Category Biodiversity

Is it only gold that glitters?

Surfer on a wave
Image courtesy of Michele Roux / Ocean Image Bank

Language matters. Language can explain or elaborate, confuse or camouflage. For example, what do we mean when we say we value something? Value is a word with multiple meanings, and multiple meanings can serve many masters.

But even plain words, words we think of as describing singular concepts, can be slippery. Suppose I show you a photograph of a dog. Just an ordinary dog, bright-eyed, expectantly looking at the camera as if waiting for a ball to be thrown. And then I point to this dog and ask you ‘what is a dog?’ You might look at me a little strangely, perhaps perplexed by the question. A dog is, after all, just a dog. But look at the photograph again. To Raymond, the pensioner who lives alone this is Reggie, his friend who lies alongside him as they sit on the sofa together and watch TV. To Sally, who volunteers with the mountain rescue team, Reggie is a respected four-legged colleague, without whom a number of people may not have gone home to their families last year. To Rachel, the geneticist, Reggie is a collaborator in her research, with Reggie’s DNA helping to unravel the story of when wolves were first domesticated, how and when the path from competitor to companion was first trod. To other scientists, Reggie may literally be an experimental animal on whom procedures are performed or drugs tested, although the tag on his pen will call him ‘D149’ rather than Reggie. In some areas of the world dogs are on the menu, afforded no more consideration than a chicken in a battery cage.

How this dog is perceived, how it is loved, respected or disrespected, used or abused, is not constant. In effect, the answer to the question ‘what is a dog?’ depends on who is doing the asking and who answers.

There’s a difference between the ‘value of’ something and the ‘value in’ something. ‘Value in’ describes the intrinsic worth, the value of something for its own sake. ‘Value of’ attempts to place a monetary value, to put a price on something. Which of these win in the conflict between them may depend on the circumstance. Someone who is unemployed and reduced to destitution may sell otherwise precious belongings so that their children do not go hungry. But some things are beyond price. The beauty of a sunset is an example typically used. But I think of an indentation of the river Camel estuary, enclosed by a horseshoe of rocks, and the early Autumn sun dropping lower in the sky. There is a shallow pool left stranded by the tide and the laughter of my toddler grandson as he splashes through the knee-deep water playfully chased by his grandfather, both chased by Bernie, the German Shepherd dog, who joins in the game when not distracted by thrown sticks. There is no ‘value of’ here, no price, only the glow of memory to be cherished as the child grows to adulthood.

Language is ambiguous. The same word can mean different things to different audiences. When a scientist talks of uncertainty and error in a measurement they’re talking of the preciseness and variability of the measure. It’s actually an expression of confidence in the correctness of the measurement. But to the general public, when a scientist says “uncertainty”, they hear “we don’t know”. When a scientist says “error” they hear “mistake”. I’ve discussed before that I dislike the term “ecosystem services”, partly because it suggests a hierarchy where those receiving the service are more important than that which provides it, but it’s also that the term, like value, can mean very different things. To the scientist the term describes something provided by the ecosystem, perhaps irreplaceably. To others, with interests beyond the ecological, the focus can be on the ‘value of’ rather than the ‘value in’. ‘Value of’ suggests a valuation, but place a price on something and the ‘value in’ becomes secondary. And that gets to the heart of a valuation. Money is a system of exchange: I give you these tokens, you give me my coffee, and you take those tokens to exchange for something that you want. If something is given a price, if it has a valuation, then that means that it is exchangeable. One of the dictionary definitions of value is this idea of exchange, and then the object with the valuation becomes just another token, no different from our usual coins, banknotes, or electronic funds. The object with the valuation, whether that’s Van Gogh’s sunflowers or endangered seahorses in a seagrass bed, has become fungible, transmutable into something different – the valuation. The object comes and goes, but the valuation remains. In this way, the ‘value in’ ceases to exist and only the ‘value of’ remains.

It’s a poverty of the human imagination that so many things are reduced to a ‘value of’, rather than being held in esteem for their intrinsic worth, but it’s also the result of human psychology and human choice. It’s the culture we are immersed in. Values don’t exist in isolation. They congregate with fellow travellers, and mass like armies against those least like them. They form consistent patterns across different cultures, suggesting that it is something fundamental within us as a species.

