Category Conservation

Wild Isles, Wild Waters, Why Here?

An image of Britain and Ireland taken by the Sentinel 3 satellite, part of the Copernicus programme.
Contains modified Copernicus Sentinel data 2017, CC BY-SA 3.0 IGO via Wikimedia Commons

An image of Britain and Ireland taken by the Sentinel 3 satellite, part of the Copernicus programme.
Contains modified Copernicus Sentinel data 2017, CC BY-SA 3.0 IGO via Wikimedia Commons

‘Wild isles’, presented by David Attenborough, is being broadcast on the BBC in March and April 2023. In contrast to his other work, this series turns away from the wider world to take a deeper look at the wildlife of Britain and Ireland. This blog, although with an emphasis more on what is in and beneath the waters around these wild isles, also has the same focus. So why do I concentrate on the local, when there is so much beauty, so much wonder elsewhere in nature? Let’s start with what the reason is not. It is not nationalism, with its unthinking pride in country and blindness to its flaws. Neither is it exceptionalism, the view that one’s own country is somehow better or more special than any other. The UK is exceptional, but not in a positive way for nature: it is one of the world’s most nature-depleted countries. It is also one of the least wooded countries in Europe, with just over 13% of woodland cover in the UK compared to over 40% for Europe as a whole. And the scale of sewage discharges into water courses simply beggars belief, with one blue flag beach in Devon (Blackpool sands) having sixty-three sewage spills totalling over more than one thousand hours in 2022.

So why the local focus? Put simply, it is my home. It is where I live. It is also what I have access to. With the exception of going to the EMSEA conference on Crete in 2015 I haven’t flown since 1988, when my last flights were as a young soldier on the plains of Germany practising loading and unloading drills from a Sea King helicopter, soaked by rain accelerated like bullets by the downdraft of the blades. I visited a dive show a few years ago, and was shocked by just how many companies were offering ‘liveaboard’ holidays in tropical locations: the Maldives, the Seychelles, Egypt, Mexico, the Galapagos islands. But how were they to get there? Ocean warming and ocean acidification are the two biggest threats to tropical reefs, and long haul flights are one of the most polluting ways to travel. Anyone taking these trips may as well have packed a hammer in their luggage to smash the reefs once they got there. I have never seen a coral reef in person, the experience kept at a distance and mediated through photographs and television. I may never see one, but by not flying, by bearing witness to the problems that the natural world – including us – face and how they may be solved, my grandson may yet have the opportunity to do so.

There are wonders in our waters, despite our nature-depleted status. We have basking shark, the second largest fish in the world. We have leatherback turtles as summer visitors, along with sunfish. We have grey seals, common around our coast with 95% of the European population and 40% of the world population residing in our waters. At smaller scales we have nudibranchs such as the violet sea slug, the orange-clubbed sea slug, and molluscs such as the blue-rayed limpet, hunkered down in their pits in the stalks of kelp. With all these jewels their small size allows them to be overlooked.

I have my own treasured moments immersed in nature in the UK; moments that hang in the memory like Christmas tree lights sparkling in the darkness of a winter night. Harlyn Beach in Cornwall, newly married and picnicking with my wife and young children on Wednesday 11th August 1999, the temperature falling and the sky darkening towards eclipse. Just after 11am, a fire juggler emerged to light what would have been the brief window of totality, had not the cloud cover conspired to hide the eclipsing sun. Diving the wreck of the James Eagan Layne, a World War two liberty ship and swimming along the bottom of what would have been the hold, the ribs curving up either side, stripped bare of hull plates long ago corroded to rust, the ribs enclosing me as if in a cathedral, with shoals of pollack and a solitary cuckoo wrasse as congregation. Or the squeal of discovery, wide-eyed with a broad grin and gesticulating towards the spot on finding a badger sett when walking with one of my daughters in the local woods; a response sometimes parodied back to me when she wants to show her excitement over something.

‘Wild isles’ has five episodes broadcast on TV, starting with the first ‘our precious isles’, followed by episodes on woodlands, grasslands, freshwater and ocean. There is, controversially, a sixth episode of ‘wild isles’ called ‘saving our wild isles’ released online through the BBC’s iPlayer service. The controversy arose because it was wrongly reported that this sixth episode had been pulled from broadcast and relegated to an online only presentation. The allegation was that the episode with its emphasis on the state of nature and the work needed to restore it was too political a message, provoking as it might the question ‘who’s fault is this?’. The BBC said that this was not the case and the episode had always been planned for an online-only delivery. This, I think, is a lost opportunity. I have written before about how important our relationship to nature is, both for ourselves, and for motivating action to protect it; we protect what we know and love, springing to its defence when it is threatened. A programme that shows both the threats and how to respond positively to them would be a powerful call to action.

Citizenship – the status of belonging to a country – goes beyond what is written on a birth certificate or passport. Surely being a good citizen involves more than blind acceptance of how things are now. It involves pointing out where the faults and failings lie; it is, in fact, a disservice to our home – country and planet – not to do so. For if we do not say ‘this is wrong: this should not stand’ are we not then complicit in the damage being done? And that brings us to the key question: do we want to be responsible for perpetuating the problem or responsible for solving it? We all make a choice. We all get to live with the consequences, good or bad, of that choice. So we must choose wisely.

How you can make a difference:

  • If you’re in the UK, then see the Save Our Wild Isles website, film trailer and support the People’s plan for nature.
  • If you’re not in the UK, then search for organisations in your area. What can you do to preserve the natural world local to you? Research for one or two actions you can take that will make a difference. Systemic change is needed (e.g. no new fossil fuel extraction), but individual actions are also important.
  • Experience it. Get outside and feel the rain on your face or the wind in your hair. Watch a bee harvesting pollen from a flower or a squirrel foraging in woodland. Listen to the birds or the whisper of surf across shingle. Breathe it in. Breathe.

MPAs: Protected, highly protected, or paper parks?

Fishing vessel hauling a catch of sardines. Image courtesy: Nicolas Job / @theOceanAgency
Fishing vessel hauling a catch of sardines. Image courtesy: Nicolas Job / @theOceanAgency

They say experience is learning from your own mistakes, while wisdom is learning from the mistakes of others. The Republic of Ireland is in the early stages of developing and implementing a network of marine protected areas (MPAs). The Fair Seas campaign has identified sixteen potential sites for MPAs to meet the 30 by 30 goal – 30% of land and sea protected by 2030. Their assessment is an impressive piece of work, with the areas chosen to maximise the conservation value based on the distributions of fifteen species of whales and dolphins, thirty-eight species of seabirds, sixteen species of sharks and rays, seven species of commercially caught fish, and eleven other species that act as indicators for particular habitats. The foreword to the assessment argues for a core of sites to be fully protected so that there is a reference against which protection, recovery, and management actions can be judged, and some sites where activities such as fishing would be allowed.

Turn the clock back to the early 2010s, when the UK first aimed to set up an ‘ecologically coherent and well-managed network’ of MPAs. Many organisations contributed data and expert opinion to a consultation, which resulted in a recommended network of over 100 sites. The government announced an initial phase that established 27 sites in English waters which, unsurprisingly, provoked a stream of criticism on the gap between plan and reality. Then came a second phase of 23 sites, and a third phase of 41 sites. Each phase greeted by disappointment from conservation organisations on the scale of provision, and criticism or concern from industry groups on their impact. The original plan was for some of these sites to be reference areas where all damaging activities were banned, sometimes called marine reserves or no-take zones. This was not implemented, due to a perception by those most affected by the higher protected status that they were being excluded from the process.

