two axes. The first is a measure of what influences and drives us, whether that comes from within or from others. Self-acceptance and popularity lie at opposite ends of this axis. The second is a measure of where our priorities lie, whether that is our own pleasure and achievement, or helping others. Hedonism and spirituality are the outliers here.
An older idea of human motivation is Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, the idea that we need to satisfy our most basic needs first, like food and shelter, before we can meet higher needs such as love and friendship and reaching our potential. The exact sequencing and relationship of those needs is still contentious, so perhaps a better fit is to think of it as three layers, the borders blurry and indistinct between them. The bottom layer contains those who are security-driven. They are looking for safety and a sense of belonging; those in this layer are often tribal in their allegiances. The middle layer are those who are outer-directed. They conspicuously display, drive the right aspirational brand of car or wear the latest fashions in clothes; they gain their status and self-esteem by seeking the approval of others. The top layer contains those who are inner-directed. They already have achieved self-esteem and are motivated more by ideas and achieving their full potential.
The three worlds model of human behaviour calls these three groups settlers, prospectors, and pioneers, each fundamentally different from each other in terms of what motivates them and what feels important. This is something we all do. The values we hold affect how we view the world and how we think it should work. They intersect with our notions of ‘value of’ and ‘value in’, to form a hierarchy of what we hold to be important and what is less so. But the values we hold don’t exist in isolation – we hold them within the culture that we live in. Are our values the majority view or the minority view or something in-between? Do they coincide with the values that those in power hold or do they conflict? These are not fixed points. Values held by individuals and societies can change over time. We are rarely the same person at fifty years old that we were at twenty, and the worlds we inhabited are similarly disparate. Cultures shift over time, sometimes for the better, sometimes for the worse.
Our current culture, political and social, is one that pays lip service to tackling the climate crisis. We upgrade our phones, whether the old one still meets our needs or not. We see record-busting floods in Pakistan but then fly to Europe for a weekend city break. Governments make grand announcements easily condensed to sound bites and slogans, even though the actions underlying the announcement are insufficient or counter-productive to achieve the goal they trumpet. In July 2022 the UK Government’s net zero strategy was found to be unlawful by the high court because it failed to show how the UK’s legally binding carbon budgets would be met should the strategy be followed. In Autumn 2022 the short-lived administration of Prime Minister Liz Truss announced plans to issue new licences for oil and gas extraction in direct contradiction of the International Energy Authority report that states that “there is no need for investment in new fossil fuel supply” if the world is to meet its climate targets.
The ‘value of’ continues to be placed above the ‘value in’, even when the ‘value in’ is an intact, well-functioning biosphere that sustains us all, something that should dwarf the ‘value of’ achieved through exploiting it. Those of us who see the ‘value in’ need to persuade those who prioritise the ‘value of’ that they need to change course. We need to influence the cultural values for the better. As the IPCC states in its sixth assessment report: “Climate change is a threat to human well-being and planetary health. Any further delay … will miss a brief and rapidly closing window of opportunity to secure a liveable and sustainable future for all.” There can be no higher stakes to recognise the intrinsic value of the natural world and our place within it than this. We embrace the ‘value in’ or little of value will remain.
Leatherback turtle on a beach making its way to the sea Image courtesy US Fish and Wildlife Service
It was, at the time, the largest corpse of its kind ever found. Friday 23rd September 1988, two days short of a full moon, the weather neither unseasonally warm nor cold, the retreating tide leaves the corpse stranded on Harlech beach like a wrecked ship. The beach is four miles long, flanked to the north by the estuary at Porthmadog and to landward by a chain of sand dunes and slacks behind which Harlech Castle rises like a sentry post. Once victualled directly by boat the castle is itself now stranded from the sea by centuries of longshore drift that sculpted the dunes lying before it. The corpse is male, weighing more than 900 kilograms, and is almost three metres long from its blunt nose to its stubby tail, two and a half metres from flipper tip to flipper tip. Fishermen had found it the day before, tangled in the lines to their whelk pots four miles off the coast in Tremadoc Bay. Cut free, drowned, adrift like flotsam, it made landfall on Harlech beach.