Shalom Schwarz developed the theory of basic human values, organising them into something he called a circumplex. He placed values according to two axes. The first is a measure of what influences and drives us, whether that comes from within or from others. Self-acceptance and popularity lie at opposite ends of this axis. The second is a measure of where our priorities lie, whether that is our own pleasure and achievement, or helping others. Hedonism and spirituality are the outliers here.

An older idea of human motivation is Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, the idea that we need to satisfy our most basic needs first, like food and shelter, before we can meet higher needs such as love and friendship and reaching our potential. The exact sequencing and relationship of those needs is still contentious, so perhaps a better fit is to think of it as three layers, the borders blurry and indistinct between them. The bottom layer contains those who are security-driven. They are looking for safety and a sense of belonging; those in this layer are often tribal in their allegiances. The middle layer are those who are outer-directed. They conspicuously display, drive the right aspirational brand of car or wear the latest fashions in clothes; they gain their status and self-esteem by seeking the approval of others. The top layer contains those who are inner-directed. They already have achieved self-esteem and are motivated more by ideas and achieving their full potential.

The three worlds model of human behaviour calls these three groups settlers, prospectors, and pioneers, each fundamentally different from each other in terms of what motivates them and what feels important. This is something we all do. The values we hold affect how we view the world and how we think it should work. They intersect with our notions of ‘value of’ and ‘value in’, to form a hierarchy of what we hold to be important and what is less so. But the values we hold don’t exist in isolation – we hold them within the culture that we live in. Are our values the majority view or the minority view or something in-between? Do they coincide with the values that those in power hold or do they conflict? These are not fixed points. Values held by individuals and societies can change over time. We are rarely the same person at fifty years old that we were at twenty, and the worlds we inhabited are similarly disparate. Cultures shift over time, sometimes for the better, sometimes for the worse.

Our current culture, political and social, is one that pays lip service to tackling the climate crisis. We upgrade our phones, whether the old one still meets our needs or not. We see record-busting floods in Pakistan but then fly to Europe for a weekend city break. Governments make grand announcements easily condensed to sound bites and slogans, even though the actions underlying the announcement are insufficient or counter-productive to achieve the goal they trumpet. In July 2022 the UK Government’s net zero strategy was found to be unlawful by the high court because it failed to show how the UK’s legally binding carbon budgets would be met should the strategy be followed. In Autumn 2022 the short-lived administration of Prime Minister Liz Truss announced plans to issue new licences for oil and gas extraction in direct contradiction of the International Energy Authority report that states that “there is no need for investment in new fossil fuel supply” if the world is to meet its climate targets.

The ‘value of’ continues to be placed above the ‘value in’, even when the ‘value in’ is an intact, well-functioning biosphere that sustains us all, something that should dwarf the ‘value of’ achieved through exploiting it. Those of us who see the ‘value in’ need to persuade those who prioritise the ‘value of’ that they need to change course. We need to influence the cultural values for the better. As the IPCC states in its sixth assessment report: “Climate change is a threat to human well-being and planetary health. Any further delay … will miss a brief and rapidly closing window of opportunity to secure a liveable and sustainable future for all.” There can be no higher stakes to recognise the intrinsic value of the natural world and our place within it than this. We embrace the ‘value in’ or little of value will remain.

Summer visitor, Ocean voyager

Leatherback turtle on a beach making its way to the sea with waves in the background. Image courtesy US Fish and Wildlife Service
Leatherback turtle on a beach making its way to the sea Image courtesy US Fish and Wildlife Service

It was, at the time, the largest corpse of its kind ever found. Friday 23rd September 1988, two days short of a full moon, the weather neither unseasonally warm nor cold, the retreating tide leaves the corpse stranded on Harlech beach like a wrecked ship. The beach is four miles long, flanked to the north by the estuary at Porthmadog and to landward by a chain of sand dunes and slacks behind which Harlech Castle rises like a sentry post. Once victualled directly by boat the castle is itself now stranded from the sea by centuries of longshore drift that sculpted the dunes lying before it. The corpse is male, weighing more than 900 kilograms, and is almost three metres long from its blunt nose to its stubby tail, two and a half metres from flipper tip to flipper tip. Fishermen had found it the day before, tangled in the lines to their whelk pots four miles off the coast in Tremadoc Bay. Cut free, drowned, adrift like flotsam, it made landfall on Harlech beach.

It was not one of the usual suspects, not native to Welsh waters, more usually thought of as belonging to tropical seas where coastlines of milk-white sand are fringed by coral reefs. That may be true of other marine turtles, who would be cold-stunned into torpor even by summer temperatures in these waters, but not the leatherback turtle. This turtle is different.

