Whales: how small can you go?

It’s a stunning sight: a humpback whale breaks through the ocean surface, mouth agape to engulf tonnes of water and the prey it contains. But why are whales the size that they are? How they feed seems to be the key.
Whales and dolphins are all cetaceans, and the cetaceans are divided into two groups. Unhelpfully, the two groups are not ‘whales’ and ‘dolphins’. For example, Killer Whales, more correctly called Orca, are actually large dolphins. The first group includes the rare and elusive beaked whales, the sperm whale, and all the dolphins and porpoises. This group is the odontoceti, the toothed whales. The second group are the baleen whales, sometimes called the ‘whalebone’ whales, named for the baleen plates in their mouths that are made of keratin, the same biological material that hair and fingernails contain. Scientists call this group the mysticeti.
There seems to be a critical size for whales that determines how they feed. Below a certain size they feed on individual prey items, like fish or squid, one at a time. Orca, the largest dolphin species, include seals in their diet. This feeding strategy is typical of the toothed whales, often using sound – biological sonar – to locate, track and then target their prey for capture.
Above this critical size baleen whales feed on shoals of smaller prey items, taking many at one time. Some baleen whales feed simply by opening their mouths and swimming forward through clouds of their prey, a method called ram-feeding. Bowhead whales, found only in Arctic and sub-Arctic waters, feed in this way. It’s a technique adopted by non-cetaceans, too. The two largest fish species in the world are both filter-feeding sharks: the basking shark and the whale shark.
The Rorquals are a sub-group within the baleen whales, and includes the humpback and the blue whale. They have what look like ‘lines’ running parallel to their lower jaw. Rorquals are the gulp- or lunge-feeders. They accelerate towards a shoal of prey and open their mouths. The ‘lines’ are actually folds of skin that allow the throat to expand to enclose a huge volume of water and the prey within it. It’s effective, but costs a lot of energy.
There is also a difference in size as well as feeding strategy between the two main groups. The baleen whales are big, the toothed whales generally much smaller, with one exception: the sperm whale. The sperm whale is a large toothed whale that dives to feed on single prey items, like giant squid, that live deep in the ocean. Why is it the exception? Scientists think that in this case, the large body size means that they have a more powerful biosonar to detect their prey in the darkness of the deep.
The blue whale, a Rorqual, is the largest animal to have ever lived, but what about a minimum size? Why are there no lunge-feeding whales the size of a common dolphin? Like a roller coaster, is there a biological equivalent of ‘you have to be this big to take this ride’? An international team of researchers from the USA and Australia think that the answer is yes, and that Minke whales are the smallest species that could feed in this way. “Minke whales are right at the threshold” says lead author David Cade “Anything smaller than a Minke could not achieve the foraging rates necessary to survive.”
All animals have an energy budget: to live, they have to take in more energy than they spend. How much energy a whale takes in depends on how often they feed when they dive, and how much prey they capture with each feeding attempt. Antarctic Minke whales feed on krill. The researchers tagged 23 Minke whales during 2018 and 2019, measuring how deep and how often they fed, and compared it to the feeding behaviour of blue and humpback whales, who also feed on krill. The bigger the whale the more water and krill it can engulf, not just in terms of the total volume, but also in relation to their body size. A blue whale can engulf water equivalent to around 135% of its body mass, while a Minke whale can only engulf water equivalent to 42% of its body mass. For Rorquals – these lunge-feeding whales – bigger is better it would seem.
Krill spend their days at depth to avoid predators and then migrate towards surface waters at night. A whale will need to dive deep to feed during the day, and while Minkes dive to the same depths as blues, their smaller size means that they feed less effectively. To compensate for this, their feeding rates are much higher, and they can lunge-feed sometimes as often as every fifteen seconds. All of the Rorquals are thought to have evolved from a Minke-sized common ancestor, and once lunge-feeding had developed as a feeding technique a larger size meant more efficient feeding. Evolution did the rest, resulting in the variety of larger whale species we see in our ocean today.
But there are limits to this evolutionary tendency of ‘big is better’. The larger an animal the more food it needs each day for its energy budget to remain in credit: large predators need lots of prey. But prey populations also need to be large enough so that they themselves can survive and reproduce, despite their losses to their leviathan predators. And these prey species also need to feed, which means that the populations of what they consume – their prey – would also need to be larger.
Energy is the currency that all living things depend on, and there are critical points at both ends of the size scale. For large whales, there comes a point at which becoming bigger is not an advantage, when more energy is expended for no increase in the amount of prey captured because there is only so much prey available. Any larger, and prey populations are too small for the whales to prosper. At the other end of the scale, the energy budget of the Minke whales is just above the break-even point, just in profit. Any smaller as an adult and it would not be able to lunge-feed often enough and catch enough prey to make up for the energy spent in feeding. It’s energy budget would be in debt, and running at a loss, and no animal can survive that for long.
A humpback whale breaks through the surface, mouth wide, the skin of its throat bulging, while a few lucky herring make the leap from mouth back to ocean. It is both spectacular and energetically costly. But there are reasons behind why these animals are this size, and why they behave and feed in the way that they do.