Island Planet, Island People

Pacific Ocean from space. Image courtesy NASA
Pacific Ocean from space. Image courtesy NASA

A blue sphere hangs dwarfed by the blackness of space: Earth. Astronauts who have seen it talked of a shift in perspective, a shift in consciousness almost. They speak of its smallness, its fragility. They experience a feeling that the artificial distinctions we place on ourselves – alliances, races, nations – are just that: arbitrary divisions of a common humanity. Look down on the Pacific Ocean from space and there is a small halo of land at the edges, the rest is water. The land masses do not enclose the ocean, they are surrounded by it. Ellen MacArthur, when sailing solo around the world, reflected on the need to conserve what she had, that any response to her own or the boat’s needs had to come from within, from what the boat was carrying. From whatever scale we view it – planet, continent, nation or boat – we are all island people, dependent solely on what our particular island can provide. Paradoxically, it is the ocean that makes this island Earth somewhere suitable for us to live.

The Earth’s deepest valleys and its highest mountainous peaks are found not on land, but beneath the ocean’s surface. We may talk of the Atlantic, the Pacific, the Arctic, the Indian or the Southern Ocean, but these are just names for particular areas, particular basins in a single, global ocean that surrounds the lands we call home. It is the ocean that absorbs most of the solar radiation reaching the Earth, and a global circulation driven by wind, waves, water temperature and density that transports this heat between different parts of the world. Heat moves between ocean and atmosphere, driving global and local patterns of weather, dividing peoples into haves and have-nots, into those beset by drought or blessed by rain; rain that itself was brought into being by evaporation from the ocean. Change the ocean circulation, change the distribution of heat, and you change the fate of billions of people.

As Sylvia Earle has said: “No blue, no green”. We are as dependent on the ocean as much as any whale, dolphin or seal, but we forget this. This is partly because of an extinction of experience, the loss of connection with nature, partly because of our perspective as a terrestrial species; we are creatures of the land, why should the ocean concern us?

The Amazon rainforest is sometimes called the ‘lungs of the world’ because, like all plants, it releases oxygen as one of the products of photosynthesis. But that’s our terrestrial bias creeping in again, distorting our viewpoint. At least half of the oxygen we breathe is released not by land-based plants but from the ocean through the actions of billions of phytoplankton. Microscopic, their small size obscures them from our gaze and disguises their importance while they silently top up the atmospheric reservoir of oxygen that we breathe from, keeping us alive, and providing the basis on which much of the life in the ocean ultimately depends.

As if providing breathable air is not enough, the ocean has also, so far, lessened the impact of our own recklessness, absorbing at least a fifth of the carbon dioxide we have short-sightedly emitted to the atmosphere in the last two decades alone. The ocean has subsidised our use of fossil fuels, but not without cost to itself. The ocean and atmosphere are connected, with heat and gases exchanging between the two at the surface. The increase in carbon dioxide concentration and heat is a double blow for coral reefs, the combination causing the coral polyps to expel the symbiotic algae that live within them, and which provide their colour and 90% of the energy the corals need to survive. The corals are left pale, ‘bleached’, operating at an energetic loss that will eventually kill them if the water temperatures do not fall in time. These reefs protect coastlines, provide economic benefits through tourism and fisheries for the communities that live by them and, no less important, they have their own innate value for their beauty and rich diversity of life.

The ocean regulates the climate. The Gulf stream flows from the Caribbean across the Atlantic to western Europe, bringing huge quantities of heat, and the occasional navigationally confused turtle. Europe is warmer than it would otherwise be, with milder winters. The flow continues further north, the water becoming cooler and denser until it reaches a place and a point where gestation is complete and genesis occurs: sea ice forms. The forming of sea ice pulls freshwater from the ocean to leave behind a saltier, denser plume of water that sinks to the seabed, asserts its identify as the North Atlantic Deep Water, and begins its long journey flowing along the bottom of the Atlantic towards Antarctica. Scientists refer to the pattern of currents here, the warmer, salty water near the surface and the colder, deeper flows southward, as the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation, or AMOC. But this liquid conveyor belt of heat, globally important, is threatened by climate change, and weakening.