There are two groups of marine turtles, two families on the evolutionary tree. Most have scutes, plates of horn-like material that form their shell and cover their head and flippers. Differences in the arrangement of these scutes helps to distinguish between the species. These species are the Chelonidae, pronounced kel-on-ee-dee. Leatherbacks, like their name suggests, lack these bony plates, their backs of tough skin stretched over seven ridges that run along the body of the animal. They are the last living species, the last survivors, of an ancient lineage, the Dermochelyidae (der-mo-kel-ee-dee).

Marine turtles are ectotherms; they do not maintain a constant body temperature in the way that mammals or birds do. There is no ‘normal’ body temperature for an ectotherm, only a range of optimal temperatures. Their body temperature takes its cue from the temperature of the environment around them. This is where evolution gave leatherbacks their advantage, gave them an ability to range further into colder waters where other turtles cannot go. They have the widest distribution of any marine turtle, ranging as far north as Norway and the Arctic Circle, and as far south as New Zealand. Leatherbacks can’t regulate their temperature, they can’t maintain it at a constant value regardless of the temperature of the environment, but they can raise it above and keep it above the temperature of the surrounding water by generating heat from their muscles. The bigger the turtle, the larger the differential it can maintain between body temperature and water, and the further north it can go.

Picture a beach on the Atlantic coast of Costa Rica, palm trees lazily slanted off-vertical and waves that caress rather than crash into the sand. It is as different from the beach at Harlech as it can be, but it is beaches like these where a leatherback will be born, on the curve of the coast facing out into the Caribbean. The turtle will hatch from one of perhaps seventy eggs from any of up to eleven batches laid by each female.

Temperature first plays a pivotal role in their lives here. Sex is controlled by the warmth of the sand and the resulting temperature that incubates the eggs in the nest. Lower temperatures produce males, higher temperatures produce females, with a transitional temperature range between them where both sexes are produced. These waters are where it will spend its first few years, feeding, growing, surviving where initially almost everything is larger than you, containing guilds of predators that would happily feed on young turtles.

Size is the key. They cannot start their pilgrimage to higher latitudes, to colder waters, to richer feeding grounds, until they have bulked up. It is a biological consequence of geometry, a simple mathematical relationship: the surface-area-to-volume ratio. Imagine two metal cubes. The first, the smaller cube, has sides one centimetre wide by one centimetre high. The second is three times the size, each side three centimetres wide by three centimetres high. Heat them both to perhaps fifty degrees, and then wait. Hold your palm above each a while later to gauge how hot they are and the smaller one will feel cooler than the larger. The smaller one has six sides, each with an area of one square centimetre to give a total surface area of six square centimetres, and has a volume of one cubic centimetre: a ratio of six to one. That’s a lot of surface through which the heat of a small volume can radiate away. The larger cube has a volume of twenty-seven cubic centimetres (three times three times three), and the surface area is now fifty-four square centimetres (six sides, each three by three). That gives the ratio fifty-four to twenty-seven or, simplifying, two to one. From six to one down to two to one. Each ‘chunk’ of volume in the larger cube has a much smaller area of surface to lose heat from.

A turtle is not cube-shaped, but the same principle applies. As the animal grows its volume increases at a faster rate than its surface area, meaning that it can better retain heat, that heat is lost to the water more slowly. This is the reason the biggest turtles can penetrate the coldest waters, out-competing their smaller brethren for access to the abundance of food in more northerly seas.

These are ocean voyagers. Researchers can tag adult turtles as they leave the nesting beaches. Leatherbacks don’t come ashore en masse to mate and nest like their hard-shelled relatives, meaning that most tagged turtles are female. Tagged males are rarer. Tagging male turtles requires capturing and tagging them at sea. Where, when, and how they mate is still something science has yet to confirm, but is thought to happen close to the nesting beaches where the females will lay their eggs.

