Category Sharks

The shark that holds its breath

Scalloped Hammerhead shark (Sphyrna lewini)
Image CC-BY Kris-Mikael Krister
Scalloped Hammerhead shark (Sphyrna lewini) The wide-set eyes give hammerheads long visual range, better than most sharks. Image CC-BY Kris-Mikael Krister

Nature can sometimes surprise us. Some things are obvious. Whales and dolphins hold their breath when they dive – as air-breathing mammals they would drown if they didn’t. Some things are unexpected. Grey seals breathe out before they dive, to avoid some of the trickier physiological issues they would otherwise face at depth. And some things provoke a straight ‘wait, what?!’ reaction, such as the shark that holds its breath when it dives. Why would a shark – a fish that breathes underwater – hold its breath? It turns out that oxygen is not the only resource that needs conserving when an animal dives deeper into the ocean: heat also matters.

The scalloped hammerhead shark (Sphyrna lewini) lives in tropical and warm temperate waters, the sort of waters where jumping in doesn’t immediately result in the rapid gasping breath of cold shock and a desire to climb back out again. This shark is an ectotherm, which means its main source of body heat comes from the environment. Some ectotherms, like the ocean sunfish, can divert blood flow to keep particular muscles and organs warm while leaving other areas to cool, similar to how our fingers might go cold when outside on a winter’s day. Others, like the leatherback turtle generate heat with their muscles, visiting colder areas outside the range of other turtles. But none of these tricks are available to our scalloped hammerhead, and the structure of the gills that make it so good for the exchange of oxygen and carbon dioxide – a large surface area, and seawater and bloodstream in close proximity – also make it exceptionally good for the transfer of heat from shark to water. The gills work like a radiator, potentially to the disadvantage of the shark because its prey lives far below it in much colder water. Researchers at the University of Hawai’i at Manoa tagged ten sharks and recorded 106 dives using a set of instruments to measure depth, water temperature, the activity and orientation of the shark, and its core muscle temperature. They were interested in seeing how the shark might deal with the thermal challenges of hunting in water of only five or six degrees centigrade.

So, let’s pick a shark and follow them on a typical dive to see what they do. Our shark starts near the surface. It’s night; the water temperature is 26oC. They start to swim down, a gentle descent at a shallow angle, like a submarine nudging down to a greater depth. When they reach a depth of perhaps 110 metres their orientation changes. They turn steeply downwards, hold their breath and descend. They swim faster and the temperature drops by as much as 20oC in five or six minutes until the shark, now at a depth of more than 600 metres, levels off and starts to hunt. The tracking data shows short sprints as the shark searches for squid in the darkness. Time is limited. Four minutes later, the shark turns sharply upwards, swimming strongly in a mirror of its descent path. At around a depth of 290 metres the shark slows and turns closer to the horizontal as it makes a steady approach towards the surface waters, recovering.

The researchers called this change in angle on the ascent the inflection point. It is here that a drop in muscle temperature was recorded: the shark, still in relatively cooler waters, has taken a breath, the need for oxygen outweighing the need to conserve heat. The dive has lasted almost an hour, and the shark has held its breath for 17 minutes of that time. So how does a shark do it? One way would be to divert blood away from the gills reducing oxygen intake as well as heat loss, but examination of dead sharks accidentally caught by fishermen didn’t show any evidence of that. A second way would be to close the gill slits to stop water flow over the gills. Scalloped hammerheads have been filmed swimming with their gill slits tightly closed at deeper depths than in this study, so it seems likely that this is the technique they use. So, a shark that holds its breath. Not what you may have been expecting. Let’s leave the last word to Mark Royer, the lead author on the paper: “This was a complete surprise! It is an extraordinary behaviour from an incredible animal.”

***

The research paper on which this post is based is: Royer et al (2023). “Breath holding” as a thermoregulation strategy in the deep-diving scalloped hammerhead shark. Science, 380 (6445), 651-655.

The basking shark: sanctuary at last?