Marine protected areas have the potential for widespread benefits. Increasing ecological resilience through protecting areas means that these areas can better withstand the stresses and impacts placed upon them. In turn, they continue to provide benefits such as fisheries spillover, where fish within the areas breed and bolster the populations outside the site’s boundaries. The end result is coastal fisheries that are more productive and more sustainable. The Fair Seas assessment explicitly includes areas that are spawning and nursery grounds for both cod and herring. Clean and diverse seas can increase tourism and recreation, helping local economies and well-being. Depending on the site, they can also form part of a nature-based solution to tackling climate change by providing coastal protection or carbon capture.

In November 2018 there were “314 designated MPAs protecting 24% of UK waters compared to 217 sites covering 8% of UK waters in 2012”. This seems like good progress towards the 30 by 30 goal for the UK, but much depends on what we mean by ‘protected’, and how well that protection is enforced. In the UK MPAs are designated based on ‘features of conservation interest’ – FOCI – which are the species and habitats the area is designed to protect. Other activities like fishing and dredging are permitted within the area provided that they don’t affect the features under protection, or unless they’re restricted by some other regulation, for example, where bottom trawling in seagrass meadows is prohibited in some areas.

So is this really protection or is it simply a lesser form of exploitation? The British Ecological Society (BES) says that most protected areas are not delivering in terms of providing real protection. Oceana and Global Fishing Watch found that in 2019 97% of UK MPAs were either being dredged or subject to bottom trawling.

How can we say these areas are protected if we allow damaging activities to take place within them? They’re created based on particular features but it’s a system, not isolated features. It’s all very well to say that activity X is fine because it doesn’t directly affect that feature, but that doesn’t help if activity X still damages the species and habitats that connect with it, and on which those features may depend.

Humans of the middle stone age lived on Doggerland, a low-lying area of tundra and marsh between what is now France and England. The end of the last ice age saw this land bridge disappear beneath the sea. Dogger bank, an extensive area of shallow sandbanks, overlays what was Doggerland and is home to sandeels, a vital food source for many seabirds, as well as whales and dolphins. Cod feed on the sandeels and breed here, boosting the stock for commercial fishers to harvest. In 2020 Greenpeace dropped granite boulders into this area, publicising the precise location in an attempt to prevent bottom trawling. In June 2022 a new byelaw was introduced to ban bottom trawling in this particular MPA, crucially after extensive consultation with the fishing industry. Where restrictions are based on dialogue, they have a much higher prospect of being followed, but this is only one of four MPAs with new bye-laws to restrict trawling. Four, out of hundreds.

But the more activities we seek to restrict the more that brings us into conflict with others such as fishers for example. We may look at the ocean and see an open expanse of water, but there are many competing demands on ocean space. Pipelines and cables run along the seafloor, bringing gas and electricity ashore, distributing it within and between countries. Telecommunications links carry data streams to connect our world. Renewable energy stakes its claim – offshore wind above the waves and tidal energy below. Fishers, unlike farmers, don’t own the grounds their livelihoods depend on, and so there is a spatial squeeze, a potential displacement away from areas traditionally fished. A report by the National Federation of Fishermen’s Organisations (NFFO) and the Scottish Fisherman’s Federation (SFF) looked at this spatial squeeze, comparing past conditions in 2000 to the current situation (2020-21), and to three future scenarios, one in 2030 and two in 2050, each with different levels of restriction for fishing in protected areas. In what it calls the ‘future 3 (worst case)’ scenario bottom trawling is banned in all protected areas that were designated for seafloor species or habitats. But is this a ‘worst case’? Should this not be the baseline case, that where an area is selected to protect seafloor species and habitats, that all activities (like trawling) that damage them are banned? Otherwise, how can we honestly claim that we are protecting them?

This gives me some discomfort personally, perhaps leaving me open to a charge of hypocrisy since I do eat fish. My diet is a little strange in that it is mostly vegan but with occasional dairy, and some sustainably sourced fish. Mostly vegan to reduce climate change emissions, some dairy because I’m not going to expect my 89 year old father to have a supply of oat milk on hand for when I visit, and sustainable fish because it’s generally a low-carbon source of protein. When I shop I’ll start by looking for the Marine Stewardship Council logo and then filter options using the Marine Conservation Society’s Good Fish Guide for fishing method and area. There’s not always enough detail on the labelling to make a completely informed decision, but I do my best. Some of the most sustainable fishing tends to be done by the inshore boats under ten metres in length that historically have not received an equitable share of quota allocation, despite their sustainability. Part of the progress towards conserving biodiversity is the ending of subsidy for damaging activities and providing incentives to the sustainable ones. Correcting the quota inequity for these inshore boats fishing sustainably would be a positive step as part of that.

The spatial squeeze on fishing grounds is likely to come from two main sources: nature conservation and renewable energy developments, yet both are of vital significance to the wider population. The 30 by 30 target is critical if we are to tackle the twin threats of climate change and biodiversity loss, but it becomes a self-delusion unless we are actually protecting those areas we count towards it. The BES report found that some land-based areas were being counted despite them not originally being created for biodiversity (e.g. Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty), and despite them not delivering in terms of protecting biodiversity. Unless these areas meaningfully contribute to nature recovery, to providing benefits for both people and nature, then it becomes nothing more than governmental greenwashing to count these towards the 30 by 30 target. They become yet another policy initiative, loudly announced then left to wither for lack of political will or funding; a shield to hide behind when accountability for the lack of any real progress is sought.

Callum Roberts, professor of marine conservation at the University of Exeter, has criticised the lack of real protection, calling areas that are not effectively protected or managed ‘paper parks’. He does, however, sound a note of caution: if we set targets for the quality as well as the quantity of protection then we risk losing the consensus to provide that protection if those targets are set too high. But that simply brings us back to our original question: what value are protected areas if they are not protected in practice?

Another issue is that the 30 by 30 goal doesn’t apply to the high seas – the area that covers nearly half the ocean surface, areas outside national jurisdiction. That’s a lot of ocean where damage can still be done, a spatial loophole for exploitation to continue, if agreement can’t be reached at the UN’s Intergovernmental Conference on Marine Biodiversity of Areas Beyond National Jurisdiction in New York in August 2022.

Language matters. It can determine the boundaries of debate; it can illuminate or deceive. The words chosen to describe something affects how we perceive it. The UK Government is running a consultation (July 2022) to select pilot areas for Highly Protected Marine Areas – HPMAs – with the first HPMAs planned for 2023. There are five pilot sites, two inshore and three offshore, with activities such as construction, dredging, and fishing banned within the boundaries, and the Government saying these areas “will have the highest level of protection in our seas.” So here ‘highly protected’ means actually protecting an area, while areas that are merely ‘protected’ are still open to damaging activities. The language distorts the reality, and we continue to reassure ourselves that we are doing more than we are.

Properly protecting areas means a spatial squeeze on fishing, and fishing effort must go somewhere. If it is displaced to other areas then these will be fished harder unless the beneficial effects of MPAs are enough to compensate, and there is a time lag between the application of protection and the benefits of it. The only other possibility is that the capacity of the industry reduces, and that’s not something that should be taken lightly – these are people’s livelihoods, people’s lives. Fishing is not a job description, it’s wrapped together with identity. It’s family history – fathers, brothers, uncles fishing before them. It’s communities, with a shared history, and sometimes encompasses a shared experience of tragedy. Fishing is a dangerous occupation. But not reducing capacity, should it be needed, just means that fishing communities suffer the more severe effects resulting from climate change and biodiversity loss alongside everyone else. No one wins.