It was not one of the usual suspects, not native to Welsh waters, more usually thought of as belonging to tropical seas where coastlines of milk-white sand are fringed by coral reefs. That may be true of other marine turtles, who would be cold-stunned into torpor even by summer temperatures in these waters, but not the leatherback turtle. This turtle is different.
There are two groups of marine turtles, two families on the evolutionary tree. Most have scutes, plates of horn-like material that form their shell and cover their head and flippers. Differences in the arrangement of these scutes helps to distinguish between the species. These species are the Chelonidae, pronounced kel-on-ee-dee. Leatherbacks, like their name suggests, lack these bony plates, their backs of tough skin stretched over seven ridges that run along the body of the animal. They are the last living species, the last survivors, of an ancient lineage, the Dermochelyidae (der-mo-kel-ee-dee).
Marine turtles are ectotherms; they do not maintain a constant body temperature in the way that mammals or birds do. There is no ‘normal’ body temperature for an ectotherm, only a range of optimal temperatures. Their body temperature takes its cue from the temperature of the environment around them. This is where evolution gave leatherbacks their advantage, gave them an ability to range further into colder waters where other turtles cannot go. They have the widest distribution of any marine turtle, ranging as far north as Norway and the Arctic Circle, and as far south as New Zealand. Leatherbacks can’t regulate their temperature, they can’t maintain it at a constant value regardless of the temperature of the environment, but they can raise it above and keep it above the temperature of the surrounding water by generating heat from their muscles. The bigger the turtle, the larger the differential it can maintain between body temperature and water, and the further north it can go.
Picture a beach on the Atlantic coast of Costa Rica, palm trees lazily slanted off-vertical and waves that caress rather than crash into the sand. It is as different from the beach at Harlech as it can be, but it is beaches like these where a leatherback will be born, on the curve of the coast facing out into the Caribbean. The turtle will hatch from one of perhaps seventy eggs from any of up to eleven batches laid by each female.
Temperature first plays a pivotal role in their lives here. Sex is controlled by the warmth of the sand and the resulting temperature that incubates the eggs in the nest. Lower temperatures produce males, higher temperatures produce females, with a transitional temperature range between them where both sexes are produced. These waters are where it will spend its first few years, feeding, growing, surviving where initially almost everything is larger than you, containing guilds of predators that would happily feed on young turtles.
Size is the key. They cannot start their pilgrimage to higher latitudes, to colder waters, to richer feeding grounds, until they have bulked up. It is a biological consequence of geometry, a simple mathematical relationship: the surface-area-to-volume ratio. Imagine two metal cubes. The first, the smaller cube, has sides one centimetre wide by one centimetre high. The second is three times the size, each side three centimetres wide by three centimetres high. Heat them both to perhaps fifty degrees, and then wait. Hold your palm above each a while later to gauge how hot they are and the smaller one will feel cooler than the larger. The smaller one has six sides, each with an area of one square centimetre to give a total surface area of six square centimetres, and has a volume of one cubic centimetre: a ratio of six to one. That’s a lot of surface through which the heat of a small volume can radiate away. The larger cube has a volume of twenty-seven cubic centimetres (three times three times three), and the surface area is now fifty-four square centimetres (six sides, each three by three). That gives the ratio fifty-four to twenty-seven or, simplifying, two to one. From six to one down to two to one. Each ‘chunk’ of volume in the larger cube has a much smaller area of surface to lose heat from.
A turtle is not cube-shaped, but the same principle applies. As the animal grows its volume increases at a faster rate than its surface area, meaning that it can better retain heat, that heat is lost to the water more slowly. This is the reason the biggest turtles can penetrate the coldest waters, out-competing their smaller brethren for access to the abundance of food in more northerly seas.
These are ocean voyagers. Researchers can tag adult turtles as they leave the nesting beaches. Leatherbacks don’t come ashore en masse to mate and nest like their hard-shelled relatives, meaning that most tagged turtles are female. Tagged males are rarer. Tagging male turtles requires capturing and tagging them at sea. Where, when, and how they mate is still something science has yet to confirm, but is thought to happen close to the nesting beaches where the females will lay their eggs.
