Restoration and recovery: saving our seagrass

Seagrass in the Isles of Scilly, Cornwall, UK. Image courtesy Michiel Vos (https://www.instagram.com/an_bollenessor) / Ocean Agency Image Bank.
Seagrass in the Isles of Scilly, Cornwall, UK. Image courtesy Michiel Vos / Ocean Agency Image Bank.

This is the third post in a three-part series on seagrass:

“May you live in interesting times” the phrase says, thought (wrongly) to originate from a Chinese curse. A curse because only the bad times were interesting; normality and stability mundane by definition. In that sense, we are certainly living in interesting times, beset by both climate and biodiversity crises, ecologically overdrawn and living beyond the capacity of our planet to recuperate and regenerate on human timescales. I would counter with two other quotes, one a Japanese proverb: “fall seven times, stand up eight”, meaning it does not matter how many setbacks you have on your chosen path, only that you choose to persist. And secondly, from Anthony Trollope: “A small daily task, if it be really daily, will beat the labours of a spasmodic Hercules”. Habits are a powerful thing, their results build, their outcomes compound. Small, repeated actions make a difference. In conservation, it can be easy to become discouraged, the rewards for our labours offset to the future, as yet unseen. Yes, seagrass is in difficulty, but decline is not inevitable. We can persist. We can make positive choices habitual. The meadows can be restored.

The first stage in restoration is not restoration, it is stopping the damage that is still being done. If the bath is overflowing then we turn off the taps and pull the plug before starting to mop the floor. In the UK context that means, primarily, tackling the issue of poor water quality by dealing with the capacity issues of the ageing wastewater systems, and dealing effectively with other sources of pollution.

Direct damage from fishing and boating needs to end. No one would object to a vessel anchoring in a seagrass bed in an emergency or where safety is at stake, but when there is a choice of where to anchor seagrass meadows should be avoided. Eco-moorings are not cheap, but do allow boats to use areas without causing damage. Fishing within seagrass meadows using gear towed along the seabed should not be permitted. There is no way to justify the damage done to such important and sensitive habitats. This exclusion is already being done in some areas of the UK coast. The organisations responsible for managing English waters within six nautical miles of the coast are the IFCAs (Inshore Fisheries and Conservation Authorities). The IFCA for the Eastern region already has byelaws in place to ban bottom trawling in protected seagrass beds in its area. Another approach would be to recognise the importance of seagrass beds by making them protected areas where this has not already been done. The EU Habitats directive lists species and habitats for which protected status should be given. While seagrass is not listed amongst the species some of the habitats that seagrass is found in are listed, meaning that they should be protected as Special Areas of Conservation (SACs). In the UK the situation is a little fluid as the post-brexit regulatory system is still something of work in progress.

Banning fishing from seagrass meadows may seem draconian. Fishers still need to make a living and fishing is statistically one of the most dangerous occupations, but with their role in capturing and storing carbon and the positive benefits to fisheries from their function as nurseries, these meadows should be seen as key national infrastructure in tackling the climate and biodiversity crises. Not all national infrastructure is steel and concrete; some is green and growing, and I say that even though I find the concept of natural capital and ecosystem services problematic, as I explored in the extinction of experience post.

Another pre-requisite for restoration is to find out what we already have. Our existing knowledge of seagrass distriution is patchy, and there are still some surprises to be had. Surveying for a restoration project found previously unknown seagrass meadows in the Fal and Helford estuaries, and Mounts Bay, Cornwall, covering an area of 172 hectares. To put this in context, this represents nearly three and a half percent of all the seagrass meadows in the UK.

Drones are increasingly being used for aerial surveys, with volunteers and researchers ‘ground-truthing’ the observations to confirm the presence of seagrass. An American study is using field visits and artificial intelligence to detect the presence of the Labyrinthula wasting disease in images from seagrass beds along 1700 miles of coast, and then relating this data to environmental conditions such as unusual changes in water temperature. Finding the factors that make seagrass prone to outbreaks of Labyrinthula means that we’re better able to protect what we have.

Restoration projects have been completed or are underway in many regions of the world, as this twitter thread from Dr. Richard Lilley, director of Project Seagrass explains. Different methods have been tried, but one general principle is that scale matters: the larger the restoration area, the more likely the restoration is to succeed. Seagrass is a foundation species, an ecosystem engineer; the establishment of new areas modifies the existing habitat, altering the water flow and sediment chemistry.

