Time to stop playing the game

Urchins vs. Kelp, Great Southern Reef, Australia. Image courtesy @Ocean_Imaging (Stefan Andrew) / @theoceanagency
Urchins vs. Kelp, Great Southern Reef, Australia.
Image courtesy @Ocean_Imaging (Stefan Andrew) / @theoceanagency

There was a game I had when I was a child. It was called Ker-plunk, with a translucent plastic tower and thin plastic sticks pushed through about half-way down. The sticks crossed over each other to support marbles that had been poured in from the top. Players would take turns removing the sticks, trying not to make any marbles drop. At first it was easy, but as the number of sticks reduced marbles would start to fall. Eventually, the removal of a single stick would cause an avalanche of marbles, losing the game for that player. We are both the player and the marbles, removing sticks and ready to fall. The mesh of sticks is biodiversity, a safety net of interconnected species and habitats that supports our survival. Each stick we remove, each species we lose, takes us closer to the point where the marbles will fall.

In life there are always boundaries. Some we can push; some it is unwise to cross. The planet is no different; it has natural thresholds that together work to keep the system stable and resilient. Staying below these thresholds gives a safe space for humanity to live within. The Stockholm Resilience Centre developed a framework to define what this safe operating space looks like, and where our activities place us in relation to those boundaries. There are nine components, and our place in each component is rated as green, amber or red. Biodiversity is one of the core components. It’s assessed in two ways. One is through functional diversity, which describes how diverse the organisms within a particular functional role are – think of a habitat that’s lost most of its decomposers or top predators and it’s easy to see how a lack of diversity within a particular function can unbalance and destabilize a particular ecosystem. But functional diversity is tricky to measure. Another way is by assessing genetic diversity through measuring extinction rates. The extinction rates we are experiencing now take us into the high risk, red zone.

There have been five previous mass extinctions, where at least 75% of species were lost in a short period of time, geologically speaking. Extinction is a natural consequence of evolution: not all species will continue to exist. There is a background level of extinction, like a low note in the song of evolution, but the sound is becoming louder. It looks as if we’ve entered the sixth mass extinction. In 2019 IPBES published a global assessment report on biodiversity and ecosystem services. It assessed the situation now and where the trends would take us under different scenarios of economic activity and carbon emissions. Extinction rates now are tens to hundreds of times higher than the rates over the last ten million years, and the rates are accelerating, with around one million species facing extinction over the next few decades.

That is shocking in itself, but the headlines hide detail, and the detail is even more frightening. More than half a million terrestrial species – one in eleven – don’t have enough habitat for long-term survival unless their habitats are restored. Around a third of all the reef-building corals are threatened with extinction, along with the same proportion of sharks and their related species,. More than one in three of every marine mammal species is also threatened with extinction. Over 55% of the ocean is covered by industrial fishing, yet the primary productivity of the ocean could reduce by up to 10%, and fish biomass by 25%, if warming follows the high emissions scenario. Tackle emissions and bring the warming down to that of the low scenario and the loss of productivity and fish biomass is only 3%. Still an issue, but much less of one for the billions of people relying on the ocean for their main source of protein.

The IPBES report lists five main causes, the drivers of these declines. For land and freshwater systems, changes in the way that land is used, and direct over-exploitation of plant and animal species have been the major factors responsible for the declines in biodiversity since 1970. For marine ecosystems, these two factors are reversed: over-exploitation, mainly through over-fishing, is the major cause, with land and sea-use changes such as coastal development and increased pollution as the second factor. Climate change is the next major driver for both land and ocean

It’s no coincidence that they’re often mentioned together. They are the two core components of the planetary boundaries framework. They are linked together: nature can help us tackle climate change, yet climate change makes tackling biodiversity loss all the more difficult. Changing temperatures means that some species prosper and some lose, but not all react in the same way or at the same rate. Birds may nest and breed according to the expected glut of caterpillars in the spring. Caterpillars may hatch based on the bursting of the buds and the availability of soft, young foliage. Trees may wake from dormancy based on daytime temperatures that get earlier each year. The chain may break unless all shift their timings in tandem, and there are many interconnected chains rather than just one.

The good news is that there is action being taken. The UN decade of restoration is a “rallying call for the protection and revival of ecosystems all around the world, for the benefit of people and nature”, running from 2021 to 2030. Alongside that is the 30 by 30 initiative, aiming for 30% of the land and ocean to be protected by 2030. As aspirational and beautiful as these goals are, they are not enough by themselves, and are unlikely to be reached unless we also deal with the foundations of the biodiversity crisis.