On land, vast herds of wildebeest undergo a yearly migration along defined routes between the Serengeti and the Masai Mara, with river crossings where they run the gauntlet of hungry Nile crocodiles. Turtle migrations lack this regularity. There is no predictability about where and when they will migrate. But let’s follow a male turtle from these Costa Rican waters, follow his journey to see how he may arrive in the Welsh seas where our Harlech leviathan met its end. This male is spent from mating. He must replenish his reserves of energy, and that means he must head northwards. His fins, proportionately the longest of any turtle, beat steadily, the muscles that power them producing the heat that permits him to venture north. But he must conserve that heat. In his fins the blood vessels that carry blood away from the body lie close to those returning cooled blood from the extremities. This arrangement, where the blood vessels are parallel but with flows in opposite directions is called a countercurrent heat exchanger. Heat from the outgoing blood warms the cooler incoming blood. In effect the heat performs a u-turn, using the closeness of the blood vessels to avoid a trip to the extremities where it would more easily be lost to the water. In colder waters he will increase his swimming speed and the rate of his fin strokes, producing additional heat to keep himself warmer than the water that surrounds him. These colder waters are rich in nutrients, productive, fuelling the growth of plankton and the predators that feed on them. Here is where the turtle finds its prey: jellyfish. These are plentiful, but nutritionally diffuse. The turtle overcomes the low nutritional density of a single jellyfish by eating in quantity to gain the calories and nutrition it needs.
The turtle dives, encountering prey on the majority of its searches. It is not a fussy eater. It will close and feed, indiscriminately, without preference of anatomy; tentacles or bell are equally welcome in the pursuit of calories and nutrition. He is an efficient predator, with little time (or energy) wasted on unsuccessful or unproductive attacks. Backward-facing spines in the throat ensure that prey does not escape. These are not small turtles yet a leatherback may consume three-quarters of its bodyweight of jellyfish each day.
As autumn yields to the approach of winter, others that arrived here by disparate routes to forage with our turtle will make the return journey south, back to warmer waters, but he will remain here between 30 and 40 degrees north, overwintering before making a transatlantic crossing eastwards to the Irish Sea or Bay of Biscay.
The Irish Sea is a rich hunting ground for a pelagic predator like the leatherback, and it is here that the Harlech turtle faced one of the threats that many large marine animals face: entanglement in fishing gear. A post-mortem revealed some plastic had been ingested, confused for jellyfish, but not enough to cause it to starve. There was some chemical contamination in its tissues of heavy metals and PCBs, another common issue with large predators whose tissue bioaccumulate toxins, but again not in particularly significant amounts. The turtle, capable of diving to depths of 1200m, drowned in waters less than 20m deep, entangled in lines to fishing pots.
The death of the Harlech leatherback passed unnoticed by me at the time. I was in my mid-twenties, a soldier stationed closer to the North Sea coast than to the Irish Sea, dealing with the emotional backwash from a recently completed tour of active duty. Re-considering my choices would lead to the University College of North Wales, Bangor just two years later to study marine biology. I would come face-to-face with the turtle much later, or at least its skeleton and taxidermed reconstruction, in one of the galleries of the national museum of Wales in Cardiff.
Here in the UK, the magnificence of our seas passes unnoticed and unremarked, perhaps hidden by the murkiness that comes with the plankton in such rich, productive waters. And they are magnificent, despite the damage being done to them, with seagrass meadows, the second largest fish in the world resident here, and leatherbacks, enduring cold northern waters to gorge on the jellyfish it finds here.
A blue sphere hangs dwarfed by the blackness of space: Earth. Astronauts who have seen it talked of a shift in perspective, a shift in consciousness almost. They speak of its smallness, its fragility. They experience a feeling that the artificial distinctions we place on ourselves – alliances, races, nations – are just that: arbitrary divisions of a common humanity. Look down on the Pacific Ocean from space and there is a small halo of land at the edges, the rest is water. The land masses do not enclose the ocean, they are surrounded by it. Ellen MacArthur, when sailing solo around the world, reflected on the need to conserve what she had, that any response to her own or the boat’s needs had to come from within, from what the boat was carrying. From whatever scale we view it – planet, continent, nation or boat – we are all island people, dependent solely on what our particular island can provide. Paradoxically, it is the ocean that makes this island Earth somewhere suitable for us to live.
The Earth’s deepest valleys and its highest mountainous peaks are found not on land, but beneath the ocean’s surface. We may talk of the Atlantic, the Pacific, the Arctic, the Indian or the Southern Ocean, but these are just names for particular areas, particular basins in a single, global ocean that surrounds the lands we call home. It is the ocean that absorbs most of the solar radiation reaching the Earth, and a global circulation driven by wind, waves, water temperature and density that transports this heat between different parts of the world. Heat moves between ocean and atmosphere, driving global and local patterns of weather, dividing peoples into haves and have-nots, into those beset by drought or blessed by rain; rain that itself was brought into being by evaporation from the ocean. Change the ocean circulation, change the distribution of heat, and you change the fate of billions of people.
As Sylvia Earle has said: “No blue, no green”. We are as dependent on the ocean as much as any whale, dolphin or seal, but we forget this. This is partly because of an extinction of experience, the loss of connection with nature, partly because of our perspective as a terrestrial species; we are creatures of the land, why should the ocean concern us?
The Amazon rainforest is sometimes called the ‘lungs of the world’ because, like all plants, it releases oxygen as one of the products of photosynthesis. But that’s our terrestrial bias creeping in again, distorting our viewpoint. At least half of the oxygen we breathe is released not by land-based plants but from the ocean through the actions of billions of phytoplankton. Microscopic, their small size obscures them from our gaze and disguises their importance while they silently top up the atmospheric reservoir of oxygen that we breathe from, keeping us alive, and providing the basis on which much of the life in the ocean ultimately depends.
As if providing breathable air is not enough, the ocean has also, so far, lessened the impact of our own recklessness, absorbing at least a fifth of the carbon dioxide we have short-sightedly emitted to the atmosphere in the last two decades alone. The ocean has subsidised our use of fossil fuels, but not without cost to itself. The ocean and atmosphere are connected, with heat and gases exchanging between the two at the surface. The increase in carbon dioxide concentration and heat is a double blow for coral reefs, the combination causing the coral polyps to expel the symbiotic algae that live within them, and which provide their colour and 90% of the energy the corals need to survive. The corals are left pale, ‘bleached’, operating at an energetic loss that will eventually kill them if the water temperatures do not fall in time. These reefs protect coastlines, provide economic benefits through tourism and fisheries for the communities that live by them and, no less important, they have their own innate value for their beauty and rich diversity of life.
The ocean regulates the climate. The Gulf stream flows from the Caribbean across the Atlantic to western Europe, bringing huge quantities of heat, and the occasional navigationally confused turtle. Europe is warmer than it would otherwise be, with milder winters. The flow continues further north, the water becoming cooler and denser until it reaches a place and a point where gestation is complete and genesis occurs: sea ice forms. The forming of sea ice pulls freshwater from the ocean to leave behind a saltier, denser plume of water that sinks to the seabed, asserts its identify as the North Atlantic Deep Water, and begins its long journey flowing along the bottom of the Atlantic towards Antarctica. Scientists refer to the pattern of currents here, the warmer, salty water near the surface and the colder, deeper flows southward, as the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation, or AMOC. But this liquid conveyor belt of heat, globally important, is threatened by climate change, and weakening.
Arrays of instruments span the Atlantic to monitor the movement and characteristics of the water that makes up this circulation. The earliest of these arrays dates to 2004, giving us almost two decades of data that show a weakening of the AMOC, but two decades is a short time, insufficiently short, when talking of the climate. Climate change models also predict a weakening of the AMOC, but the changes we see are outpacing the models. The AMOC is the weakest it has been for over a thousand years, with significant declines from the 19th century onwards, and the recent weakening is happening ten times faster than predicted. The Arctic is warming faster than more temperate regions, releasing freshwater from the melting of the Greenland Ice Sheet that acts to reduce the salinity of the seawater in the critical areas of ocean where deep water forms and sinks. Overall, it is more difficult for sea ice to form and leave behind the saltier water that drives the circulation. The AMOC appears to exist in two modes, two stable states. There is the ‘strong’ mode, the one that we see now, and a ‘weak’ mode, where the flows of water and heat are very much reduced. Characteristic patterns of water temperatures at the surface and at depth act as early warning signals and show that we are getting closer to the tipping point when the circulation switches to this weaker mode.
