Footprints

The sand glistens. Footprints mar its surface, their ridges and troughs a photographic negative of the sole that made them. A wave arrives on the beach, hissing the last of its momentum to blur and level the footprints before falling back to be replaced by another. The tide rises and falls; the reliable ticking of a planetary clock. In one sense, the movement of the tides is an illusion. We see the solidity of the land and the fluidity of the water, and assume we know the nature of the movement between the two. But we would be wrong. A combination of gravitational attraction and planetary motion produces two bulges of water on opposite sides of the world, beneath which the land moves as the Earth rotates while the bulges slop and surge around it.
Everything has an impact. Everything we do leaves a mark. Step as lightly on the Earth as we can and still we leave footprints as an inevitable trace of our having passed that way. One of our deepest footprints is the carbon dioxide our civilisation exhales into the atmosphere. Massing like an invading army on the border, its capacity to damage and devastate is growing. The quantity rises and falls with the passing of the seasons, but the fall in winter never quite reaches the previous starting point and so the concentration sawtooths ever upwards.
Our society stands on a foundation of easily available energy. It fuels our transportation, enables our communications, powers our entertainments. With the possible exception of air travel, electricity could substitute for our other uses of energy, but its impact depends on the methods we use to generate it. This is where the ocean, with the rise and fall of the tide, offers us the chance to tread more gently on the Earth.
Energy from the tides has a long history. In Milford Haven the Carew Tidal Mill, built around 1801, trapped the tide to grind flour, but technology rarely remains static, evolving and morphing into something new. In Brittany, France the estuary of the river Rance is enclosed by a tidal barrage, generating electricity since it first went into operation in 1966. Strange then, that power from the tides should be such a novel idea in the UK, since the UK has the second highest tidal range in the world, second only to Canada.
But how to harness the power from these immense movements of water? Swansea Bay, South Wales, between where the river Tawe and the river Neath meet the waters of the Bristol Channel, is the site for a proposed tidal lagoon. The Blue Eden project, once built, will have a sea wall almost nine and a half kilometres long and enclose nearly twelve square kilometres of water at high tide. It will have the capacity to generate 320 million Watts of power (320 MW), enough to meet the energy demands of 155,000 homes. This project, costing £1.7 billion and funded entirely by the private sector, will be built in three phases over twelve years. As well as power from the tidal lagoon, there are plans for a floating solar array in the adjacent Queen’s dock, a data centre run solely on renewable energy, and a climate and oceanic research centre. There will be energy-efficient homes for 5,000 people using the waste heat from the data centre, and 150 floating homes.
Large projects are administratively complex, often needing multiple permissions and consents from multiple agencies. Wales has the added complication of being a devolved Government, with powers and responsibilities split between themselves and the central Government of the UK. Where there is administrative complexity there is always the possibility of delay, of an arduous journey to completion, or even cancellation as an earlier proposal for a tidal lagoon on the same site found.
The earlier project, Swansea Bay Tidal Lagoon, was originally given planning consent in 2015, but also needed a marine licence from Natural Resources Wales. This was initially refused on environmental grounds, with the impacts on fish populations thought too severe. The developers contested the refusal and the Hendry Review (commissioned by the UK Government) recommended the project should be built. The Welsh Government confirmed financial support for the project in early 2018 only for the UK central Government to then decide not to issue the project with a contract for difference (CfD) later that year. A contract for difference is one way of supporting the development of technologies that can’t yet compete directly on price. It pays the difference between what the market will pay for the electricity and the cost of generating it, subsidising the technology as it develops, as economies of scale are gained and costs fall until the subsidy is no longer needed. It is a model that worked well in the early days of onshore wind power, which is now amongst the cheapest forms of electricity available in the UK. A key legal permission, the development consent order, expired in 2020, ending the prospects for the project.
But all was not over. The proposal was revived as part of a wider project, Blue Eden, which proposed a more extensive redevelopment of Swansea waterfront. Construction is planned to begin in 2023, subject to planning consent which, as we have seen with the earlier proposal is not necessarily straight-forward.