The bad news is that the trends are all taking us in the wrong direction, and tweaks to the current system will not be enough to change this. Our economic system prioritises growth while ignoring the resulting environmental damage and externalising its costs – leaving it for others to clean up the mess and meet the expense of doing so. The IPBES report says that “most international societal and environmental goals, …, will not be achieved based on current trajectories”, and that any goals beyond 2030 “may only be achieved through transformative changes.” What does it mean by transformative change? Well, it means “a fundamental, system-wide reorganization across technological, economic and social factors, including paradigms, goals and values.” Read that again. Fundamental. System-wide. Changing paradigms – the models and frameworks society accepts as the norm. Values. George Monbiot has been making a similar argument, that incremental change is not sufficient, not fast enough, to deal with the problems facing us in the timescale we have. Systems, especially those containing actors that have considerable power and influence and where the status quo is in their interest, are unlikely candidates for rapid change. We have to do better.

The IPBES report specifically mentions that an economy that is sustainable is one that has steered “away from the current limited paradigm of economic growth”, and mentions a number of interventions to help us towards that sustainable model. We need to give incentives for those activities that help us towards sustainability, and remove subsidies for those that don’t. With the International Energy Agency saying there is no need for new oil and gas fields if we are to achieve net zero by 2050 then why should the fossil fuel industry continue to receive public subsidies unless that money is used to transition away from fossil fuels? Our actions, our policies, should build resilience for society and nature, and this may require collaboration between different sectors of the economy and across international borders. Environmental laws need strengthening and enforcement. We live within a system: we need to see it as such and acknowledge our place within it.

The climate change conferences, like COP 26 in Glasgow, Scotland, are relatively well known. The biodiversity conferences less so. COP 15 takes place in Montreal, Canada from the 5th – 17th December 2022. COP simply stands for ‘conference of the parties’, and the number represents that this will be the fifteenth biodiversity conference. Normally taking place every two years, COVID disruption means that this is the first conference for four years. The aim of the conference is to develop a global biodiversity framework, but the prospects leading up to the conference are not looking good. Preliminary talks in Nairobi in June 2022 ended without agreement and with criticism by conservation and other groups of the lack of engagement being shown by political leaders. The outcomes of COP 15 are ambitious: the 30% by 2030 goal, targets to prevent extinctions and restore habitats, and to halt and then reverse the loss of biodiversity that we are all so dependent on. Ambitious yes, but if we are not ambitious about achieving those things that directly affect our own well-being and long-term survival, then what point is there in ambition? Funding is an issue for some, with some African nations questioning the viability of the 30 by 30 goal without financial help from the global north. But as the COVID pandemic has shown, funding can be found when a problem is perceived as serious enough and the political will to deal with it is there.

For the ocean, there is also a governance gap. The convention on biological diversity only deals with marine biodiversity within territorial waters, typically twelve nautical miles from the coast. Beyond this, a nation has an Exclusive Economic Zone out to two hundred nautical miles from the coast, and beyond that are the high seas, both areas governed through UNCLOS (the United Nation’s Conference on the Law of the Sea). There are spaces between and within where these different laws apply, areas ‘beyond national jurisdiction’ in the jargon, where biodiversity still needs protection. The United Nations is working to close this governance gap, with a treaty to protect marine biodiversity in these areas, but again, like COP 15, progress is slow and agreement hard to reach.

Where does it come from, this failure to engage meaningfully with the challenges that face us? Is it fatalism? Is it simply a consequence of the complexities of human psychology and society? Is it our preoccupation with the now and near rather than future horizons and realities? The science is unambiguous and detailed, with uncertainties and caveats clearly stated, and yet we still are not reacting with the urgency needed. Is it a failure to take or accept responsibility? Nations (like my own) hiding behind emissions that are comparatively low now and disregarding their much higher share of emissions from the industrial revolution onwards? Whatever the reason, there is only so long we can play this game of ecological ker-plunk before the marbles will fall.

So, what can we do? In the words of Theodore Roosevelt: “Do what you can, where you are, with what you have.” Sign the 30 by 30 petition and write to your political representatives. Many conservation organisations will have campaigns around biodiversity: support them. Get involved. It is not yet too late. Hope expressed through action overcomes the inertia of pessimism.