There is still a case for areas to have different levels of protection. One size does not fit all and a diversity of approach is beneficial, but the default MPA should be a fully protected one. Protection should mean real protection. We gain nothing if we think that the lines on a map have meaning without the enforcement to achieve the basis for which they were created. We can truly protect areas and receive the benefits they provide, or we can continue to delude ourselves that we are doing something, thinking that we are making progress against the threats we face, until the damage is done, and it is too late. The Republic of Ireland is standing at a point of divergence, two path of marine conservation before it: protection in name, or protection in practice. Let us hope it chooses the path less travelled.

Restoration and recovery: saving our seagrass

Seagrass in the Isles of Scilly, Cornwall, UK. Image courtesy Michiel Vos (https://www.instagram.com/an_bollenessor) / Ocean Agency Image Bank.
Seagrass in the Isles of Scilly, Cornwall, UK. Image courtesy Michiel Vos / Ocean Agency Image Bank.

This is the third post in a three-part series on seagrass:

“May you live in interesting times” the phrase says, thought (wrongly) to originate from a Chinese curse. A curse because only the bad times were interesting; normality and stability mundane by definition. In that sense, we are certainly living in interesting times, beset by both climate and biodiversity crises, ecologically overdrawn and living beyond the capacity of our planet to recuperate and regenerate on human timescales. I would counter with two other quotes, one a Japanese proverb: “fall seven times, stand up eight”, meaning it does not matter how many setbacks you have on your chosen path, only that you choose to persist. And secondly, from Anthony Trollope: “A small daily task, if it be really daily, will beat the labours of a spasmodic Hercules”. Habits are a powerful thing, their results build, their outcomes compound. Small, repeated actions make a difference. In conservation, it can be easy to become discouraged, the rewards for our labours offset to the future, as yet unseen. Yes, seagrass is in difficulty, but decline is not inevitable. We can persist. We can make positive choices habitual. The meadows can be restored.

The first stage in restoration is not restoration, it is stopping the damage that is still being done. If the bath is overflowing then we turn off the taps and pull the plug before starting to mop the floor. In the UK context that means, primarily, tackling the issue of poor water quality by dealing with the capacity issues of the ageing wastewater systems, and dealing effectively with other sources of pollution.

Direct damage from fishing and boating needs to end. No one would object to a vessel anchoring in a seagrass bed in an emergency or where safety is at stake, but when there is a choice of where to anchor seagrass meadows should be avoided. Eco-moorings are not cheap, but do allow boats to use areas without causing damage. Fishing within seagrass meadows using gear towed along the seabed should not be permitted. There is no way to justify the damage done to such important and sensitive habitats. This exclusion is already being done in some areas of the UK coast. The organisations responsible for managing English waters within six nautical miles of the coast are the IFCAs (Inshore Fisheries and Conservation Authorities). The IFCA for the Eastern region already has byelaws in place to ban bottom trawling in protected seagrass beds in its area. Another approach would be to recognise the importance of seagrass beds by making them protected areas where this has not already been done. The EU Habitats directive lists species and habitats for which protected status should be given. While seagrass is not listed amongst the species some of the habitats that seagrass is found in are listed, meaning that they should be protected as Special Areas of Conservation (SACs). In the UK the situation is a little fluid as the post-brexit regulatory system is still something of work in progress.

Banning fishing from seagrass meadows may seem draconian. Fishers still need to make a living and fishing is statistically one of the most dangerous occupations, but with their role in capturing and storing carbon and the positive benefits to fisheries from their function as nurseries, these meadows should be seen as key national infrastructure in tackling the climate and biodiversity crises. Not all national infrastructure is steel and concrete; some is green and growing, and I say that even though I find the concept of natural capital and ecosystem services problematic, as I explored in the extinction of experience post.

Another pre-requisite for restoration is to find out what we already have. Our existing knowledge of seagrass distriution is patchy, and there are still some surprises to be had. Surveying for a restoration project found previously unknown seagrass meadows in the Fal and Helford estuaries, and Mounts Bay, Cornwall, covering an area of 172 hectares. To put this in context, this represents nearly three and a half percent of all the seagrass meadows in the UK.

Drones are increasingly being used for aerial surveys, with volunteers and researchers ‘ground-truthing’ the observations to confirm the presence of seagrass. An American study is using field visits and artificial intelligence to detect the presence of the Labyrinthula wasting disease in images from seagrass beds along 1700 miles of coast, and then relating this data to environmental conditions such as unusual changes in water temperature. Finding the factors that make seagrass prone to outbreaks of Labyrinthula means that we’re better able to protect what we have.

Restoration projects have been completed or are underway in many regions of the world, as this twitter thread from Dr. Richard Lilley, director of Project Seagrass explains. Different methods have been tried, but one general principle is that scale matters: the larger the restoration area, the more likely the restoration is to succeed. Seagrass is a foundation species, an ecosystem engineer; the establishment of new areas modifies the existing habitat, altering the water flow and sediment chemistry.

Milford Haven waterway at the south-west tip of Wales is one of the world’s deepest natural harbours. Like many harbours around the southern edge of the UK it is a ria, a river valley submerged by rising seas at the end of the last ice age. Tankers visiting the oil refineries and liquid natural gas terminals on the banks of the estuary, as well as ferries and cruise ships using the waterway, make this a busy area for shipping. And yet, there is seagrass here. At Dale, in the north-west corner, two hectares of seagrass have been restored. Small hessian bags, each containing 50 seagrass seeds, and filled with sediment collected from areas close to existing meadows were anchored to lines along the seabed by divers. Each bag one metre apart along the line, each line one metre apart, giving a grid of possible new plants one hundred metres square. Do this twice and you potentially have two hectares of new meadow. While shoots grew from almost all of the bags, the germination rates of the seeds was low, at under five per cent. This is one of the reasons why natural regeneration is slow.

Restoration is not cheap. Each hectare at Dale needed half a million seeds, collected by divers from existing meadows, processed and packed into the hessian bags. Once packed, the lines of bags needed divers again to lay them on the seabed. This is time-consuming and expensive, and so the search for cheaper, more efficient methods of restoration goes on. Scale matters. Larger restoration projects are more likely to succeed but that raises the quantity of resources needed for the restoration, and multiple organisations may come together to partner in common cause.

The ‘Save our seabed’ project is a two-and-a-half million pound project to protect five special areas of conservation (SACs), and is implemented by five organisations – Natural England (the project lead), the ocean conservation trust, based at the National Marine Aquarium in Plymouth, the Marine Conservation Society, the Royal Yachting Association, and Plymouth City Council. The project aims to restore a total of eight hectares of seagrass in Plymouth Sound and the Solent, as well as restoring seagrass beds in the the Isles of Scilly, the Essex Estuaries SAC, and the Fal and Helford estuaries.

Multiple restoration sites means that multiple methods of restoration can be explored and tested. In Plymouth Sound, the seed bags are delivered by boat. A four metre tube guides the seed bags on their descentto the seabed without the need for a diver. Keeping a steady speed and dropping one bag a second into the tube gives a spacing of around half a metre between them on the seabed.

Another approach would be to plant seedlings rather than seeds, neatly sidestepping the problem of low germination rates from seed. The ocean conservation trust has developed a seagrass nursery at the National Marine Aquarium, with the first seedlings being produced in June 2022. These seedlings will later be planted directly into the seabed by divers.