One key advantage of tidal energy is that the tides are predictable, unlike some other forms of renewable energy. We know when a particular tide will be, months and years in advance. We know how high it should be, although wind direction and air pressure may alter the height of tide that we actually get. Contrast this predictability with wave energy where the wave height (and the power produced from it) depends on the strength and duration of the winds in the hours and days before. One reason we need tidal predictions is that the time of high tide changes from day to day, and varies from place to place. This variability is an inconvenience if you’re a fisherman, sailor, or freight ship captain, but very useful if you’re putting together an energy grid. Tides are always falling or rising somewhere; tidal streams flooding in one place, ebbing in another. There is a minimum amount of energy we need to generate called the baseload. Fall below this and our power grid may fail. Choose wisely in where we place our sites and we can use tidal energy to make a significant contribution to generating this baseload energy. Of course, how significant a contribution depends on the size of each site, how many we have, and where we put them around the coast.
Each of these lagoons will leave their mark on the Earth, as all of humanity’s works do, but what will that mark be? There are existing installations such as the tidal barrage in Brittany, France but tidal barrages and tidal lagoons are different. A tidal barrage encloses the mouth of an estuary with a relatively short sea wall, and rivers discharge freshwater into the area behind it, changing the characteristics of the estuary. A tidal lagoon is different; it uses a longer sea wall to enclose an area of water between two points on the coast. The two types are not the same. This means that experience with tidal barrages may not be the best teacher when learning how best to build and operate a tidal lagoon project. This is one of the reasons why the Swansea project is described as a ‘pathfinder’ project – an opportunity to learn, to troubleshoot, to advance the technology before the building of larger projects.
If we are to learn the most from the Swansea Bay project then surveying and monitoring are vital. We must know how things are before we can measure how they change. In the UK proposals for development are usually preceded by a phase I habitat survey, a standardised ecological assessment designed to identify what species and habitats are present, and whether any are protected, which would cause changes to the plans for the development. At Swansea the biological surveys for the previous project proposal were extensive. Fish, surveyed over a year to tease out the seasonal links between areas used for feeding, spawning or nurseries. Birds, surveyed to identify breeding and overwintering populations, as well as to document the local, more permanent, residents. But a tidal lagoon project needs onshore facilities as well, for example to connect to the electricity grid, and that means impacts on land as well as at sea. They may not be the most obvious candidates to be affected by a tidal energy development but bats and reptiles were also surveyed for.
Once the lagoon is built and generating electricity (assuming it is not delayed yet again), then the next phase of monitoring begins. In open water collision with tidal stream turbines is a risk for marine mammals such as harbour porpoises or grey seals. What risks here, where the flow of water around the turbines is constrained by the openings for them in the sea wall? Acoustic deterrents could be used to deter wildlife, but these have their own disadvantages to those that use sound to feed or navigate. The sea wall will cause the pattern and speed of currents to change, speeding up in one place, slowing in another. Moving water carries sediments. Where the water moves more quickly sediment is picked up and transported. The faster the water the bigger the sediment particles that can be carried; gravels instead of sand, sand instead of mud. Where the water slows, the sediment is dropped. The initial surveys looked at what types of sediment were present, and where they were found within the site. Together with measurements of wave heights, currents and turbidity these help develop an understanding of how silts or sands might be transported. Continued surveying and monitoring after construction turns a prediction of what might happen into a description of what did happen. Comparing the two adds another page to the book that shows us how to best build and use these technologies.
But our ambition should not be simply to document and reduce the impacts the lagoon may have. There is also the opportunity to enhance. The sea wall will become an artificial reef, and so what the sea wall is built from and how it is built matters. By varying the roughness of the surface, and using a mix of rock and crevice sizes, a much wider diversity of creatures can make it their home than would be able to on a plain concrete slab. Artificial rock pools can be added to the intertidal sections of the sea wall, increasing the complexity of the habitat further. Swansea Bay was once home to an oyster fishery, but pollution and overfishing reduced the population too much to support one now. Spatting ponds, where mature oysters can spawn, could be placed inside the lagoon, and used to re-stock the bay. Oysters, as well as providing food and employment through a fishery, also improve water quality through filtration, and store carbon. The lagoon would also be an ideal location for seagrass restoration, boosting biodiversity and again storing carbon.
Everything we do leaves an ecological footprint. Energy from the tides leaves a smaller impact in its extraction and use than oil and gas, but it is not without consequence. We have the tools and techniques with which to monitor and measure these impacts, and can learn from them as the technology progresses. We can place activities where they complement each other, like the co-location of the solar array and data centre of the Blue Eden project. Synergies build, moving closer to a more sustainable, more circular, economy. If we must leave a footprint then it is our responsibility to ourselves, our children, our planet and the wildlife we share it with, to make that footprint as light as we can.