On land, vast herds of wildebeest undergo a yearly migration along defined routes between the Serengeti and the Masai Mara, with river crossings where they run the gauntlet of hungry Nile crocodiles. Turtle migrations lack this regularity. There is no predictability about where and when they will migrate. But let’s follow a male turtle from these Costa Rican waters, follow his journey to see how he may arrive in the Welsh seas where our Harlech leviathan met its end. This male is spent from mating. He must replenish his reserves of energy, and that means he must head northwards. His fins, proportionately the longest of any turtle, beat steadily, the muscles that power them producing the heat that permits him to venture north. But he must conserve that heat. In his fins the blood vessels that carry blood away from the body lie close to those returning cooled blood from the extremities. This arrangement, where the blood vessels are parallel but with flows in opposite directions is called a countercurrent heat exchanger. Heat from the outgoing blood warms the cooler incoming blood. In effect the heat performs a u-turn, using the closeness of the blood vessels to avoid a trip to the extremities where it would more easily be lost to the water. In colder waters he will increase his swimming speed and the rate of his fin strokes, producing additional heat to keep himself warmer than the water that surrounds him. These colder waters are rich in nutrients, productive, fuelling the growth of plankton and the predators that feed on them. Here is where the turtle finds its prey: jellyfish. These are plentiful, but nutritionally diffuse. The turtle overcomes the low nutritional density of a single jellyfish by eating in quantity to gain the calories and nutrition it needs.

The turtle dives, encountering prey on the majority of its searches. It is not a fussy eater. It will close and feed, indiscriminately, without preference of anatomy; tentacles or bell are equally welcome in the pursuit of calories and nutrition. He is an efficient predator, with little time (or energy) wasted on unsuccessful or unproductive attacks. Backward-facing spines in the throat ensure that prey does not escape. These are not small turtles yet a leatherback may consume three-quarters of its bodyweight of jellyfish each day.

As autumn yields to the approach of winter, others that arrived here by disparate routes to forage with our turtle will make the return journey south, back to warmer waters, but he will remain here between 30 and 40 degrees north, overwintering before making a transatlantic crossing eastwards to the Irish Sea or Bay of Biscay.

The Irish Sea is a rich hunting ground for a pelagic predator like the leatherback, and it is here that the Harlech turtle faced one of the threats that many large marine animals face: entanglement in fishing gear. A post-mortem revealed some plastic had been ingested, confused for jellyfish, but not enough to cause it to starve. There was some chemical contamination in its tissues of heavy metals and PCBs, another common issue with large predators whose tissue bioaccumulate toxins, but again not in particularly significant amounts. The turtle, capable of diving to depths of 1200m, drowned in waters less than 20m deep, entangled in lines to fishing pots.

The death of the Harlech leatherback passed unnoticed by me at the time. I was in my mid-twenties, a soldier stationed closer to the North Sea coast than to the Irish Sea, dealing with the emotional backwash from a recently completed tour of active duty. Re-considering my choices would lead to the University College of North Wales, Bangor just two years later to study marine biology. I would come face-to-face with the turtle much later, or at least its skeleton and taxidermed reconstruction, in one of the galleries of the national museum of Wales in Cardiff.

Here in the UK, the magnificence of our seas passes unnoticed and unremarked, perhaps hidden by the murkiness that comes with the plankton in such rich, productive waters. And they are magnificent, despite the damage being done to them, with seagrass meadows, the second largest fish in the world resident here, and leatherbacks, enduring cold northern waters to gorge on the jellyfish it finds here.

MPAs: Protected, highly protected, or paper parks?

Fishing vessel hauling a catch of sardines. Image courtesy: Nicolas Job / @theOceanAgency
Fishing vessel hauling a catch of sardines. Image courtesy: Nicolas Job / @theOceanAgency

They say experience is learning from your own mistakes, while wisdom is learning from the mistakes of others. The Republic of Ireland is in the early stages of developing and implementing a network of marine protected areas (MPAs). The Fair Seas campaign has identified sixteen potential sites for MPAs to meet the 30 by 30 goal – 30% of land and sea protected by 2030. Their assessment is an impressive piece of work, with the areas chosen to maximise the conservation value based on the distributions of fifteen species of whales and dolphins, thirty-eight species of seabirds, sixteen species of sharks and rays, seven species of commercially caught fish, and eleven other species that act as indicators for particular habitats. The foreword to the assessment argues for a core of sites to be fully protected so that there is a reference against which protection, recovery, and management actions can be judged, and some sites where activities such as fishing would be allowed.