Restoration Forth in Scotland also has uses a multi-agency, collaborative approach for a joint project between the ecology centre, the Scottish Seabird Centre, and WWF-UK, aiming to restore four hectares of seagrass in the Firth of Forth. But here the restoration of the seagrass meadows is to be accompanied by the restoration of another ecosystem engineer: oyster beds. Oyster beds are ideal neighbours for seagrass, each oyster filtering up to two hundred litres of water each day, improving the clarity of the water and reducing nitrogen levels, as well as capturing carbon themselves.

But restoration can also be more community-led, more locally focused. The charity Seawilding is restoring seagrass and oyster beds in Loch Craignish. Here, a quarter of a hectare of seagrass was restored in 2021 with another quarter of a hectare planned for 2022. This may seem small in comparison to the other projects, but they train local volunteers and community groups to help in the restoration, and with surveys of the loch suggesting an area of eighty hectares for potential restoration, those volunteers could be making contributions to their community for a while yet. Seawilding, like the Restoration Forth project, is also restoring oyster beds alongside seagrass, recognising the additional benefits from restoring both together.

Many environmental problems are interlinked. One issue may affect another, which affects another, which branches off to affect yet another, but also links back to the first. Trying to fix these issues can sometimes feel like trying to untangle that set of Christmas tree lights that you were sure you packed away so carefully last year. But issues being interlinked is both a barrier and an opportunity. Start to solve one and you start to solve the others. Work on more than one simultaneously and progress builds on progress. We need our seagrass meadows to be healthy to capture and store carbon; that means we also need to tackle water quality and pollution issues. Changes in agricultural practices high in a river catchment may reduce nutrients from farming entering the river, but may also help to reduce flooding further downstream. Improving the infrastructure of our sewage and wastewater systems reduces not just the nutrients released, but also lessens the release of any potential pathogens as well. Yes, we are living in interesting times. The world turns and change is inevitable, but by our persistence, by our actions, we can make positive changes.

Further information and how you can help:

Ignorance, indifference and pollution: seagrass under threat

Small-spotted catshark amongst seagrass, Helford River, Cornwall
Small-spotted catshark (Scyliorhinus canicula) in seagrass, Helford, Cornwall.
Image courtesy of Shannon Moran (Instagram, twitter) and the Ocean Agency Image Bank.

This is the second post in a three-part series on seagrass:

  • Part one: “Seagrass – the undervalued ally” – what is seagrass, and why should we care about it?
  • Part two: what are the threats that seagrass faces?
  • Part three: what can we do about it?

In our attempt to tackle the climate crisis we have an ally alongside us: seagrass. But our attempt is half-hearted. We are doing too little at much too slow a pace, and working against ourselves with our treatment of our ally. Seagrass is vitally important as part of the biosphere we inhabit and ultimately depend on, but unfortunately like many parts of that biosphere, it is subject to our indifference and carelessness.

There are some specific ways in which we’re damaging seagrass, but also some more generic reasons why it is under threat. First, is our general ignorance of it. We lack the awareness of what it is and why it is important. Many in the UK would be surprised to learn that we actually have seagrass here, thinking of it as an inhabitant of warmer climates, but even there unless people have direct experience of it or dependency on it – fisherman or those involved in tourism for example – then the importance of seagrass can still be discounted. People protect the things and places that they care about and connect to, but increasingly, people have a remoteness from the natural world that thwarts that emotional connection.

Secondly, restoring and protecting something requires information, the information to give answers to the questions: how much is there? How much have we lost? What condition is it in? What is damaging it and how can we correct that? Too often, that information simply isn’t there in enough detail and without it, we struggle to do the right thing.

A third factor, and one that goes to the heart of so much that is wrong in our dysfunctional relationship with the natural world, is to recognize that society and ecology are intimately interlinked. For society to persist, to function well, to provide us with the material things we need to live, we need to understand that society (and us) are part of ecology, not separate from it. We need to link the ecological to the social and economic. The natural world is not outside society or the economy; it envelops them. We do not and cannot exist without it. Ignorance of our dependency does not remove that dependency, it only frustrates our ability to make good choices.

We have lost much of the seagrass around the UK, perhaps as much as over 90% since the start of the twentieth century. Some was lost after the first world war, with another significant loss in the 1930s due to a wasting disease. Still more has been lost since the 1980s. Seagrass is a shallow water habitat, and this proximity to the coast is the source of many of the problems facing it.

Poor water quality is probably the most critical factor. Eutrophication, an excess of nutrients in the water, can harm seagrass, particularly if the nutrient in question is nitrogen. Too much nitrogen favours the growth of algae at the expense of seagrass. This algae might grow on the seagrass leaves as epiphytes, and while some algal growth on the leaves is normal and beneficial to the meadow overall, too much is a problem. The algae could also be present as microscopic plants in the water above and around the seagrass, acting to reduce the amount of light reaching it and reducing its growth.

There is another, more fundamental way that too much nitrogen can affect seagrass, by making it more susceptible to disease through causing an imbalance in the plant’s internal chemistry. There is an ideal ratio between how much nitrogen and how much carbon there is within seagrass. One form of nitrogen within the plant is nitrate. Too much nitrate distorts this ideal ratio, reducing the amount of a key group of molecules called phenolic compounds. It is these compounds that help to protect the seagrass from a wasting disease caused by the protist Labyrinthula, the same wasting disease responsible for devastating the UK’s seagrass meadows in the 1930s.

So where does the nitrogen come from? It can come from sewage discharged untreated into rivers or coastal waters. Despite these sewage discharges being legal in the UK under certain conditions, there is increasing public concern around water quality, and prosecutions where those discharges have not met the legal conditions set for them. Even treated sewage can be high in nitrates when discharged. It can also come from agricultural sources such as excess fertiliser washed from fields.

Direct physical disturbance is another way seagrass meadows can be damaged. This can be from the result of wave and storm action, direct damage from fishing gear such as trawls, or from boats mooring and anchoring where seagrass is present.

Successful anchoring doesn’t work by weight alone, but by keeping the pull on the anchor along the seabed as much as possible. The line connecting the anchor to the boat is called the rode, and a boat where the rode consists solely of metal chain will need to let out a length of chain at least four times the water depth. Chain is heavy and expensive, and so some rodes have a shorter length of chain connected to the anchor with the remainder of the rode as rope. The skipper on these boats will need to let out an anchor line that’s at least six times the water depth.

The anchor drags along the seabed before it digs in, ploughing a trough through the meadow. Once the anchor has dug in, or set, the chain closest to the anchor will lie along the seabed. This is why the length of rode is so long compared to the water depth – to keep that pull on the anchor along the seabed, digging it in further. As the tide or wind changes the boat will swing around its anchor and the chain will be dragged around, leaving a halo of disturbed and damaged seagrass around the anchor.

Traditional moorings damage seagrass in a similar way. They have a weight on the seabed and a chain that connects to a rope leading to the buoy on the surface. A boat moors to the buoy, and any chain lying on the seabed is dragged as the boat is moved around by wind and tide. Studland bay in Dorset, England, has seagrass meadows and is home to the two species of seahorse found in UK waters, but is also a very popular area for recreational boating and tourism. As a result, attempts to protect the seagrass beds have been a source of controversy over a number of years. In May 2019, the bay was designated a marine conservation zone (MCZ), and in June 2022 a voluntary no-anchoring zone was introduced in the southern end of the bay where the majority of the seagrass meadows are found. Ten eco-moorings have now been installed as part of a joint project between the seahorse trust and boatfolk. These work by having a large vertical component that screws into the seabed and then a flexible connection between that and the buoy on the surface. With no chain lying on the seabed there is nothing to damage the seagrass.