It is 1975. I am eleven years old, and my parents, my twin sister and I are going to the cinema to watch Jaws. My favourite TV program is The Undersea World of Jacques Cousteau, and it has given me a fascination for the ocean, despite living about as far from it as you can get in the UK. I have read about this film, read about how people have reacted to it, and heard about the ‘eyeball’ moment. I am unsure, frightened even. It’s irrational, but it’s a feeling I can’t shake. Not a fear of sharks, but a fear of my own reaction: what if watching this film changes how I feel about the ocean? What if I no longer feel at home in the water, always looking for what may be about to burst through a haze of poor visibility to harm me? Thankfully, the film did not change me, and while I do sometimes have dreams where I am underwater with sharks, they are not nightmares. The sharks in these dreams do not attack me. I feel no fear, only curiosity and wonder.

Original artwork of a basking shark feeding
A basking shark feeds
© 2018 Duncan Greenhill

We have many species of sharks in the waters around the UK, from the smallspotted catshark with its puppy-like cuteness, to the cobalt beauty of the blue shark, to the imposing majesty of the basking shark, the largest around these coasts. It is the second largest fish in the world; only the whale shark grows larger. Six to eight metres long is a typical size for a basking shark, although they can grow up to twelve metres and weigh four tonnes. Despite their size, they pose no danger to humans, feeding only on plankton filtered from the water. Yet every summer the tabloid papers will, at some point, run a story along the lines of ‘monster sharks stalk our beaches’, seeing all sharks as a danger.

Four basking sharks swim in formation in the sea of the Hebrides, their dorsal fins slicing the surface, and light from the sun dancing patterns like camouflage across their backs. From May to October they will feed at the surface like this, the behaviour that gives them their name of ‘basking’ shark. They feed on the spring bloom of plankton, whose growth is boosted by the warming water and longer days. The sharks swim with mouths agape; they are ‘ram’ feeders, forward motion providing the flow of water across their gill rakers, the comb-like structures that line their mouth and catch their prey. Their mouths are only closed to swallow the plankton filtered from the sea. This is a small group, but small groups are not uncommon. The groups can be very much larger. In 2005, an aerial survey off the north-east coast of the USA recorded an aggregation of almost 1400 animals.

The islands of North Uist, Benbecula, and South Uist mark the western border between the sea of the Hebrides and the Atlantic Ocean. The Isle of Skye guards the north-east corner, while the west coast of the Scottish mainland runs down the eastern edge to the Isle of Mull. This sea is one of three hotspots, three areas where the basking sharks congregate and are frequently seen; the others are around the Isle of Man, and around the south-west tip of the UK.

The four sharks swim in proximity, sometimes closely following each other, sometimes swimming in echelon formation, where each shark swims near the pectoral fin of the shark in front, like the ‘V’ of a flock of migrating geese in flight. For an animal so large they are still something of an enigma, with still so much unknown about their behaviour and biology. Perhaps there is an energetic efficiency in swimming like this, always useful when your prey can be concentrated in patches many kilometres apart. Perhaps the sharks position themselves to take advantage of the prey missed by the sharks ahead of them. In European seas copepods are a common prey item, and later life stages can ‘jump’ as they detect pressure changes in the water from an approaching predator. For some, this will be an ‘out of the frying pan, and into the fire’ moment as their jumps place them in the path of the sharks following behind.

Such a large animal feeding on small prey means that it must find and eat large quantities. Spring blooms are one source, but these pass. There is another: oceanic fronts. In summer the surface waters in some areas can warm up, becoming less dense, and ‘floating’ on top of a colder, denser layer. This summer stratification means that nutrients in the upper layer that fuel the growth of phytoplankton – the microscopic algae that the copepods feed on – are quickly used up, and plankton growth slows. The density change acts as a border between the two layers, causing a paucity of nutrients close to the surface as they are used up and not replaced.