Turn the clock back to the early 2010s, when the UK first aimed to set up an ‘ecologically coherent and well-managed network’ of MPAs. Many organisations contributed data and expert opinion to a consultation, which resulted in a recommended network of over 100 sites. The government announced an initial phase that established 27 sites in English waters which, unsurprisingly, provoked a stream of criticism on the gap between plan and reality. Then came a second phase of 23 sites, and a third phase of 41 sites. Each phase greeted by disappointment from conservation organisations on the scale of provision, and criticism or concern from industry groups on their impact. The original plan was for some of these sites to be reference areas where all damaging activities were banned, sometimes called marine reserves or no-take zones. This was not implemented, due to a perception by those most affected by the higher protected status that they were being excluded from the process.

Marine protected areas have the potential for widespread benefits. Increasing ecological resilience through protecting areas means that these areas can better withstand the stresses and impacts placed upon them. In turn, they continue to provide benefits such as fisheries spillover, where fish within the areas breed and bolster the populations outside the site’s boundaries. The end result is coastal fisheries that are more productive and more sustainable. The Fair Seas assessment explicitly includes areas that are spawning and nursery grounds for both cod and herring. Clean and diverse seas can increase tourism and recreation, helping local economies and well-being. Depending on the site, they can also form part of a nature-based solution to tackling climate change by providing coastal protection or carbon capture.

In November 2018 there were “314 designated MPAs protecting 24% of UK waters compared to 217 sites covering 8% of UK waters in 2012”. This seems like good progress towards the 30 by 30 goal for the UK, but much depends on what we mean by ‘protected’, and how well that protection is enforced. In the UK MPAs are designated based on ‘features of conservation interest’ – FOCI – which are the species and habitats the area is designed to protect. Other activities like fishing and dredging are permitted within the area provided that they don’t affect the features under protection, or unless they’re restricted by some other regulation, for example, where bottom trawling in seagrass meadows is prohibited in some areas.

So is this really protection or is it simply a lesser form of exploitation? The British Ecological Society (BES) says that most protected areas are not delivering in terms of providing real protection. Oceana and Global Fishing Watch found that in 2019 97% of UK MPAs were either being dredged or subject to bottom trawling.

How can we say these areas are protected if we allow damaging activities to take place within them? They’re created based on particular features but it’s a system, not isolated features. It’s all very well to say that activity X is fine because it doesn’t directly affect that feature, but that doesn’t help if activity X still damages the species and habitats that connect with it, and on which those features may depend.

Humans of the middle stone age lived on Doggerland, a low-lying area of tundra and marsh between what is now France and England. The end of the last ice age saw this land bridge disappear beneath the sea. Dogger bank, an extensive area of shallow sandbanks, overlays what was Doggerland and is home to sandeels, a vital food source for many seabirds, as well as whales and dolphins. Cod feed on the sandeels and breed here, boosting the stock for commercial fishers to harvest. In 2020 Greenpeace dropped granite boulders into this area, publicising the precise location in an attempt to prevent bottom trawling. In June 2022 a new byelaw was introduced to ban bottom trawling in this particular MPA, crucially after extensive consultation with the fishing industry. Where restrictions are based on dialogue, they have a much higher prospect of being followed, but this is only one of four MPAs with new bye-laws to restrict trawling. Four, out of hundreds.

But the more activities we seek to restrict the more that brings us into conflict with others such as fishers for example. We may look at the ocean and see an open expanse of water, but there are many competing demands on ocean space. Pipelines and cables run along the seafloor, bringing gas and electricity ashore, distributing it within and between countries. Telecommunications links carry data streams to connect our world. Renewable energy stakes its claim – offshore wind above the waves and tidal energy below. Fishers, unlike farmers, don’t own the grounds their livelihoods depend on, and so there is a spatial squeeze, a potential displacement away from areas traditionally fished. A report by the National Federation of Fishermen’s Organisations (NFFO) and the Scottish Fisherman’s Federation (SFF) looked at this spatial squeeze, comparing past conditions in 2000 to the current situation (2020-21), and to three future scenarios, one in 2030 and two in 2050, each with different levels of restriction for fishing in protected areas. In what it calls the ‘future 3 (worst case)’ scenario bottom trawling is banned in all protected areas that were designated for seafloor species or habitats. But is this a ‘worst case’? Should this not be the baseline case, that where an area is selected to protect seafloor species and habitats, that all activities (like trawling) that damage them are banned? Otherwise, how can we honestly claim that we are protecting them?