Recent research has revealed a new way in which seagrass might be being damaged: noise. We think of noise pollution in the oceans as primarily a problem for animals, such as disrupting the communication and echolocation of whales and dolphins. It seems strange that noise would affect something we assume doesn’t have a sense of hearing, but while plants don’t need to hear it’s an advantage to sense gravity, to know which way is up or down. Exposure to sound in the lab produced changes in the starch-filled structures called amyloplasts that are used to sense gravity in seagrass, reducing their number and leaving them mis-shapen and with holes in their surface.

But we need to treat these results with caution. This is one study, with one species, with sound exposure levels much higher than are likely to be normally experienced in natural environments. The sound levels used were 157 decibels for up to 120 hours. For comparison, a jet engine at takeoff is 140 decibels. I’m not confident of what condition I would be in after five days of exposure to sound of that intensity. So the question remains: seagrass can be damaged by noise, but at what levels does that damage start to occur, and are those levels experienced in nature? For what activities might we need to take noise pollution into account?

Seagrass is being damaged and lost, but it’s not inevitable. Seagrass meadows are also being restored, and it’s these efforts to restore them that I’ll look at in the next article. The damage and loss are the result of choices that we, personally and as a society, choose to make. We can make better choices.

Seagrass: the undervalued ally

Breaking waves on the north coast of Crete seen through an archway.
Breaking waves on the north coast of Crete seen through an archway.
© Duncan Greenhill 2015

This is the first post in a short series on seagrass, one of the most important yet undervalued marine habitats:

I let out a squeal, or as much of a squeal as was possible with a snorkel in my mouth. It was 2015; I was on Crete for the EMSEA conference, and I had made myself the promise that I would snorkel or dive every day. The hotel entrance opened out through an arch on to a coast road that in places crumbled to the water. A groyne of piled stone pointed north into the Mediterranean, the area nearest the shore flattened and smoothed for a few cars to park. There was no beach, only a strip of rough stone rubble between the road and the plain and unpromising patch of sea. I sat on the groyne to fit my fins and mask and then belly-flopped forward into the water. A few fin strokes and it was below me: seagrass. And so the squeal of joy. The canopy was short, no more than 30 centimetres. A small group of ornate wrasse kept me company as I explored, and a lone red mullet watched my approach from within the fronds. Later, diving on the last day before flying home, I would spot another patch, but not be able to reach it. I was at twenty metres, the depth limit of my diver qualification, the seagrass another six or eight metres below me in the clear water.

There’s a perception we have here in the UK of seagrass: that it’s found in warmer waters only; unusual, exotic perhaps, with turtles and dugongs grazing on meadows dappled by tropical sunlight. That’s the perception, but it’s wrong. We do have seagrass here, but like seagrass across the globe it’s in trouble, and it needs our help.

So, what is seagrass? Well, it’s not algae, it’s not seaweed. It’s also not a grass. It’s a group of flowering plants, loosely related, that have made the return evolutionary journey from land to ocean on at least three separate occasions. It’s also an overlooked habitat with a profound importance for both us and the natural world. It acts as nursery areas for fish, here in the UK and across the world, where millions of people depend on coastal fisheries for their livelihoods and their main source of protein. Seagrass meadows absorb and store more carbon than forests on land, some 35 to 40 times more. We need to be looking more to our reservoirs of ‘blue carbon’ if we are to mitigate the worst effects of climate change.

Seagrass meadows hold a treasure trove of life. They have their ‘stars’ – the manatees, turtles and seahorses – but to focus solely on these is to neglect the richness of biodiversity within them. The seagrass fronds form habitats of their own, a three-dimensional complexity that gives shelter to many, and the surface of their leaves provides a home to algae and sedentary animals. The algae makes the meadow more productive than it would be with seagrass alone, and provides food for other residents. The sediment of seagrass meadows supports many species of clams and mussels, filter-feeding and incorporating organic matter into it. Fish are abundant, using the meadow for shelter and food. Over fifty species of fish were recorded from a single seagrass meadow in North Wales. Some species reside within for their whole lives. Others, like cod and pollack, make use of the meadow when young and leave for other habitats as they mature. Still others commute, using the meadow for refuge and visiting other nearby areas to feed. Crabs, shrimps and lobsters also live in the meadows, with the larger species again using them as nurseries while they grow and mature. These nurseries boost the adult populations, and so fishers directly benefit from seagrass meadows through larger catches. Lose the meadows and you lose that nursery area, lose that benefit.

There are around seventy species of seagrass, the exact number depending on who you ask. Taxonomy is an active branch of science, and classification is a moving target, with species classified and re-classified as new information or evolutionary relationships become apparent. As well as its more familiar location in the tropics and subtropics, seagrass is found in cooler, more temperate seas both further north and south from the equator. One species in Europe has been found above the Arctic circle, but none have made it to the Antarctic continent.

The depths that seagrass can grow at depends on how well the light can penetrate. In clearer waters, they can be found down to sixty metres. Around UK coasts five or six metres is more typical; these waters may harbour a wealth of marine life, much of it often overlooked, but they are not renowned for their clarity. There are two species found here. Eelgrass – Zostera marina – is found below the low water mark and up into the intertidal. Dwarf eelgrass – Zostera noltii – is found almost exclusively in the zone between low and high tides.

Seagrass spreads by growing horizontal stems through the sediment called rhizomes, with vertical stems at intervals, from which the strap-like leaves are buoyed up into the water. Together the rhizome and the above-ground stem are called a ramet. As the rhizomes extend and new ramets are formed the meadow expands. Effectively, the plant spreads itself by cloning. This means that, genetically speaking, a meadow may be made up of only a few individual plants, with each plant covering a relatively large area. In one meadow in the Baltic sea one particular genotype – plants with the same genetic makeup – occupied over half an hectare and was estimated at over one thousand years old based on the rate of growth. But this has its disadvantages. Identical genetics means identical susceptibility to disease and pathogens.

Living in seawater presents extra challenges for seagrass. Gasses diffuse more slowly in water than they do in air and seagrass, like all plants, needs carbon dioxide to photosynthesise. When carbon dioxide dissolves in water it quickly reacts to form bicarbonate ions and then carbonate ions. This is a bonus for the calcifiers of the ocean, like the corals and crustaceans, which use carbonate to build their hard skeletons and shells, but it means the dissolved concentrations of the gas are low. Seagrasses have evolved to use the more abundant bicarbonate ion for photosynthesis instead. Another trick they have developed is to use their own wastes, the carbon dioxide produced by their own respiration, in photosynthesis, which is transported through gas-filled spaces in the leaves called lacunae. These lacunae give buoyancy to the leaves and allow oxygen to reach the roots more easily, an advantage for roots binding the plant to sediments often low in oxygen.

Seagrass roots help to stabilize these sediments, and their leaves help to slow water currents, but it’s a delicate balance. Too much current or wave action and the sediment can be churned up, resuspended and transported away. Too little current and the plants may find that the flow of nutrients to photosynthesise and grow is not sufficient.

Seagrass is under threat, and sensitive to disturbance and damage. In the UK, we have lost the majority of our seagrass meadows. Estimates vary, but since the start of the 20th century losses for the UK could be over 90%. In the 1930s a wasting disease devastated the meadows, and recent research puts the loss at another 44% since then, with most of that occurring since the 1980s. This means that the urgency for protecting seagrass is here and now, precisely at the time we need those meadows the most to tackle the climate crisis. Seagrass meadows, damaged and degraded, are another warning sign that we are on the wrong path if we wish to live sustainably.

