MPAs: Protected, highly protected, or paper parks?

They say experience is learning from your own mistakes, while wisdom is learning from the mistakes of others. The Republic of Ireland is in the early stages of developing and implementing a network of marine protected areas (MPAs). The Fair Seas campaign has identified sixteen potential sites for MPAs to meet the 30 by 30 goal – 30% of land and sea protected by 2030. Their assessment is an impressive piece of work, with the areas chosen to maximise the conservation value based on the distributions of fifteen species of whales and dolphins, thirty-eight species of seabirds, sixteen species of sharks and rays, seven species of commercially caught fish, and eleven other species that act as indicators for particular habitats. The foreword to the assessment argues for a core of sites to be fully protected so that there is a reference against which protection, recovery, and management actions can be judged, and some sites where activities such as fishing would be allowed.
Turn the clock back to the early 2010s, when the UK first aimed to set up an ‘ecologically coherent and well-managed network’ of MPAs. Many organisations contributed data and expert opinion to a consultation, which resulted in a recommended network of over 100 sites. The government announced an initial phase that established 27 sites in English waters which, unsurprisingly, provoked a stream of criticism on the gap between plan and reality. Then came a second phase of 23 sites, and a third phase of 41 sites. Each phase greeted by disappointment from conservation organisations on the scale of provision, and criticism or concern from industry groups on their impact. The original plan was for some of these sites to be reference areas where all damaging activities were banned, sometimes called marine reserves or no-take zones. This was not implemented, due to a perception by those most affected by the higher protected status that they were being excluded from the process.
Marine protected areas have the potential for widespread benefits. Increasing ecological resilience through protecting areas means that these areas can better withstand the stresses and impacts placed upon them. In turn, they continue to provide benefits such as fisheries spillover, where fish within the areas breed and bolster the populations outside the site’s boundaries. The end result is coastal fisheries that are more productive and more sustainable. The Fair Seas assessment explicitly includes areas that are spawning and nursery grounds for both cod and herring. Clean and diverse seas can increase tourism and recreation, helping local economies and well-being. Depending on the site, they can also form part of a nature-based solution to tackling climate change by providing coastal protection or carbon capture.
In November 2018 there were “314 designated MPAs protecting 24% of UK waters compared to 217 sites covering 8% of UK waters in 2012”. This seems like good progress towards the 30 by 30 goal for the UK, but much depends on what we mean by ‘protected’, and how well that protection is enforced. In the UK MPAs are designated based on ‘features of conservation interest’ – FOCI – which are the species and habitats the area is designed to protect. Other activities like fishing and dredging are permitted within the area provided that they don’t affect the features under protection, or unless they’re restricted by some other regulation, for example, where bottom trawling in seagrass meadows is prohibited in some areas.
So is this really protection or is it simply a lesser form of exploitation? The British Ecological Society (BES) says that most protected areas are not delivering in terms of providing real protection. Oceana and Global Fishing Watch found that in 2019 97% of UK MPAs were either being dredged or subject to bottom trawling.
How can we say these areas are protected if we allow damaging activities to take place within them? They’re created based on particular features but it’s a system, not isolated features. It’s all very well to say that activity X is fine because it doesn’t directly affect that feature, but that doesn’t help if activity X still damages the species and habitats that connect with it, and on which those features may depend.
Humans of the middle stone age lived on Doggerland, a low-lying area of tundra and marsh between what is now France and England. The end of the last ice age saw this land bridge disappear beneath the sea. Dogger bank, an extensive area of shallow sandbanks, overlays what was Doggerland and is home to sandeels, a vital food source for many seabirds, as well as whales and dolphins. Cod feed on the sandeels and breed here, boosting the stock for commercial fishers to harvest. In 2020 Greenpeace dropped granite boulders into this area, publicising the precise location in an attempt to prevent bottom trawling. In June 2022 a new byelaw was introduced to ban bottom trawling in this particular MPA, crucially after extensive consultation with the fishing industry. Where restrictions are based on dialogue, they have a much higher prospect of being followed, but this is only one of four MPAs with new bye-laws to restrict trawling. Four, out of hundreds.
But the more activities we seek to restrict the more that brings us into conflict with others such as fishers for example. We may look at the ocean and see an open expanse of water, but there are many competing demands on ocean space. Pipelines and cables run along the seafloor, bringing gas and electricity ashore, distributing it within and between countries. Telecommunications links carry data streams to connect our world. Renewable energy stakes its claim – offshore wind above the waves and tidal energy below. Fishers, unlike farmers, don’t own the grounds their livelihoods depend on, and so there is a spatial squeeze, a potential displacement away from areas traditionally fished. A report by the National Federation of Fishermen’s Organisations (NFFO) and the Scottish Fisherman’s Federation (SFF) looked at this spatial squeeze, comparing past conditions in 2000 to the current situation (2020-21), and to three future scenarios, one in 2030 and two in 2050, each with different levels of restriction for fishing in protected areas. In what it calls the ‘future 3 (worst case)’ scenario bottom trawling is banned in all protected areas that were designated for seafloor species or habitats. But is this a ‘worst case’? Should this not be the baseline case, that where an area is selected to protect seafloor species and habitats, that all activities (like trawling) that damage them are banned? Otherwise, how can we honestly claim that we are protecting them?