This gives me some discomfort personally, perhaps leaving me open to a charge of hypocrisy since I do eat fish. My diet is a little strange in that it is mostly vegan but with occasional dairy, and some sustainably sourced fish. Mostly vegan to reduce climate change emissions, some dairy because I’m not going to expect my 89 year old father to have a supply of oat milk on hand for when I visit, and sustainable fish because it’s generally a low-carbon source of protein. When I shop I’ll start by looking for the Marine Stewardship Council logo and then filter options using the Marine Conservation Society’s Good Fish Guide for fishing method and area. There’s not always enough detail on the labelling to make a completely informed decision, but I do my best. Some of the most sustainable fishing tends to be done by the inshore boats under ten metres in length that historically have not received an equitable share of quota allocation, despite their sustainability. Part of the progress towards conserving biodiversity is the ending of subsidy for damaging activities and providing incentives to the sustainable ones. Correcting the quota inequity for these inshore boats fishing sustainably would be a positive step as part of that.

The spatial squeeze on fishing grounds is likely to come from two main sources: nature conservation and renewable energy developments, yet both are of vital significance to the wider population. The 30 by 30 target is critical if we are to tackle the twin threats of climate change and biodiversity loss, but it becomes a self-delusion unless we are actually protecting those areas we count towards it. The BES report found that some land-based areas were being counted despite them not originally being created for biodiversity (e.g. Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty), and despite them not delivering in terms of protecting biodiversity. Unless these areas meaningfully contribute to nature recovery, to providing benefits for both people and nature, then it becomes nothing more than governmental greenwashing to count these towards the 30 by 30 target. They become yet another policy initiative, loudly announced then left to wither for lack of political will or funding; a shield to hide behind when accountability for the lack of any real progress is sought.

Callum Roberts, professor of marine conservation at the University of Exeter, has criticised the lack of real protection, calling areas that are not effectively protected or managed ‘paper parks’. He does, however, sound a note of caution: if we set targets for the quality as well as the quantity of protection then we risk losing the consensus to provide that protection if those targets are set too high. But that simply brings us back to our original question: what value are protected areas if they are not protected in practice?

Another issue is that the 30 by 30 goal doesn’t apply to the high seas – the area that covers nearly half the ocean surface, areas outside national jurisdiction. That’s a lot of ocean where damage can still be done, a spatial loophole for exploitation to continue, if agreement can’t be reached at the UN’s Intergovernmental Conference on Marine Biodiversity of Areas Beyond National Jurisdiction in New York in August 2022.

Language matters. It can determine the boundaries of debate; it can illuminate or deceive. The words chosen to describe something affects how we perceive it. The UK Government is running a consultation (July 2022) to select pilot areas for Highly Protected Marine Areas – HPMAs – with the first HPMAs planned for 2023. There are five pilot sites, two inshore and three offshore, with activities such as construction, dredging, and fishing banned within the boundaries, and the Government saying these areas “will have the highest level of protection in our seas.” So here ‘highly protected’ means actually protecting an area, while areas that are merely ‘protected’ are still open to damaging activities. The language distorts the reality, and we continue to reassure ourselves that we are doing more than we are.

Properly protecting areas means a spatial squeeze on fishing, and fishing effort must go somewhere. If it is displaced to other areas then these will be fished harder unless the beneficial effects of MPAs are enough to compensate, and there is a time lag between the application of protection and the benefits of it. The only other possibility is that the capacity of the industry reduces, and that’s not something that should be taken lightly – these are people’s livelihoods, people’s lives. Fishing is not a job description, it’s wrapped together with identity. It’s family history – fathers, brothers, uncles fishing before them. It’s communities, with a shared history, and sometimes encompasses a shared experience of tragedy. Fishing is a dangerous occupation. But not reducing capacity, should it be needed, just means that fishing communities suffer the more severe effects resulting from climate change and biodiversity loss alongside everyone else. No one wins.

There is still a case for areas to have different levels of protection. One size does not fit all and a diversity of approach is beneficial, but the default MPA should be a fully protected one. Protection should mean real protection. We gain nothing if we think that the lines on a map have meaning without the enforcement to achieve the basis for which they were created. We can truly protect areas and receive the benefits they provide, or we can continue to delude ourselves that we are doing something, thinking that we are making progress against the threats we face, until the damage is done, and it is too late. The Republic of Ireland is standing at a point of divergence, two path of marine conservation before it: protection in name, or protection in practice. Let us hope it chooses the path less travelled.

