Is it only gold that glitters?

Language matters. Language can explain or elaborate, confuse or camouflage. For example, what do we mean when we say we value something? Value is a word with multiple meanings, and multiple meanings can serve many masters.
But even plain words, words we think of as describing singular concepts, can be slippery. Suppose I show you a photograph of a dog. Just an ordinary dog, bright-eyed, expectantly looking at the camera as if waiting for a ball to be thrown. And then I point to this dog and ask you ‘what is a dog?’ You might look at me a little strangely, perhaps perplexed by the question. A dog is, after all, just a dog. But look at the photograph again. To Raymond, the pensioner who lives alone this is Reggie, his friend who lies alongside him as they sit on the sofa together and watch TV. To Sally, who volunteers with the mountain rescue team, Reggie is a respected four-legged colleague, without whom a number of people may not have gone home to their families last year. To Rachel, the geneticist, Reggie is a collaborator in her research, with Reggie’s DNA helping to unravel the story of when wolves were first domesticated, how and when the path from competitor to companion was first trod. To other scientists, Reggie may literally be an experimental animal on whom procedures are performed or drugs tested, although the tag on his pen will call him ‘D149’ rather than Reggie. In some areas of the world dogs are on the menu, afforded no more consideration than a chicken in a battery cage.
How this dog is perceived, how it is loved, respected or disrespected, used or abused, is not constant. In effect, the answer to the question ‘what is a dog?’ depends on who is doing the asking and who answers.
There’s a difference between the ‘value of’ something and the ‘value in’ something. ‘Value in’ describes the intrinsic worth, the value of something for its own sake. ‘Value of’ attempts to place a monetary value, to put a price on something. Which of these win in the conflict between them may depend on the circumstance. Someone who is unemployed and reduced to destitution may sell otherwise precious belongings so that their children do not go hungry. But some things are beyond price. The beauty of a sunset is an example typically used. But I think of an indentation of the river Camel estuary, enclosed by a horseshoe of rocks, and the early Autumn sun dropping lower in the sky. There is a shallow pool left stranded by the tide and the laughter of my toddler grandson as he splashes through the knee-deep water playfully chased by his grandfather, both chased by Bernie, the German Shepherd dog, who joins in the game when not distracted by thrown sticks. There is no ‘value of’ here, no price, only the glow of memory to be cherished as the child grows to adulthood.
Language is ambiguous. The same word can mean different things to different audiences. When a scientist talks of uncertainty and error in a measurement they’re talking of the preciseness and variability of the measure. It’s actually an expression of confidence in the correctness of the measurement. But to the general public, when a scientist says “uncertainty”, they hear “we don’t know”. When a scientist says “error” they hear “mistake”. I’ve discussed before that I dislike the term “ecosystem services”, partly because it suggests a hierarchy where those receiving the service are more important than that which provides it, but it’s also that the term, like value, can mean very different things. To the scientist the term describes something provided by the ecosystem, perhaps irreplaceably. To others, with interests beyond the ecological, the focus can be on the ‘value of’ rather than the ‘value in’. ‘Value of’ suggests a valuation, but place a price on something and the ‘value in’ becomes secondary. And that gets to the heart of a valuation. Money is a system of exchange: I give you these tokens, you give me my coffee, and you take those tokens to exchange for something that you want. If something is given a price, if it has a valuation, then that means that it is exchangeable. One of the dictionary definitions of value is this idea of exchange, and then the object with the valuation becomes just another token, no different from our usual coins, banknotes, or electronic funds. The object with the valuation, whether that’s Van Gogh’s sunflowers or endangered seahorses in a seagrass bed, has become fungible, transmutable into something different – the valuation. The object comes and goes, but the valuation remains. In this way, the ‘value in’ ceases to exist and only the ‘value of’ remains.
It’s a poverty of the human imagination that so many things are reduced to a ‘value of’, rather than being held in esteem for their intrinsic worth, but it’s also the result of human psychology and human choice. It’s the culture we are immersed in. Values don’t exist in isolation. They congregate with fellow travellers, and mass like armies against those least like them. They form consistent patterns across different cultures, suggesting that it is something fundamental within us as a species.
Shalom Schwarz developed the theory of basic human values, organising them into something he called a circumplex. He placed values according to two axes. The first is a measure of what influences and drives us, whether that comes from within or from others. Self-acceptance and popularity lie at opposite ends of this axis. The second is a measure of where our priorities lie, whether that is our own pleasure and achievement, or helping others. Hedonism and spirituality are the outliers here.
An older idea of human motivation is Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, the idea that we need to satisfy our most basic needs first, like food and shelter, before we can meet higher needs such as love and friendship and reaching our potential. The exact sequencing and relationship of those needs is still contentious, so perhaps a better fit is to think of it as three layers, the borders blurry and indistinct between them. The bottom layer contains those who are security-driven. They are looking for safety and a sense of belonging; those in this layer are often tribal in their allegiances. The middle layer are those who are outer-directed. They conspicuously display, drive the right aspirational brand of car or wear the latest fashions in clothes; they gain their status and self-esteem by seeking the approval of others. The top layer contains those who are inner-directed. They already have achieved self-esteem and are motivated more by ideas and achieving their full potential.
The three worlds model of human behaviour calls these three groups settlers, prospectors, and pioneers, each fundamentally different from each other in terms of what motivates them and what feels important. This is something we all do. The values we hold affect how we view the world and how we think it should work. They intersect with our notions of ‘value of’ and ‘value in’, to form a hierarchy of what we hold to be important and what is less so. But the values we hold don’t exist in isolation – we hold them within the culture that we live in. Are our values the majority view or the minority view or something in-between? Do they coincide with the values that those in power hold or do they conflict? These are not fixed points. Values held by individuals and societies can change over time. We are rarely the same person at fifty years old that we were at twenty, and the worlds we inhabited are similarly disparate. Cultures shift over time, sometimes for the better, sometimes for the worse.
Our current culture, political and social, is one that pays lip service to tackling the climate crisis. We upgrade our phones, whether the old one still meets our needs or not. We see record-busting floods in Pakistan but then fly to Europe for a weekend city break. Governments make grand announcements easily condensed to sound bites and slogans, even though the actions underlying the announcement are insufficient or counter-productive to achieve the goal they trumpet. In July 2022 the UK Government’s net zero strategy was found to be unlawful by the high court because it failed to show how the UK’s legally binding carbon budgets would be met should the strategy be followed. In Autumn 2022 the short-lived administration of Prime Minister Liz Truss announced plans to issue new licences for oil and gas extraction in direct contradiction of the International Energy Authority report that states that “there is no need for investment in new fossil fuel supply” if the world is to meet its climate targets.
The ‘value of’ continues to be placed above the ‘value in’, even when the ‘value in’ is an intact, well-functioning biosphere that sustains us all, something that should dwarf the ‘value of’ achieved through exploiting it. Those of us who see the ‘value in’ need to persuade those who prioritise the ‘value of’ that they need to change course. We need to influence the cultural values for the better. As the IPCC states in its sixth assessment report: “Climate change is a threat to human well-being and planetary health. Any further delay … will miss a brief and rapidly closing window of opportunity to secure a liveable and sustainable future for all.” There can be no higher stakes to recognise the intrinsic value of the natural world and our place within it than this. We embrace the ‘value in’ or little of value will remain.
Leave a Reply