Seagrass – it’s less that we ignore it and more that we’re ignorant of it, ignorant in the sense that we lack knowledge. We think, if we think of it at all, that it’s somewhere else and remote from us, that it’s unimportant, that it’s just something else pretty to look at when we’re on holiday. It’s not. Seagrass helps to feed many millions of people around the world. It helps to protect us from our folly of ever increasing carbon emissions. It’s our ally. We should treat it as such.

The basking shark: sanctuary at last?

It is 1975. I am eleven years old, and my parents, my twin sister and I are going to the cinema to watch Jaws. My favourite TV program is The Undersea World of Jacques Cousteau, and it has given me a fascination for the ocean, despite living about as far from it as you can get in the UK. I have read about this film, read about how people have reacted to it, and heard about the ‘eyeball’ moment. I am unsure, frightened even. It’s irrational, but it’s a feeling I can’t shake. Not a fear of sharks, but a fear of my own reaction: what if watching this film changes how I feel about the ocean? What if I no longer feel at home in the water, always looking for what may be about to burst through a haze of poor visibility to harm me? Thankfully, the film did not change me, and while I do sometimes have dreams where I am underwater with sharks, they are not nightmares. The sharks in these dreams do not attack me. I feel no fear, only curiosity and wonder.

Original artwork of a basking shark feeding
A basking shark feeds
© 2018 Duncan Greenhill

We have many species of sharks in the waters around the UK, from the smallspotted catshark with its puppy-like cuteness, to the cobalt beauty of the blue shark, to the imposing majesty of the basking shark, the largest around these coasts. It is the second largest fish in the world; only the whale shark grows larger. Six to eight metres long is a typical size for a basking shark, although they can grow up to twelve metres and weigh four tonnes. Despite their size, they pose no danger to humans, feeding only on plankton filtered from the water. Yet every summer the tabloid papers will, at some point, run a story along the lines of ‘monster sharks stalk our beaches’, seeing all sharks as a danger.

Four basking sharks swim in formation in the sea of the Hebrides, their dorsal fins slicing the surface, and light from the sun dancing patterns like camouflage across their backs. From May to October they will feed at the surface like this, the behaviour that gives them their name of ‘basking’ shark. They feed on the spring bloom of plankton, whose growth is boosted by the warming water and longer days. The sharks swim with mouths agape; they are ‘ram’ feeders, forward motion providing the flow of water across their gill rakers, the comb-like structures that line their mouth and catch their prey. Their mouths are only closed to swallow the plankton filtered from the sea. This is a small group, but small groups are not uncommon. The groups can be very much larger. In 2005, an aerial survey off the north-east coast of the USA recorded an aggregation of almost 1400 animals.

The islands of North Uist, Benbecula, and South Uist mark the western border between the sea of the Hebrides and the Atlantic Ocean. The Isle of Skye guards the north-east corner, while the west coast of the Scottish mainland runs down the eastern edge to the Isle of Mull. This sea is one of three hotspots, three areas where the basking sharks congregate and are frequently seen; the others are around the Isle of Man, and around the south-west tip of the UK.

The four sharks swim in proximity, sometimes closely following each other, sometimes swimming in echelon formation, where each shark swims near the pectoral fin of the shark in front, like the ‘V’ of a flock of migrating geese in flight. For an animal so large they are still something of an enigma, with still so much unknown about their behaviour and biology. Perhaps there is an energetic efficiency in swimming like this, always useful when your prey can be concentrated in patches many kilometres apart. Perhaps the sharks position themselves to take advantage of the prey missed by the sharks ahead of them. In European seas copepods are a common prey item, and later life stages can ‘jump’ as they detect pressure changes in the water from an approaching predator. For some, this will be an ‘out of the frying pan, and into the fire’ moment as their jumps place them in the path of the sharks following behind.

Such a large animal feeding on small prey means that it must find and eat large quantities. Spring blooms are one source, but these pass. There is another: oceanic fronts. In summer the surface waters in some areas can warm up, becoming less dense, and ‘floating’ on top of a colder, denser layer. This summer stratification means that nutrients in the upper layer that fuel the growth of phytoplankton – the microscopic algae that the copepods feed on – are quickly used up, and plankton growth slows. The density change acts as a border between the two layers, causing a paucity of nutrients close to the surface as they are used up and not replaced.

In other areas the water is not separated into layers. There is no barrier between the deeper and surface waters. Nutrients are present from surface to seabed. Where these two types of water – stratified and well-mixed – meet is called an oceanic front. This is the jackpot for the basking sharks; the plankton thrives here. The sharks will travel long distances to find these fronts and once there will move seemingly in random directions, sometimes for a short time before turning and sometimes for much longer. They are looking for an accumulation of plankton. Mathematicians call this pattern a Lévy walk or Lévy flight. Then, finding that richness of plankton, they will slow and turn more frequently, their movements keeping them inside the patch as much as possible while they feed. The ecologists call this pattern of movement area restricted searching. The plankton may not always be at the surface; they migrate up and down through the water during the day. The sharks will descend from the surface to the bottom and then return, ‘yo-yo’ diving, searching for where the plankton are to be found.

I crossed this Hebridean sea once as a young man, a soldier, on a flat-bottomed military transport ship heading to a firing camp on South Uist where anti-aircraft missiles would be flung at targets towed over the Atlantic. The weather was not kind, and I drank mug after mug of warm, sweet tea in an unsuccessful attempt to ward off seasickness. But these waters have seen real conflict beyond training for the defence of a nation: conflict between man and shark. Blood has been spilled into these waters in the pursuit of profit. A basking shark’s liver can form up to a quarter of its body weight, of which nearly 40% can be an oil called squalene. This oil, derived from the shark’s planktonic prey, functions as both an energy source and for buoyancy, and many deep diving shark species have high concentrations in their liver. The oil, originally used for lighting, was also a valuable engineering and aircraft oil. For over 200 years the sharks were pursued for this oil by fishers from the UK, Ireland and Norway, with harpoon and net. The estimates vary. One study gave the catch in the forty years between 1946 and 1986 as over 77,000 individual sharks caught and processed.

Recovery from such depredation is slow. Despite the number of sharks taken there is only one recorded case of a pregnant female being caught in 1936, who gave birth to six pups, one stillborn, while being towed after capture. Even something as how long gestation lasts is not known with certainty, but is thought to be between one and two years. Small numbers of young on this timescale means that rebuilding populations takes time. While they are no longer actively pursued they are still sometimes caught accidentally as by-catch, by trawling and gill-netting, slowing recovery further.

Sharks congregate where the plankton patches are richest. Some groups are of similar sizes or of the same sex, but where the group is mixed proximity while feeding permits the fulfilling of other biological needs. They follow each other closely, breaking away to swim in parallel. One may approach another by swimming towards its side. Pectoral fins may be bitten. They may breach, leaping upwards out of the water, as great white sharks have been seen to do as part of their courtship behaviour. They will mate in the summer, the male transferring packets of sperm called spermatophores into the female using his claspers, the tubular organs that lie along the body at the base of their pelvic fins. Fertilisation is internal, as is the laying and hatching of the eggs and the development of the young sharks, before their eventual live birth as one-and-a-half metre long miniatures of their parents. The newly-born males will take at least twelve years before they themselves may mate, while the females may be twenty years old before they make their own contribution to the population.