Arrays of instruments span the Atlantic to monitor the movement and characteristics of the water that makes up this circulation. The earliest of these arrays dates to 2004, giving us almost two decades of data that show a weakening of the AMOC, but two decades is a short time, insufficiently short, when talking of the climate. Climate change models also predict a weakening of the AMOC, but the changes we see are outpacing the models. The AMOC is the weakest it has been for over a thousand years, with significant declines from the 19th century onwards, and the recent weakening is happening ten times faster than predicted. The Arctic is warming faster than more temperate regions, releasing freshwater from the melting of the Greenland Ice Sheet that acts to reduce the salinity of the seawater in the critical areas of ocean where deep water forms and sinks. Overall, it is more difficult for sea ice to form and leave behind the saltier water that drives the circulation. The AMOC appears to exist in two modes, two stable states. There is the ‘strong’ mode, the one that we see now, and a ‘weak’ mode, where the flows of water and heat are very much reduced. Characteristic patterns of water temperatures at the surface and at depth act as early warning signals and show that we are getting closer to the tipping point when the circulation switches to this weaker mode.

The consequences of a switch would be global and severe. The delivery of heat from the tropics to the temperate seas of Europe would stop, dropping the average temperature, and changing the patterns and volume of rainfall. Part of the signal of a weakening circulation is warming of the seas where the Gulf stream starts and a cooling in northern seas as less heat is transferred north. But warmth is energy and warmer tropical seas evaporate more water to fuel more frequent and more powerful hurricanes.

The current carries more than just heat. Like a savings account at a bank, the AMOC transports large amounts of carbon to deposit them in the sedimentary vaults of the deep ocean. Lose this transport, and the challenge of tackling climate change becomes that much harder. Water that descends to the depths must eventually surface, bringing within it rich supplies of nutrients to fuel the growth of phytoplankton and the other creatures that depend on them. Around three billion people worldwide depend on the ocean for their primary source of protein. Some of the fisheries that provide this protein depend on this upwelling while others depend on the productivity of the shelf seas – the relatively shallow waters near to the coast. Many fisheries are either over-exploited or close to being fully exploited. There is no slack, no spare capacity to compensate for any reductions in fish stocks that result from a change in ocean circulation and the distribution of nutrients. Put simply, people will starve, most likely those in the global south already disproportionately hit by the consequences of climate change.

As a child in the 1970s the ‘undersea world of Jacques Cousteau’ series of books were frequent presents at Christmas and birthdays. In one of them he talked about the mineral resources in the deep sea, nodules rich in manganese, zinc and other elements, and how one day we might mine these for use. Today, that prospect is much closer. These minerals and rare earths are used in electric vehicles and the other electronic devices that define our modern age. Yet we know so little of the deep ocean, and what damage extracting those resources would do.

The abyssal plains that cover much of the ocean floor are typically around four kilometres deep. Light does not reach these depths, and food is scarce, falling from above either as a snowfall of dead plankton, the occasional bounty of a larger carcass such as a whale, or for predators a chance encounter in the dark. They are low energy environments; water moves slowly. Disturbance of the sediment is likely to persist for a long time, like a tyre print across tundra or the footprint of an astronaut in lunar dust. The creatures that live here are highly specialised and, with the exception of life around hydrothermal vents, sparsely distributed.

At a conference I attended in 2014 one presenter showed a map of an area where deep sea mining was proposed. On the slide were markers showing the location of sightings recorded in a biodiversity database. He then went to the next slide, which removed all the sightings from the top 1500m of water leaving only the deeper sightings. There were no markers. None. There was literally no data on the species that lived in that area at the depths at which deep sea mining would take place. This is less ignoring the precautionary principle and more denying its existence. How can any extraction be justified without a detailed and proper analysis of the impacts that it would cause? Have we learned nothing from our experience of using CFCs, DDT, or the extraction of fossil fuels?

We are all island peoples, surrounded by ocean, utterly dependent on it for our continued well-being and survival. Our actions have consequences; we are damaging and stressing the ocean, and through that damaging ourselves. Unless we are careful, unless we change course, we may find that we have crossed a climate tipping point, like the AMOC switching to a weaker state, and entered a time where we have little control or agency over what the consequences will be. At that point, we may find that we have damaged beyond redemption that with which we need to survive and prosper.