Ignorance, indifference and pollution: seagrass under threat

Small-spotted catshark amongst seagrass, Helford River, Cornwall
Small-spotted catshark (Scyliorhinus canicula) in seagrass, Helford, Cornwall.
Image courtesy of Shannon Moran (Instagram, twitter) and the Ocean Agency Image Bank.

This is the second post in a three-part series on seagrass:

  • Part one: “Seagrass – the undervalued ally” – what is seagrass, and why should we care about it?
  • Part two: what are the threats that seagrass faces?
  • Part three: what can we do about it?

In our attempt to tackle the climate crisis we have an ally alongside us: seagrass. But our attempt is half-hearted. We are doing too little at much too slow a pace, and working against ourselves with our treatment of our ally. Seagrass is vitally important as part of the biosphere we inhabit and ultimately depend on, but unfortunately like many parts of that biosphere, it is subject to our indifference and carelessness.

There are some specific ways in which we’re damaging seagrass, but also some more generic reasons why it is under threat. First, is our general ignorance of it. We lack the awareness of what it is and why it is important. Many in the UK would be surprised to learn that we actually have seagrass here, thinking of it as an inhabitant of warmer climates, but even there unless people have direct experience of it or dependency on it – fisherman or those involved in tourism for example – then the importance of seagrass can still be discounted. People protect the things and places that they care about and connect to, but increasingly, people have a remoteness from the natural world that thwarts that emotional connection.

Secondly, restoring and protecting something requires information, the information to give answers to the questions: how much is there? How much have we lost? What condition is it in? What is damaging it and how can we correct that? Too often, that information simply isn’t there in enough detail and without it, we struggle to do the right thing.

A third factor, and one that goes to the heart of so much that is wrong in our dysfunctional relationship with the natural world, is to recognize that society and ecology are intimately interlinked. For society to persist, to function well, to provide us with the material things we need to live, we need to understand that society (and us) are part of ecology, not separate from it. We need to link the ecological to the social and economic. The natural world is not outside society or the economy; it envelops them. We do not and cannot exist without it. Ignorance of our dependency does not remove that dependency, it only frustrates our ability to make good choices.

We have lost much of the seagrass around the UK, perhaps as much as over 90% since the start of the twentieth century. Some was lost after the first world war, with another significant loss in the 1930s due to a wasting disease. Still more has been lost since the 1980s. Seagrass is a shallow water habitat, and this proximity to the coast is the source of many of the problems facing it.

Poor water quality is probably the most critical factor. Eutrophication, an excess of nutrients in the water, can harm seagrass, particularly if the nutrient in question is nitrogen. Too much nitrogen favours the growth of algae at the expense of seagrass. This algae might grow on the seagrass leaves as epiphytes, and while some algal growth on the leaves is normal and beneficial to the meadow overall, too much is a problem. The algae could also be present as microscopic plants in the water above and around the seagrass, acting to reduce the amount of light reaching it and reducing its growth.

There is another, more fundamental way that too much nitrogen can affect seagrass, by making it more susceptible to disease through causing an imbalance in the plant’s internal chemistry. There is an ideal ratio between how much nitrogen and how much carbon there is within seagrass. One form of nitrogen within the plant is nitrate. Too much nitrate distorts this ideal ratio, reducing the amount of a key group of molecules called phenolic compounds. It is these compounds that help to protect the seagrass from a wasting disease caused by the protist Labyrinthula, the same wasting disease responsible for devastating the UK’s seagrass meadows in the 1930s.

So where does the nitrogen come from? It can come from sewage discharged untreated into rivers or coastal waters. Despite these sewage discharges being legal in the UK under certain conditions, there is increasing public concern around water quality, and prosecutions where those discharges have not met the legal conditions set for them. Even treated sewage can be high in nitrates when discharged. It can also come from agricultural sources such as excess fertiliser washed from fields.

Direct physical disturbance is another way seagrass meadows can be damaged. This can be from the result of wave and storm action, direct damage from fishing gear such as trawls, or from boats mooring and anchoring where seagrass is present.

Successful anchoring doesn’t work by weight alone, but by keeping the pull on the anchor along the seabed as much as possible. The line connecting the anchor to the boat is called the rode, and a boat where the rode consists solely of metal chain will need to let out a length of chain at least four times the water depth. Chain is heavy and expensive, and so some rodes have a shorter length of chain connected to the anchor with the remainder of the rode as rope. The skipper on these boats will need to let out an anchor line that’s at least six times the water depth.

The anchor drags along the seabed before it digs in, ploughing a trough through the meadow. Once the anchor has dug in, or set, the chain closest to the anchor will lie along the seabed. This is why the length of rode is so long compared to the water depth – to keep that pull on the anchor along the seabed, digging it in further. As the tide or wind changes the boat will swing around its anchor and the chain will be dragged around, leaving a halo of disturbed and damaged seagrass around the anchor.

Traditional moorings damage seagrass in a similar way. They have a weight on the seabed and a chain that connects to a rope leading to the buoy on the surface. A boat moors to the buoy, and any chain lying on the seabed is dragged as the boat is moved around by wind and tide. Studland bay in Dorset, England, has seagrass meadows and is home to the two species of seahorse found in UK waters, but is also a very popular area for recreational boating and tourism. As a result, attempts to protect the seagrass beds have been a source of controversy over a number of years. In May 2019, the bay was designated a marine conservation zone (MCZ), and in June 2022 a voluntary no-anchoring zone was introduced in the southern end of the bay where the majority of the seagrass meadows are found. Ten eco-moorings have now been installed as part of a joint project between the seahorse trust and boatfolk. These work by having a large vertical component that screws into the seabed and then a flexible connection between that and the buoy on the surface. With no chain lying on the seabed there is nothing to damage the seagrass.

Recent research has revealed a new way in which seagrass might be being damaged: noise. We think of noise pollution in the oceans as primarily a problem for animals, such as disrupting the communication and echolocation of whales and dolphins. It seems strange that noise would affect something we assume doesn’t have a sense of hearing, but while plants don’t need to hear it’s an advantage to sense gravity, to know which way is up or down. Exposure to sound in the lab produced changes in the starch-filled structures called amyloplasts that are used to sense gravity in seagrass, reducing their number and leaving them mis-shapen and with holes in their surface.

But we need to treat these results with caution. This is one study, with one species, with sound exposure levels much higher than are likely to be normally experienced in natural environments. The sound levels used were 157 decibels for up to 120 hours. For comparison, a jet engine at takeoff is 140 decibels. I’m not confident of what condition I would be in after five days of exposure to sound of that intensity. So the question remains: seagrass can be damaged by noise, but at what levels does that damage start to occur, and are those levels experienced in nature? For what activities might we need to take noise pollution into account?

Seagrass is being damaged and lost, but it’s not inevitable. Seagrass meadows are also being restored, and it’s these efforts to restore them that I’ll look at in the next article. The damage and loss are the result of choices that we, personally and as a society, choose to make. We can make better choices.