This gives me some discomfort personally, perhaps leaving me open to a charge of hypocrisy since I do eat fish. My diet is a little strange in that it is mostly vegan but with occasional dairy, and some sustainably sourced fish. Mostly vegan to reduce climate change emissions, some dairy because I’m not going to expect my 89 year old father to have a supply of oat milk on hand for when I visit, and sustainable fish because it’s generally a low-carbon source of protein. When I shop I’ll start by looking for the Marine Stewardship Council logo and then filter options using the Marine Conservation Society’s Good Fish Guide for fishing method and area. There’s not always enough detail on the labelling to make a completely informed decision, but I do my best. Some of the most sustainable fishing tends to be done by the inshore boats under ten metres in length that historically have not received an equitable share of quota allocation, despite their sustainability. Part of the progress towards conserving biodiversity is the ending of subsidy for damaging activities and providing incentives to the sustainable ones. Correcting the quota inequity for these inshore boats fishing sustainably would be a positive step as part of that.
The spatial squeeze on fishing grounds is likely to come from two main sources: nature conservation and renewable energy developments, yet both are of vital significance to the wider population. The 30 by 30 target is critical if we are to tackle the twin threats of climate change and biodiversity loss, but it becomes a self-delusion unless we are actually protecting those areas we count towards it. The BES report found that some land-based areas were being counted despite them not originally being created for biodiversity (e.g. Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty), and despite them not delivering in terms of protecting biodiversity. Unless these areas meaningfully contribute to nature recovery, to providing benefits for both people and nature, then it becomes nothing more than governmental greenwashing to count these towards the 30 by 30 target. They become yet another policy initiative, loudly announced then left to wither for lack of political will or funding; a shield to hide behind when accountability for the lack of any real progress is sought.
Callum Roberts, professor of marine conservation at the University of Exeter, has criticised the lack of real protection, calling areas that are not effectively protected or managed ‘paper parks’. He does, however, sound a note of caution: if we set targets for the quality as well as the quantity of protection then we risk losing the consensus to provide that protection if those targets are set too high. But that simply brings us back to our original question: what value are protected areas if they are not protected in practice?
Another issue is that the 30 by 30 goal doesn’t apply to the high seas – the area that covers nearly half the ocean surface, areas outside national jurisdiction. That’s a lot of ocean where damage can still be done, a spatial loophole for exploitation to continue, if agreement can’t be reached at the UN’s Intergovernmental Conference on Marine Biodiversity of Areas Beyond National Jurisdiction in New York in August 2022.
Language matters. It can determine the boundaries of debate; it can illuminate or deceive. The words chosen to describe something affects how we perceive it. The UK Government is running a consultation (July 2022) to select pilot areas for Highly Protected Marine Areas – HPMAs – with the first HPMAs planned for 2023. There are five pilot sites, two inshore and three offshore, with activities such as construction, dredging, and fishing banned within the boundaries, and the Government saying these areas “will have the highest level of protection in our seas.” So here ‘highly protected’ means actually protecting an area, while areas that are merely ‘protected’ are still open to damaging activities. The language distorts the reality, and we continue to reassure ourselves that we are doing more than we are.
Properly protecting areas means a spatial squeeze on fishing, and fishing effort must go somewhere. If it is displaced to other areas then these will be fished harder unless the beneficial effects of MPAs are enough to compensate, and there is a time lag between the application of protection and the benefits of it. The only other possibility is that the capacity of the industry reduces, and that’s not something that should be taken lightly – these are people’s livelihoods, people’s lives. Fishing is not a job description, it’s wrapped together with identity. It’s family history – fathers, brothers, uncles fishing before them. It’s communities, with a shared history, and sometimes encompasses a shared experience of tragedy. Fishing is a dangerous occupation. But not reducing capacity, should it be needed, just means that fishing communities suffer the more severe effects resulting from climate change and biodiversity loss alongside everyone else. No one wins.
There is still a case for areas to have different levels of protection. One size does not fit all and a diversity of approach is beneficial, but the default MPA should be a fully protected one. Protection should mean real protection. We gain nothing if we think that the lines on a map have meaning without the enforcement to achieve the basis for which they were created. We can truly protect areas and receive the benefits they provide, or we can continue to delude ourselves that we are doing something, thinking that we are making progress against the threats we face, until the damage is done, and it is too late. The Republic of Ireland is standing at a point of divergence, two path of marine conservation before it: protection in name, or protection in practice. Let us hope it chooses the path less travelled.