In other areas the water is not separated into layers. There is no barrier between the deeper and surface waters. Nutrients are present from surface to seabed. Where these two types of water – stratified and well-mixed – meet is called an oceanic front. This is the jackpot for the basking sharks; the plankton thrives here. The sharks will travel long distances to find these fronts and once there will move seemingly in random directions, sometimes for a short time before turning and sometimes for much longer. They are looking for an accumulation of plankton. Mathematicians call this pattern a Lévy walk or Lévy flight. Then, finding that richness of plankton, they will slow and turn more frequently, their movements keeping them inside the patch as much as possible while they feed. The ecologists call this pattern of movement area restricted searching. The plankton may not always be at the surface; they migrate up and down through the water during the day. The sharks will descend from the surface to the bottom and then return, ‘yo-yo’ diving, searching for where the plankton are to be found.

I crossed this Hebridean sea once as a young man, a soldier, on a flat-bottomed military transport ship heading to a firing camp on South Uist where anti-aircraft missiles would be flung at targets towed over the Atlantic. The weather was not kind, and I drank mug after mug of warm, sweet tea in an unsuccessful attempt to ward off seasickness. But these waters have seen real conflict beyond training for the defence of a nation: conflict between man and shark. Blood has been spilled into these waters in the pursuit of profit. A basking shark’s liver can form up to a quarter of its body weight, of which nearly 40% can be an oil called squalene. This oil, derived from the shark’s planktonic prey, functions as both an energy source and for buoyancy, and many deep diving shark species have high concentrations in their liver. The oil, originally used for lighting, was also a valuable engineering and aircraft oil. For over 200 years the sharks were pursued for this oil by fishers from the UK, Ireland and Norway, with harpoon and net. The estimates vary. One study gave the catch in the forty years between 1946 and 1986 as over 77,000 individual sharks caught and processed.

Recovery from such depredation is slow. Despite the number of sharks taken there is only one recorded case of a pregnant female being caught in 1936, who gave birth to six pups, one stillborn, while being towed after capture. Even something as how long gestation lasts is not known with certainty, but is thought to be between one and two years. Small numbers of young on this timescale means that rebuilding populations takes time. While they are no longer actively pursued they are still sometimes caught accidentally as by-catch, by trawling and gill-netting, slowing recovery further.

Sharks congregate where the plankton patches are richest. Some groups are of similar sizes or of the same sex, but where the group is mixed proximity while feeding permits the fulfilling of other biological needs. They follow each other closely, breaking away to swim in parallel. One may approach another by swimming towards its side. Pectoral fins may be bitten. They may breach, leaping upwards out of the water, as great white sharks have been seen to do as part of their courtship behaviour. They will mate in the summer, the male transferring packets of sperm called spermatophores into the female using his claspers, the tubular organs that lie along the body at the base of their pelvic fins. Fertilisation is internal, as is the laying and hatching of the eggs and the development of the young sharks, before their eventual live birth as one-and-a-half metre long miniatures of their parents. The newly-born males will take at least twelve years before they themselves may mate, while the females may be twenty years old before they make their own contribution to the population.

In UK waters, the basking shark has been protected since 1998, but the outlook for the species is not good. The IUCN publishes its red list of threatened species. In the assessments undertaken in 1996, 2000, and 2009 the basking shark was classed as vulnerable. In 2019 and 2021 the assessment listed them in the more serious category of endangered. Conserving species that are mobile, that travel large distances, is difficult because of the size of the area that would need to be protected, but by protecting key areas such as those used for foraging or breeding a positive contribution to their conservation can be made. Satellites can detect the temperature of the ocean, can signpost the existence and development of the oceanic fronts so beneficial to the basking shark. The sea of Hebrides is one area where these fronts are frequently found, and in December 2020 over ten thousand square kilometres of this sea was declared a Nature Conservation Marine Protected Area. This sea, once the scene of carnage for this species is now a haven for it. I hope to sail these waters again one day in my own boat, with basking sharks alongside that match or exceed the 8m length of the hulls; here be monsters, and we are all the richer for having them.

GDPR Logo
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.