The consequences of a switch would be global and severe. The delivery of heat from the tropics to the temperate seas of Europe would stop, dropping the average temperature, and changing the patterns and volume of rainfall. Part of the signal of a weakening circulation is warming of the seas where the Gulf stream starts and a cooling in northern seas as less heat is transferred north. But warmth is energy and warmer tropical seas evaporate more water to fuel more frequent and more powerful hurricanes.
The current carries more than just heat. Like a savings account at a bank, the AMOC transports large amounts of carbon to deposit them in the sedimentary vaults of the deep ocean. Lose this transport, and the challenge of tackling climate change becomes that much harder. Water that descends to the depths must eventually surface, bringing within it rich supplies of nutrients to fuel the growth of phytoplankton and the other creatures that depend on them. Around three billion people worldwide depend on the ocean for their primary source of protein. Some of the fisheries that provide this protein depend on this upwelling while others depend on the productivity of the shelf seas – the relatively shallow waters near to the coast. Many fisheries are either over-exploited or close to being fully exploited. There is no slack, no spare capacity to compensate for any reductions in fish stocks that result from a change in ocean circulation and the distribution of nutrients. Put simply, people will starve, most likely those in the global south already disproportionately hit by the consequences of climate change.
As a child in the 1970s the ‘undersea world of Jacques Cousteau’ series of books were frequent presents at Christmas and birthdays. In one of them he talked about the mineral resources in the deep sea, nodules rich in manganese, zinc and other elements, and how one day we might mine these for use. Today, that prospect is much closer. These minerals and rare earths are used in electric vehicles and the other electronic devices that define our modern age. Yet we know so little of the deep ocean, and what damage extracting those resources would do.
The abyssal plains that cover much of the ocean floor are typically around four kilometres deep. Light does not reach these depths, and food is scarce, falling from above either as a snowfall of dead plankton, the occasional bounty of a larger carcass such as a whale, or for predators a chance encounter in the dark. They are low energy environments; water moves slowly. Disturbance of the sediment is likely to persist for a long time, like a tyre print across tundra or the footprint of an astronaut in lunar dust. The creatures that live here are highly specialised and, with the exception of life around hydrothermal vents, sparsely distributed.
At a conference I attended in 2014 one presenter showed a map of an area where deep sea mining was proposed. On the slide were markers showing the location of sightings recorded in a biodiversity database. He then went to the next slide, which removed all the sightings from the top 1500m of water leaving only the deeper sightings. There were no markers. None. There was literally no data on the species that lived in that area at the depths at which deep sea mining would take place. This is less ignoring the precautionary principle and more denying its existence. How can any extraction be justified without a detailed and proper analysis of the impacts that it would cause? Have we learned nothing from our experience of using CFCs, DDT, or the extraction of fossil fuels?
We are all island peoples, surrounded by ocean, utterly dependent on it for our continued well-being and survival. Our actions have consequences; we are damaging and stressing the ocean, and through that damaging ourselves. Unless we are careful, unless we change course, we may find that we have crossed a climate tipping point, like the AMOC switching to a weaker state, and entered a time where we have little control or agency over what the consequences will be. At that point, we may find that we have damaged beyond redemption that with which we need to survive and prosper.
Kelp on the shore at low tide. Image courtesy of J P Davies on pixabay
If someone speaks of farming in the ocean, of aquaculture, then what do we think of? Salmon pens in Scottish sea lochs; mussels on ropes hanging down in the water, fed and washed clean by the current; sea bass perhaps since so little sea bass is now wild-caught in UK waters; or tropical prawns if we pause to read the label in the supermarket. What we probably don’t think of is seaweed. After all, there’s only so much sushi one person can eat. But that means we’re missing an opportunity. Seaweed has value beyond mere nutrition, and farming it offers the chance to deal with the problems facing us in the twenty-first century, from mitigating climate change, to reducing plastic waste, to providing new drugs to heal the sick.