In UK waters, the basking shark has been protected since 1998, but the outlook for the species is not good. The IUCN publishes its red list of threatened species. In the assessments undertaken in 1996, 2000, and 2009 the basking shark was classed as vulnerable. In 2019 and 2021 the assessment listed them in the more serious category of endangered. Conserving species that are mobile, that travel large distances, is difficult because of the size of the area that would need to be protected, but by protecting key areas such as those used for foraging or breeding a positive contribution to their conservation can be made. Satellites can detect the temperature of the ocean, can signpost the existence and development of the oceanic fronts so beneficial to the basking shark. The sea of Hebrides is one area where these fronts are frequently found, and in December 2020 over ten thousand square kilometres of this sea was declared a Nature Conservation Marine Protected Area. This sea, once the scene of carnage for this species is now a haven for it. I hope to sail these waters again one day in my own boat, with basking sharks alongside that match or exceed the 8m length of the hulls; here be monsters, and we are all the richer for having them.

The stories we hear, the stories we tell

Sunset on Gwithian Beach
© 2018 Duncan Greenhill

The relationship we have with nature is critically important, but an extinction of experience is making it dysfunctional. Like many dysfunctional relationships it is shaped by the stories we hear and the stories we tell, to others and ourselves. Stories where the narrative does not always match the truth.

Humans have always told stories to make sense of the world, and stories have both power and magic. The way we see the world is moulded by these stories, how they are presented – how they are framed – and who the story says is the villain and the hero. It all affects our ideas of what is good and bad, right and wrong. Some of the darkest parts of history are characterised by stories that paint some group as an other, as an enemy, stories that then reach horrific expression. The narratives we tell, the stories we choose to live by, will shape how nature will fare when faced with an expected nine billion people on Earth by 2050, and by extension, how we will fare.

As Sylvia Earle has said – “no blue, no green”, meaning that without a healthy ocean there cannot be a healthy, well-functioning planet. And there are many stories we can tell of how the ocean supports us. It gives us breath courtesy of photosynthetic algae expelling oxygen, it feeds us by providing the main source of protein for three billion people. Humans and the ocean are, as the ocean literacy principles state, “inextricably interconnected”. It quenches our thirst and irrigates our crops – much of our freshwater comes from the ocean, evaporated from the surface to fall later on land and start its journey back, carrying the dissolved substances that make the ocean salty. Seagrass meadows provide nursery grounds for fish, and habitats for other creatures, boosting biodiversity. They capture carbon out of all proportion to their abundance, helping us by removing carbon from the atmosphere and lessening the severity of the climate change to come.

The things that the ocean provides us are sometimes called ‘ecosystem services’, which means the ‘goods’ (like fish) and ‘services’ (like carbon capture) that are provided from the ocean to us. I understand why the concept is used, but it’s one I dislike. An ecosystem providing services to humans. From nature, to us. It’s a bad story, the wrong story. It does a disservice because of what it implies – the term to me suggests a hierarchy, a ranking of who is the dominant party in that particular exchange. It does not suggest a parity between the two. That’s not to suggest humanity should be subservient to nature instead. A diver is not ‘subservient’ to their equipment, but sensibly recognises that care and maintenance is better than dealing with gear failure while still thirty metres under water.

To see ourselves as somehow superior to nature, above it, having ‘dominion’ over it, just shows the arrogance that we, as a species, have in its own exceptionalism. For all our advances and achievements from antibiotics to space travel we are simply one more species of primate, albeit with less fur, bigger brains and better tool-making abilities; this exceptionalism insulates us from our connection and dependence on the natural world.

Here in the UK the issue of poor water quality in rivers and coastal waters is, at the time of writing, receiving a lot of attention. Water quality can be degraded by run-off from agricultural land, such as excess fertiliser, or discharges of raw sewage into rivers and coastal waters. Water companies are permitted to discharge raw sewage under certain conditions, for example during heavy rainfall when the volume of water needing treatment exceeds the capacity of the treatment works to process. Enforcing the regulations by prosecuting those that breach them is necessary, but not enough by itself. In 2021 one company received a record fine of 90 million pounds for discharges that were not authorised by environmental permits, with the discharges into waters where the majority were covered by domestic and international environmental protections. But this is prosecution and protection after the fact, when the damage has already been done. The fine was given out in 2021, while the discharges happened between 2010 and 2015.

But poor water quality also affects our ability to enjoy the coast and ocean. When my daughters were small we were in the surf off a Welsh shore, jumping over and diving under the breaking waves. There had been heavy rainfall a few days earlier, so a permitted discharge may well have happened. There is little that will get me out of the water, but coming face-to-face – literally – with one particular “floating hazard” was enough to send me and my family back to the beach. Is this a story we want to tell, a narrative we want to embrace, that our ocean is simply a receptacle for our waste?

Some go to the ocean to lose themselves in nature, some as a group to share the experience with others, bonding in the light from the flames of a driftwood fire on the beach as daylight retreats. Still others go for a challenge, like kite surfing among the breakers or fighting through the sleep deprivation of single-handed sailing in a long-distance race. We can tell the stories for each of these, but should not forget the one that matters most: that the fate of the ocean and our fate are intertwined, and cannot be separated. This is the story that we most need to tell, and the story that most needs to be heard.

The Extinction of Experience

A pair of great spotted woodpeckers at a nest
A pair of great spotted woodpeckers at a nest.
© 2021 Duncan Greenhill

It’s the relationships we have that give meaning to our lives. We may achieve what passes for status – career success, possessions – via the consumption and competitiveness that marks and mars our society, but it is the relationships we have and nurture that define who we are. The relationships with our friends, our family, our ‘significant others’. But there is one significant other where the relationship is being undermined, neglected, where it’s faltering, right at the point where it’s at its most important for us. Our relationship with nature. As the world warms, our future is intimately linked to the natural world that sustains us. It’s always been that way of course, but the severity and speed of the change is about to refresh the memory of that in those that have forgotten it. This loss of connection, this ‘extinction of experience’ as Miller has called it, disadvantages us. It removes a source of knowledge that gives context to the challenges we face, and a source of comfort as we face them.

The public health measures around Covid placed restrictions on where and how we could connect with our fellow human beings, and in response many found connection to nature instead, experiencing benefits physically, but also mentally, in a world that had lurched away from what we recognised as ‘normal’. I live about as far from the coast as you can get in the UK, so travel restrictions meant that I could not journey to the ocean for significant periods of time. I responded by revisiting some of my local sites containing my second favourite habitat: woodland. I found familiar friends, like yellow lesser celandine flowers that reminded me of early morning walks to lectures at university. I saw both parents at a great spotted woodpecker nest as they changed shifts to look after their young inside, the male with a red flash on the back of his head. I saw nesting swans hatch four chicks, only for two of them to be lost, presumably to predators or illness. I found badger tracks, latrines, and spoil heaps from freshly dug setts in an area I have known since childhood, yet never knew they were there. The truth was I’d never looked, always discounting the area as too enclosed, too urbanised, too small to support a badger population. Walking through a woodland reminds me of the ocean in some ways. Where sunlight is fractured by the canopy and shards of light dance over the woodland floor I feel much of the same immersion, the same enclosure, that I do snorkelling through shallow water.

The connection between nature and us is one where each depends on the other. That may seem strange – it’s easy to see our dependence on nature, but how is nature dependent on us? Perhaps dependent is the wrong word, perhaps reliant instead. Nature is relying on us to stop inflicting the damage we are.