Time to stop playing the game

Urchins vs. Kelp, Great Southern Reef, Australia. Image courtesy @Ocean_Imaging (Stefan Andrew) / @theoceanagency
Urchins vs. Kelp, Great Southern Reef, Australia.
Image courtesy @Ocean_Imaging (Stefan Andrew) / @theoceanagency

There was a game I had when I was a child. It was called Ker-plunk, with a translucent plastic tower and thin plastic sticks pushed through about half-way down. The sticks crossed over each other to support marbles that had been poured in from the top. Players would take turns removing the sticks, trying not to make any marbles drop. At first it was easy, but as the number of sticks reduced marbles would start to fall. Eventually, the removal of a single stick would cause an avalanche of marbles, losing the game for that player. We are both the player and the marbles, removing sticks and ready to fall. The mesh of sticks is biodiversity, a safety net of interconnected species and habitats that supports our survival. Each stick we remove, each species we lose, takes us closer to the point where the marbles will fall.

In life there are always boundaries. Some we can push; some it is unwise to cross. The planet is no different; it has natural thresholds that together work to keep the system stable and resilient. Staying below these thresholds gives a safe space for humanity to live within. The Stockholm Resilience Centre developed a framework to define what this safe operating space looks like, and where our activities place us in relation to those boundaries. There are nine components, and our place in each component is rated as green, amber or red. Biodiversity is one of the core components. It’s assessed in two ways. One is through functional diversity, which describes how diverse the organisms within a particular functional role are – think of a habitat that’s lost most of its decomposers or top predators and it’s easy to see how a lack of diversity within a particular function can unbalance and destabilize a particular ecosystem. But functional diversity is tricky to measure. Another way is by assessing genetic diversity through measuring extinction rates. The extinction rates we are experiencing now take us into the high risk, red zone.

There have been five previous mass extinctions, where at least 75% of species were lost in a short period of time, geologically speaking. Extinction is a natural consequence of evolution: not all species will continue to exist. There is a background level of extinction, like a low note in the song of evolution, but the sound is becoming louder. It looks as if we’ve entered the sixth mass extinction. In 2019 IPBES published a global assessment report on biodiversity and ecosystem services. It assessed the situation now and where the trends would take us under different scenarios of economic activity and carbon emissions. Extinction rates now are tens to hundreds of times higher than the rates over the last ten million years, and the rates are accelerating, with around one million species facing extinction over the next few decades.

That is shocking in itself, but the headlines hide detail, and the detail is even more frightening. More than half a million terrestrial species – one in eleven – don’t have enough habitat for long-term survival unless their habitats are restored. Around a third of all the reef-building corals are threatened with extinction, along with the same proportion of sharks and their related species,. More than one in three of every marine mammal species is also threatened with extinction. Over 55% of the ocean is covered by industrial fishing, yet the primary productivity of the ocean could reduce by up to 10%, and fish biomass by 25%, if warming follows the high emissions scenario. Tackle emissions and bring the warming down to that of the low scenario and the loss of productivity and fish biomass is only 3%. Still an issue, but much less of one for the billions of people relying on the ocean for their main source of protein.

The IPBES report lists five main causes, the drivers of these declines. For land and freshwater systems, changes in the way that land is used, and direct over-exploitation of plant and animal species have been the major factors responsible for the declines in biodiversity since 1970. For marine ecosystems, these two factors are reversed: over-exploitation, mainly through over-fishing, is the major cause, with land and sea-use changes such as coastal development and increased pollution as the second factor. Climate change is the next major driver for both land and ocean

It’s no coincidence that they’re often mentioned together. They are the two core components of the planetary boundaries framework. They are linked together: nature can help us tackle climate change, yet climate change makes tackling biodiversity loss all the more difficult. Changing temperatures means that some species prosper and some lose, but not all react in the same way or at the same rate. Birds may nest and breed according to the expected glut of caterpillars in the spring. Caterpillars may hatch based on the bursting of the buds and the availability of soft, young foliage. Trees may wake from dormancy based on daytime temperatures that get earlier each year. The chain may break unless all shift their timings in tandem, and there are many interconnected chains rather than just one.

The good news is that there is action being taken. The UN decade of restoration is a “rallying call for the protection and revival of ecosystems all around the world, for the benefit of people and nature”, running from 2021 to 2030. Alongside that is the 30 by 30 initiative, aiming for 30% of the land and ocean to be protected by 2030. As aspirational and beautiful as these goals are, they are not enough by themselves, and are unlikely to be reached unless we also deal with the foundations of the biodiversity crisis.