Seaweed has always been harvested, collected from the shore for food or improving the soil, but farming it is more recent. Most seaweed aquaculture takes place in Asian countries, with the crop used either directly as seaweed or indirectly as alginates – thickening agents – in other products such as ice cream and toothpaste. The quantity of the crop produced has increased steadily by over six per cent per year from 2000 to 2018. Other countries are looking at seaweed aquaculture, and not just as a foodstuff. This isn’t a recent innovation; France and Germany looked at algal aquaculture using kelp in the 1990s, followed by the UK and Ireland in the 2000s. Norway is actively researching the potential of farming kelp as part of a bio-economy, sparked an initial interest in the development of biofuels.
Seaweed aquaculture offers so much more than simply food and fuel, if it is implemented in a way that is well thought out, and integrated with other aspects of society and the natural world. The world population is increasing, expected to reach almost ten billion people by 2050. Earth overshoot day, when our impact on nature takes us into ecological debt, moves ever earlier in the year. The limits of ecological capacity means that not everyone can live like those in developed countries do with their level of consumption, but environmental justice and basic humanity means that development can’t be denied to countries simply because they started on the path of development later. Algal aquaculture, for all its apparent simplicity, offers one way for that development to be approached in a more sustainable way.
What makes seaweed special? What gives it its versatility and value? The composition of seaweeds depends on the season and the species. The kelps are typically high in various types of carbohydrate, particularly towards the autumn and winter when they are laying down energy stores to see them through until the spring. Protein is another significant component, with a higher proportion of essential amino acids than terrestrial plants, making them a good prospect for the manufacture of animal feeds. The third main group of components is the ‘mineral’ fraction, containing chlorine, potassium, zinc, manganese, and iodine, along with heavy metals such as lead and cadmium. A big advantage is that seaweed doesn’t require fertilisers or feed; nutrients borne by the current are brought to it, wastes are washed away. Coastal areas are suffering from an excess of nutrients called eutrophication that fuels the growth of microscopic algae into algal blooms. These blooms strip the oxygen from the water as the algae die and decompose, often taking the oxygen concentration down to levels that make life difficult for other creatures such as fish and invertebrates. These excess nutrients originate from the land, and so seaweed aquaculture can help to clean our coastal seas, reducing the eutrophication and hypoxia resulting from discharges that should ideally be dealt with at source. Another source of nutrients in coastal waters is the waste from fish farms. Placing these two forms of aquaculture together helps to lessen the impact of the fish farm, an approach called integrated multi-trophic aquaculture (IMTA).
Seaweed aquaculture battles climate change on multiple fronts. First, it removes carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, which dissolves in the water to be taken up by the seaweed as it grows, and incorporated into its tissues. Although the seaweed is ultimately harvested, some growth is lost to the environment. Wave action and currents break off the older parts of the fronds at the ends, and these fragments are transported away, where they become part of the sediments of shallow coastal waters or the deep sea. Up to half of the carbon stored in the sediment of a seagrass bed comes from sources outside the bed.
Methane, like carbon dioxide, drives climate change, but has around eighty times the warming potential of carbon dioxide. It’s a complex situation with a mix of natural sources that seem to be increasing, and anthropogenic sources from human activities and society. One study in 2020 found that as little as 0.2% of algae in the feed to cattle reduced their methane emissions by 98%.
A second effect of carbon dioxide dissolving in seawater is to lower the pH, a process called ocean acidification. Algae use carbon dioxide when they photosynthesise and grow, partially countering the lowering of pH, and providing an area of refuge for those organisms that use calcium carbonate in their tissues, from coraline algae to oysters and other shellfish.