There’s a concept in ecology called ‘shifting baselines’, that the losses we register, the comparisons we make, are only to the earlier times we have experienced. We only compare change and loss to what we have previously known. We can see the change, like the maximum size of an particular fish landed for example, but assume that past point in time represents an undamaged state, a starting point of decline. But old photographs show fish of a size we would consider giants, fish that would dwarf what a fisherman now would call exceptional. Change is overlain by change and damage and loss accumulates, but we see only the latest phase of that damage, the rest hidden, like looking only at the outermost shell of a set of Russian dolls.

We learn the attitudes we hold as adults from our family, carrying them into independence. They colour the value we place on things. Our attitudes to nature we also bring from childhood, and childhoods devoid of messy play, sat in front of screens immersed in counterfeit experiences, divorce us from our ecological identities. We are as dependent on nature for our survival as an otter twisting through water chasing a fish. Richard Louv, co-founder of the Children and Nature Network talks of the ‘last child in the woods’, and how modern society, at least in developed nations, is increasingly isolating our children from experiencing nature in the way that earlier generations did. The consequences could be profound. What policies are made more difficult to introduce or implement when a community, without the knowledge that comes from that connection to nature, doesn’t see the importance and relevance of them? The changes we will need to make to deal with the climate emergency come to mind.

In the end, people protect what they love, they love what they know, and they come to know what they experience. That what we strive to protect is what we are ultimately dependent on makes immersion in those experiences all the more vital.

What future for wild sea bass?

There are many things that can cause problems for a species. Sometimes it’s some aspect of the biology that makes them vulnerable. Sometimes it’s human pressures. And sometimes it all comes together to really cause problems for an animal. Sea bass are a popular fish for commercial fishermen and anglers, and are a popular fish for eating. Despite the fact that most of the sea bass consumed in the EU is farmed wild sea bass populations are in trouble. While assessments of the stock are not easy, ICES, the intergovernmental organisation that gives advice on sustainable fishing to the EU has said that the losses from the population due to fishing have consistently been above sustainable levels1 and also recruitment of young fish has been very poor since 20081.

Swimming Sea Bass

Sea Bass by Bjoertvedt is licensed under creative commons (CC-BY-SA 4.0)

Sea bass grow slowly and mature relatively late. They mature between four and seven years old when the males are around 35 cm long and the females are around 42 cm2. Before the 1st September 2015 the minimum size for landing was 36cm nationally2, although some regions such as Cornwall had a slightly larger size3. Not surprisingly, having a minimum size where the female fish could be landed before they had had a chance to breed is not the best route to a sustainable fishery. Sea bass behaviour also increases their vulnerability to over-exploitation. The juveniles congregate in groups in estuaries, and as adults migrate offshore to spawn (where they are targeted by trawlers4) and then return to the same coastal sites year after year5. This site fidelity means that once local populations are overfished recovery is slow, especially if there are cold winters that can kill juveniles, reducing the number of new individuals recruited to the population5. All these factors mean that the breeding population has dropped from around 16,000 tonnes in 2009 to less than 7,000 tonnes in 2015. ICES state that the ability of the population to reproduce successfully is seriously compromised below 5,000 tonnes.

So what has been the response? The minimum landing size has been increased to 42cm6 and is now called the minimum conservation reference size, which at least gives the females a chance to breed but comes at a cost for the fishermen. The fish that are above 35cm now and could have been caught under the old rules are now not available to be caught until they grow large enough to exceed the new minimum. There is also to be a closed season for six months of the year between January and June to allow the fish to spawn. For the other six months of the year recreational anglers will be allowed to land one bass per day, while commercial fishers are restricted to catch limits of one tonne per month. The EU proposes that catch limits should fall from 2,656 tonnes in 2015 to 1,449 tonnes in 2016, a reduction of around 45%7. The problem is, though, that ICES has said that the limit should be set at 541 tonnes for 20168, which would be a reduction of 80% on the 2015 figures. In other words, the limit set by the EU is nearly three times larger than what the scientific assessment says it should be. This may be an attempt to spread the impact on fishermen over a longer period, but with the stock at such a low level this may backfire. A collapsed fishery supports no one.

What else could be done? Save Our Sea Bass suggest that the lower landings limit (the ICES figure) should be adopted as a matter of urgency, and that both anglers and commercial fishermen should only be allowed to catch sea bass by rod and line or hand lines. They also suggest that the share in the 541 tonnes should be distributed in line with article 17 of the common fisheries policy, which means based on environmental criteria and economic benefits to coastal communities. The idea behind using lines to catch sea bass is that line-caught sea bass fetches higher prices. The marine conservation society has a good fish guide, and currently (November 2015) lists wild-caught sea bass as a fish to avoid. Farmed sea bass are a more acceptable alternative to wild-caught fish.

You can keep up to date with sea bass issues either from the Marine Conservation Society or Save Our Sea Bass site.

References

1,8 ICES Advice on fishing opportunities, catch, and effort Celtic Seas and Greater North Sea Ecoregions 2015
2 European sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax) exploited around Welsh waters – preliminary results: December 2013.
3Cornwall Inshore Fishery and Conservation Association new minimum size for bass
4Protecting Sea Bass
5Parliamentary briefing on sea bass.
6Bass fishing: catch limits, minimum size, and where you can fish (Gov.uk)
7Commission proposes fishing opportunities in the Atlantic and North Sea for 2016

Creative Commons Licence
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

No limits, no future

Recently, I volunteered with the Shark’s Trust at the Dive Show in Birmingham helping to raise awareness about their ‘no limits no future‘ campaign to stop uncontrolled shark fishing. Shark and ray populations worldwide are under increasing pressure, and the total number of sharks caught annually may be over 100 million. One study1 published earlier this year (2014) estimated that up to a quarter of shark and ray species are threatened if assessed using the IUCN red list criteria. If we think about risks to shark populations we might think about shark finning in the Pacific, or sharks being caught as part of longline fisheries for tuna2 but the problem is actually a lot closer to home.

Originally, sharks were an unwanted part of the catch (bycatch) as fishermen pursued species such as cod and tuna, but now there is an increasing trend for the targeting and retention of these bycatch sharks. They are caught for their meat, their fins and their liver oil. Unfortunately, the life-history and behaviour of sharks makes them vulnerable to overfishing and populations are declining. Sharks reach maturity late and have relatively few young compared to other fish. In addition, they often congregate in groups of individuals that are either all a single sex, or are very close in age. Should a fisherman catch these sharks it has a bigger effect than catching the same number of sharks at random from the population.

In 2012 there were 280,000 tonnes of reported shark landings worldwide, with EU vessels landing 40% of this world total, the majority of which came from the Atlantic ocean and Mediterranean sea. One issue in that this is reported landings – the true level of landings is thought to be three to four times higher3. Worse still, most of this European catch from the Atlantic and Mediterranean is concentrated on just five species4.

These five species are:

97% of all sharks caught and landed from the Atlantic and Mediterranean in 2012 are no limits species, which has been estimated to amount to 6,400,000 individuals. This is why although some of the species above are currently listed as of ‘least concern’ it’s important to make the fisheries sustainable before the populations crash due to overfishing. Once overfished, there is no guarantee that populations will recover as demonstrated by the collapse of the cod fishery on the grand banks off the eastern coast of Canada. In addition, sharks are important components of ecosystems as top-level predators. The shark trust is campaigning for science-based catch limits. Please sign the petition, and see the ‘get involved‘ page for other ways to contribute.

References

1http://elifesciences.org/content/3/e00590
2http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2351989414000055
3 4http://www.nolimitsnofuture.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/no_limits.pdf

Creative Commons Licence
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

GDPR Logo
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.