The bad news is that the trends are all taking us in the wrong direction, and tweaks to the current system will not be enough to change this. Our economic system prioritises growth while ignoring the resulting environmental damage and externalising its costs – leaving it for others to clean up the mess and meet the expense of doing so. The IPBES report says that “most international societal and environmental goals, …, will not be achieved based on current trajectories”, and that any goals beyond 2030 “may only be achieved through transformative changes.” What does it mean by transformative change? Well, it means “a fundamental, system-wide reorganization across technological, economic and social factors, including paradigms, goals and values.” Read that again. Fundamental. System-wide. Changing paradigms – the models and frameworks society accepts as the norm. Values. George Monbiot has been making a similar argument, that incremental change is not sufficient, not fast enough, to deal with the problems facing us in the timescale we have. Systems, especially those containing actors that have considerable power and influence and where the status quo is in their interest, are unlikely candidates for rapid change. We have to do better.

The IPBES report specifically mentions that an economy that is sustainable is one that has steered “away from the current limited paradigm of economic growth”, and mentions a number of interventions to help us towards that sustainable model. We need to give incentives for those activities that help us towards sustainability, and remove subsidies for those that don’t. With the International Energy Agency saying there is no need for new oil and gas fields if we are to achieve net zero by 2050 then why should the fossil fuel industry continue to receive public subsidies unless that money is used to transition away from fossil fuels? Our actions, our policies, should build resilience for society and nature, and this may require collaboration between different sectors of the economy and across international borders. Environmental laws need strengthening and enforcement. We live within a system: we need to see it as such and acknowledge our place within it.

The climate change conferences, like COP 26 in Glasgow, Scotland, are relatively well known. The biodiversity conferences less so. COP 15 takes place in Montreal, Canada from the 5th – 17th December 2022. COP simply stands for ‘conference of the parties’, and the number represents that this will be the fifteenth biodiversity conference. Normally taking place every two years, COVID disruption means that this is the first conference for four years. The aim of the conference is to develop a global biodiversity framework, but the prospects leading up to the conference are not looking good. Preliminary talks in Nairobi in June 2022 ended without agreement and with criticism by conservation and other groups of the lack of engagement being shown by political leaders. The outcomes of COP 15 are ambitious: the 30% by 2030 goal, targets to prevent extinctions and restore habitats, and to halt and then reverse the loss of biodiversity that we are all so dependent on. Ambitious yes, but if we are not ambitious about achieving those things that directly affect our own well-being and long-term survival, then what point is there in ambition? Funding is an issue for some, with some African nations questioning the viability of the 30 by 30 goal without financial help from the global north. But as the COVID pandemic has shown, funding can be found when a problem is perceived as serious enough and the political will to deal with it is there.

For the ocean, there is also a governance gap. The convention on biological diversity only deals with marine biodiversity within territorial waters, typically twelve nautical miles from the coast. Beyond this, a nation has an Exclusive Economic Zone out to two hundred nautical miles from the coast, and beyond that are the high seas, both areas governed through UNCLOS (the United Nation’s Conference on the Law of the Sea). There are spaces between and within where these different laws apply, areas ‘beyond national jurisdiction’ in the jargon, where biodiversity still needs protection. The United Nations is working to close this governance gap, with a treaty to protect marine biodiversity in these areas, but again, like COP 15, progress is slow and agreement hard to reach.

Where does it come from, this failure to engage meaningfully with the challenges that face us? Is it fatalism? Is it simply a consequence of the complexities of human psychology and society? Is it our preoccupation with the now and near rather than future horizons and realities? The science is unambiguous and detailed, with uncertainties and caveats clearly stated, and yet we still are not reacting with the urgency needed. Is it a failure to take or accept responsibility? Nations (like my own) hiding behind emissions that are comparatively low now and disregarding their much higher share of emissions from the industrial revolution onwards? Whatever the reason, there is only so long we can play this game of ecological ker-plunk before the marbles will fall.

So, what can we do? In the words of Theodore Roosevelt: “Do what you can, where you are, with what you have.” Sign the 30 by 30 petition and write to your political representatives. Many conservation organisations will have campaigns around biodiversity: support them. Get involved. It is not yet too late. Hope expressed through action overcomes the inertia of pessimism.

GDPR Logo
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.