Seaweed can be used to produce biofuels. These release carbon dioxide when they are used in homes or for transport, but the process overall tends towards being carbon neutral, only releasing the carbon dioxide that was captured during growth. Biofuel from algae means less biofuel needs to be produced on land, freeing up those areas for food production or nature restoration. But we can go further: seaweed aquaculture can capture and store carbon – called sequestration – as its primary aim with other uses providing secondary benefits. If this is done then the process overall becomes carbon negative, removing more carbon dioxide from the atmosphere than it releases to it, and we can start to undo some of the damage the anthropocene has visited on the natural world.
Natural kelp forests are complex three-dimensional habitats, rich in species. Even a seaweed farm with its algal monoculture can offer shelter and food to other creatures, particularly if hard substrates are locally in short supply. Their fronds provide living space for others such as bryozoans, filter-feeding colonial animals attached to the surface of the fronds. Kelp forests act as refuges and nurseries for fish and invertebrates such as crabs and lobsters. Careful positioning of seaweed farms can mean that there is less of a spatial squeeze on fishers. For example, placing them next to existing fish farms or within the boundaries of a wind farm reduces the additional area that seaweed aquaculture would need.
Algal aquaculture can feed industry, as well as people and livestock. It offers us routes into a bio-economy, a circular economy, where low carbon industrial production interlinks like an ecosystem to provide a sustainable economic future. Seaweed can be used to produce bioplastics, reducing the amount of fossil fuel used to produce packaging that is then often discarded after a single use. Kelps contain significant amount of polyphenols, a diverse group of chemicals consisting of multiple rings of carbon atoms. Some polyphenols have antioxidant, antifungal and antibacterial properties, making them useful as food supplements or pharmaceuticals. Other compounds can be used in cosmetics. This is one of the strengths of seaweed aquaculture, to see the crop not as a single product, but as a raw material for a multitude of different uses.
There are problems and issues though, as there always are. Seaweed can concentrate harmful substances, among them heavy metals such as lead, cadmium, mercury and arsenic. Some elements such as iodine, zinc and manganese, harmless at low concentrations, become harmful above a certain threshold. The chemical composition of the crop needs careful monitoring, particularly when used for animal and human consumption.
There is an element of the chicken and the egg when considering a wider use of seaweed farming. What comes first, the products or the markets for those products? How do we incorporate these products into a circular economy when that circular economy is still in its infancy? Biofuels and pharmaceuticals need markets, but markets can only develop for those products that are available, and developing them to the point where they can be marketed takes time and investment. The supporting web of infrastructure – skilled workers, suppliers of specialist equipment and spare parts – needs to develop and link together. Processing plants are required, with a reliable year-round supply of a raw material that normally grows seasonally; learning how and when to store the crop to minimise the loss of quality involves experimentation, with the inevitable mistakes and ‘wrong turns’ before success. Leadership and investment by governments are needed to bring the industry to maturity, as has been done for other industries before, such as the subsidies paid in the early stages of renewable energy development.
There are seventeen sustainable development goals. Seaweed aquaculture can help us meet many of them, particularly for people in the global south. The cost of entry to the industry is relatively low, at least compared to other forms of agriculture and aquaculture, and done well can attract payments for the public goods it provides (in the form of storing carbon and tackling nutrient discharge), all of which goes towards meeting SDG 1 ‘no poverty’. Provision of these public goods together with the benefit of nursery areas for fish and local reductions in ocean acidification helps to meet both SDG 13 ‘climate action’ and SDG 14 ‘life below water’. Biofuel production releases agricultural land for other purposes, reducing pressures on native biodiversity, and offsets fossil fuels that would otherwise be used for energy, contributing towards climate action and SDG 15 ‘life on land’. The entrepreneurship and inventiveness that is needed for the wider integration of algal biofuels helps meet both SDG 9 ‘industry innovation’, and SDG 7 ‘affordable and clean energy’. The use of seaweed as foodstuffs and nutritional supplements helps to meet SDG 2 ‘zero hunger’ and SDG 3 ‘good health’. Many goals, so much potential progress, and all from one source.
We are ecologically overdrawn, in a society as yet too contemptuous of its impact on the natural world to realise how deeply it is in trouble. We are living unsustainably. Unsustainable, by definition, means that we cannot continue as we are. Something as mundane as seaweed offers us a way to begin addressing that, setting ourselves on the path to both sustainability, and survivability.