Milford Haven waterway at the south-west tip of Wales is one of the world’s deepest natural harbours. Like many harbours around the southern edge of the UK it is a ria, a river valley submerged by rising seas at the end of the last ice age. Tankers visiting the oil refineries and liquid natural gas terminals on the banks of the estuary, as well as ferries and cruise ships using the waterway, make this a busy area for shipping. And yet, there is seagrass here. At Dale, in the north-west corner, two hectares of seagrass have been restored. Small hessian bags, each containing 50 seagrass seeds, and filled with sediment collected from areas close to existing meadows were anchored to lines along the seabed by divers. Each bag one metre apart along the line, each line one metre apart, giving a grid of possible new plants one hundred metres square. Do this twice and you potentially have two hectares of new meadow. While shoots grew from almost all of the bags, the germination rates of the seeds was low, at under five per cent. This is one of the reasons why natural regeneration is slow.

Restoration is not cheap. Each hectare at Dale needed half a million seeds, collected by divers from existing meadows, processed and packed into the hessian bags. Once packed, the lines of bags needed divers again to lay them on the seabed. This is time-consuming and expensive, and so the search for cheaper, more efficient methods of restoration goes on. Scale matters. Larger restoration projects are more likely to succeed but that raises the quantity of resources needed for the restoration, and multiple organisations may come together to partner in common cause.

The ‘Save our seabed’ project is a two-and-a-half million pound project to protect five special areas of conservation (SACs), and is implemented by five organisations – Natural England (the project lead), the ocean conservation trust, based at the National Marine Aquarium in Plymouth, the Marine Conservation Society, the Royal Yachting Association, and Plymouth City Council. The project aims to restore a total of eight hectares of seagrass in Plymouth Sound and the Solent, as well as restoring seagrass beds in the the Isles of Scilly, the Essex Estuaries SAC, and the Fal and Helford estuaries.

Multiple restoration sites means that multiple methods of restoration can be explored and tested. In Plymouth Sound, the seed bags are delivered by boat. A four metre tube guides the seed bags on their descentto the seabed without the need for a diver. Keeping a steady speed and dropping one bag a second into the tube gives a spacing of around half a metre between them on the seabed.

Another approach would be to plant seedlings rather than seeds, neatly sidestepping the problem of low germination rates from seed. The ocean conservation trust has developed a seagrass nursery at the National Marine Aquarium, with the first seedlings being produced in June 2022. These seedlings will later be planted directly into the seabed by divers.

Restoration Forth in Scotland also has uses a multi-agency, collaborative approach for a joint project between the ecology centre, the Scottish Seabird Centre, and WWF-UK, aiming to restore four hectares of seagrass in the Firth of Forth. But here the restoration of the seagrass meadows is to be accompanied by the restoration of another ecosystem engineer: oyster beds. Oyster beds are ideal neighbours for seagrass, each oyster filtering up to two hundred litres of water each day, improving the clarity of the water and reducing nitrogen levels, as well as capturing carbon themselves.

But restoration can also be more community-led, more locally focused. The charity Seawilding is restoring seagrass and oyster beds in Loch Craignish. Here, a quarter of a hectare of seagrass was restored in 2021 with another quarter of a hectare planned for 2022. This may seem small in comparison to the other projects, but they train local volunteers and community groups to help in the restoration, and with surveys of the loch suggesting an area of eighty hectares for potential restoration, those volunteers could be making contributions to their community for a while yet. Seawilding, like the Restoration Forth project, is also restoring oyster beds alongside seagrass, recognising the additional benefits from restoring both together.

Many environmental problems are interlinked. One issue may affect another, which affects another, which branches off to affect yet another, but also links back to the first. Trying to fix these issues can sometimes feel like trying to untangle that set of Christmas tree lights that you were sure you packed away so carefully last year. But issues being interlinked is both a barrier and an opportunity. Start to solve one and you start to solve the others. Work on more than one simultaneously and progress builds on progress. We need our seagrass meadows to be healthy to capture and store carbon; that means we also need to tackle water quality and pollution issues. Changes in agricultural practices high in a river catchment may reduce nutrients from farming entering the river, but may also help to reduce flooding further downstream. Improving the infrastructure of our sewage and wastewater systems reduces not just the nutrients released, but also lessens the release of any potential pathogens as well. Yes, we are living in interesting times. The world turns and change is inevitable, but by our persistence, by our actions, we can make positive changes.

Further information and how you can help: