Tidal Flows, Tidal Power

An ocean wave on the verge of breaking. Image courtesy: @theoceanagency / @ThomasHorig
An ocean wave on the verge of breaking. Image courtesy: @theoceanagency / @ThomasHorig

This was my (unsuccessful) application for the Save Our Seas Foundation Ocean Storytelling Writing Grant, submitted at the end of November 2022. Congratulations to the three winners, and looking forward to reading their work.

Thirty metres underwater in the inner sound of the Pentland Firth a harbour seal searches for a meal of sandeels. Nearer the surface razorbills row themselves through the water looking for herring. An unimaginable mass of water squeezes between the Orkney islands and the north coast of Scotland, moving between the Atlantic and the North Sea and back again. Here, the speed and turbulence of the water attracts all partners in the dance between predator and prey, but they are not alone in their interest. Here, people and nature are brought together by the surges and eddies of tidal waters. For the animals, to feed themselves; for us, to feed our society’s hunger for energy.

The Pentland Firth sits at the very north-eastern tip of the mainland UK where two islands, Stroma and Swona, squat like stepping stones between the mainland and the Orkney islands. On the seabed about halfway from the mainland to Stroma lies phase I of the MeyGEN tidal energy project. Scotland has a rich potential for wave and tidal energy, the result of having around sixteen and a half thousand kilometres of coastline and many narrow channels to funnel the tide on its daily rise and ebb. That, and the powerful Atlantic swells that roll on to the west coast unhindered by any intervening land masses. The four turbines of phase one became operational in April 2018, with a capacity of six million watts (6 MW), enough to provide the electricity for 2,600 homes. Phase one is the demonstration phase. Phase two, already approved, is for an array of turbines providing 80 MW. A third phase would expand the array further to a capacity of almost 400 MW.

But everything has an impact: nothing is without environmental consequences, of which the risk of collision is one. The blades of the turbines in phase one are eighteen metres in diameter, the slowest of the two types turning eight times a minute at full power, giving the blade tip a speed of around seven and a half metres per second. The result of a spinning blade hitting a seal is not likely to end in the seal’s favour.

The ocean is far from quiet, and turbines add yet another instrument to the orchestra of man-made sounds. The turbines themselves emit noise from the movement of their components: gears, bearings and generators, but also from the tumbling chaos of the water as it leaves the spinning blades. Noise can exclude. Noise can displace. Those species that hunt or sense their surroundings through sound are particularly vulnerable. Dolphins, harbour porpoise and Orca have all been seen in the waters of the Pentland Firth.

A third, more unusual, potential impact could easily be overlooked. The turbines feed their power to a hub on the seabed, and from there a cable brings the power ashore. These cables generate electro-magnetic fields. Some animals, such as sharks, can detect the minute electric fields from their prey. Others, such as eels, sense magnetic fields to navigate. What effect would the cables have on these animals?

Doug Gillespie, Gordon Hastie and Joe Onouifrou, researchers from the Sea Mammal Research Unit at the University of St. Andrews, are working to assess some of these impacts. Harbour seals were tagged with GPS transmitters and their movements followed to answer two questions: did the seals change their behaviour when the turbines were installed, and do they behave differently when the turbines are turning? The tag data told the story. The presence of the turbines made no difference, no more than any other underwater obstacle. With the turbines turning the seals started to avoid the area, with a fall in numbers of almost thirty per cent within two kilometres of the turbines. The most likely cause, based on seal behaviour elsewhere in the world, is noise. That still leaves the majority of seals continuing to use the area, still risking a fatal interaction with the turbine blades. But how do the animals behave around the turbines? How do we ‘see’ their behaviour in murky, fast-flowing water thirty metres below the surface? The researchers have the answer: HiCUP, or High Current Underwater Platform. This package of scientific instruments has hydrophones to record the clicks and whistles of whales and dolphins, a technique called passive acoustic monitoring or PAM. But hydrophones only detect those species that make sounds, and many species do not, or at least too rarely to be useful for reliable detection; seals rarely vocalise. For these animals a different approach is needed: HiCUP has two multibeam sonars. One sonar alone will give you position on a horizontal plane. Add a second, its beam slightly offset vertically, and you gain some idea of the depth of the returning echo. HiCUP sends its data ashore but the quantities are huge, much too large for email or online storage, so the hard disks are sent back to the researchers by courier. And then, this mass of data needs to be analysed. Is this echo a seal or a shark? A cormorant or a razorbill? For now, deciphering these echoes still needs human expertise, but the researchers are developing software tools to automate this, much needed if we are to meaningfully process and analyse the data from multiple sites. And with better analysis of data we gain a better understanding of risk.

This is one tidal energy site. We will need many more, along with their above surface brethren of offshore wind if we are to reduce carbon dioxide emissions, reduce the exhaust of our addiction to fossil fuels. The exhaust that warms the atmosphere and then the ocean, raises sea levels and alters oceanic chemistry. We are inextricably linked to the ocean, and we can (and must) provide for our needs without degrading the ocean’s provision for its own. The story of the ocean is our story, its future ours.